As weโve reported over and over again, the popular and successful Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) and other regional climate agreements are under attack from polluters. Today, a bombshell report by Bloomberg News makes it undeniably clear who is leading the attack, and paints an ugly picture of collusion, influence, and state legislators deep in the pocket of the fossil fuelย industry.ย
Bloomberg reporter Alison Fitzpatrickย writes:
The process seems to work, at least to some degree. Within the past year, legistators in at least eight states have introduced provisions to leave their respective emissions reduction pacts. David Anderson, who writes the New Hampshire Primary 2012: Green blog about climate change and the 2012 election, first spotted the template. After doing some heroic digging, he found that in at least six of these states, the legislation introduced was literally copied-and-pasted from the template provided by ALEC. These states are Michigan, Montana, New Mexico, Oregon, Washington (all PDFs), and New Hampshire.
Anderson first spotted the language in the โfindingsโ section of the New Hampshire bill. As he told Living on Earth: โIt says โwhereas there has been no credible economic analysis of the increasing cost of doing business in the state of,โ and then thereโs a blank, so, in this case, they inserted the words, New Hampshire.โ
When the bill was discussed in committee, Anderson reported this incredible exchange:
The billโs lead sponsor, state Rep. Richard Barry (R), looked a bit like a dog caught with the family cat in its mouth when he was asked to explain the language at a public hearing; he nervously said that none of the billโs sponsors had written this particular section, but stopped short of revealing ALEC as the source of the text. That didnโt sit well with Rep. James Garrity (R), chair of the House Science, Technology, and Energy Committee, who later explained, โOur committee does not feel that editorials belong in laws.โ The matter was resolved by dropping the ALEC text, and theย amended billย went on to pass theย House.
Fitzpatrick reports that ALECโs โmodel bills, which now total almost 1,000, are listed on its website, although their full texts can be called up only by members.โ But the Center for Media and Democracy actually acquired the full texts of over 800 of the bills earlier this month, and posted them at ALECexposed.org.
ALEC has received at least $124,000 from the Exxon Mobil Foundation in dues and sponsorships, but that figure doesnโt include direct grants or gifts from the corporation itself. Greenpeace reveals that the Council has also received at least $408,000 from the Charles Koch Charitable Foundation since 1997.
This isnโt, of course, the first time weโve seen Koch money directly influencing regional climate pacts.
Last month, Governor Chris Christie pulled New Jersey out of RGGI, stripping the ten state agreement of one of its key cornerstone partners. Next door in New York,ย Americans for Prosperity,ย a group whoseย ties to the Koch brothersย are well established,ย sued the state for its continued commitment to RGGI.
Despite widespread public support in the Garden State, Christie, who doesnโt deny that humans are causing global warming, claimed that RGGI was โa failure and an ineffective approach to reducing greenhouse gas emissions.โ This claim has been widely and summarily dismissed by scores of economists, environmentalists, and five governors who remain fully committed to RGGI. โGovernor Christie is simply wrong when he claims that these efforts are a failure,โ said Maryland Governor Martin OโMalley.
Americans for Prosperityย celebrated Christieโs decision, even taking direct credit for it in a public press release: Americans for Prosperity Declares Victory over RGGI Cap & Trade!
The New Jersey chapter of AFP spent roughly $200,000 in the state on advertisements and other public efforts to fight RGGI, and plenty of analysts assume that Christieโs announcement was made to appease the notorious Tea Party funders as he sets his sights on a prospective White House run in 2012.
But while the New Jersey campaign was done in broad daylight, this Bloomberg News bombshell makes clear that Koch-funded organizations are still spearheading shadowy attempts to help states cut and run from their regional climate commitments.
With the prospects for nationwide carbon pricing at a ten-year low, regional agreements like RGGI, the Western Climate Initiative, and the Midwestern Greenhouse Gas Accord seem to hold the best hope for creating a carbon market and generating revenue to fund clean energy and energy efficiency projects. For this reason, no doubt, polluting interests like Koch Industries are sharpening their swords, and their legislation drafting pencils.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Stay up to date with DeSmog news and alerts