Dr. Tim Ball: The Lie that Just Won't Die

authordefault
on

The deathless and – in many specific respects – completely fictional meanderings of Dr. Tim Ball have begun appearing again on right-wing blogs all over the net. At City Troll, at Convenient Untruth and at New Orleans Lady, the same tired and retreaded old climate rant paints Dr. Ball as the courageous victim of a plot to silence a well-meaningย skeptic.

But Ball canโ€™t even tell the truth about his own resume. His claim to be the first Climatology Ph.D. in Canada is a total falsehood; his degree was in historical geography – not climatology – and it was nowhere near the first ever granted to someone writing vaguely in the field.ย  It also was granted by the university as a doctor of philosophy, not the more prestigious โ€œdoctor of scienceโ€ that Ball claims in theseย articles.

UPDATE: to make matters worse, it looks like Ballโ€™s โ€œglobal warming is good for usโ€ message is running front page in the right-wing uber site, The Drudgeย Report.

He claims as well to have been a professor (again of climatology) at the University of Winnipeg for 32 years, while he confirmed in his own Statement of Claim in a pending lawsuit (look here ) that he was a professor (of geography, never climatology) for just eightย years.

Dr. Ball claims never to have been paid by oil and gas interests, but if you look here , youโ€™ll find a Globe and Mail story in which Dr. Barry Cooper, the man behind Ballโ€™s former industry front group, the Friends of Science , offers this clumsy admission: โ€œ[The moneyโ€™s] not exclusively from the oil and gas industry,โ€ says Prof. Cooper. โ€œItโ€™s also from foundations and individuals. I canโ€™t tell you the names of those companies, or the foundations for that matter, or theย individuals.โ€

Here youโ€™ll find a podcast of Dr. Ball talking to the Ottawa Citizen , saying that he goes out of his way to ignore who might be paying his bills, but crediting the energy industry lobby firm, the High Park Group . And here, youโ€™ll find High Park Group veteran Tom Harris, telling the Toronto Star that his new industry front group, the Natural Resources Stewardship Project , was created at the suggestion of High Park Group president Timothyย Egan.

Tom Harris, executive director of the NRSP, is credited by New Orleans Lady for passing along this version of the Ball tirade, also printed Monday on the right-wingy website, Canada Free Press. Yet all of these factual inconsistencies have been brought to Harrisโ€™s attention on previousย occasions.

It is inevitable that this post will be criticized as an ad hominem attack on dear Dr. Ball (and perhaps on Harris, as well). But how can you argue science with someone who doesnโ€™t feel bound by the limits ofย truth?

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has just endured an unprecedented process of vetting and peer-review to produce a document, the veracity of which has been double-checked and endorsed by thousands of the best scientists in the world. It must be soul-destroying to see a long-retired geographer who rarely published during his colourless academic career and who never conducted any research in atmospheric science dismiss that effort without a shred of evidence or a hint of goodย conscience.

Related Posts

on

At the Heartland Instituteโ€™s annual climate conference, fossil fuel allies warn MAHAโ€™s push on regulating chemicals and plastics could threaten the oil industry โ€” exposing a growing rift inside Trumpโ€™s base.

At the Heartland Instituteโ€™s annual climate conference, fossil fuel allies warn MAHAโ€™s push on regulating chemicals and plastics could threaten the oil industry โ€” exposing a growing rift inside Trumpโ€™s base.
on

Experts say mass-produced AI misinformation is the โ€œnew Cambridge Analytica scandalโ€.

Experts say mass-produced AI misinformation is the โ€œnew Cambridge Analytica scandalโ€.
on

The think tank representatives are making variations of a similar argument: Trumpโ€™s illegal military incursions serve as an opportunity for Canada to expand oil and gas infrastructure.

The think tank representatives are making variations of a similar argument: Trumpโ€™s illegal military incursions serve as an opportunity for Canada to expand oil and gas infrastructure.
Analysis
on

Belief in climate change is rising, but action stalls. New research reveals how subtle narratives are slowing policy โ€“ and how to fight back.

Belief in climate change is rising, but action stalls. New research reveals how subtle narratives are slowing policy โ€“ and how to fight back.