Background
Wageningen University & Research (WUR) is a Netherlands-based research center. WUR is a collaboration between Wageningen University, a Dutch public university, and the Wageningen Research Foundation, and is made up of the university and nine research institutes.1โAbout Wageningen University and Research,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/U7wi3 2โManagement & Organisation,โ Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 16, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/GEMKD
Wageningen University is a publicly funded institution, while Wageningen University & Research is registered as a privately funded company.
According to its website, WURโs mission is โto explore the potential of nature to improve the quality of life,” and its โstrengthโ is โits ability to join the forces of specialised research institutes and the university.โ3โAbout Wageningen University and Research,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/U7wi3
WUR writes that its research institutes, which include livestock, plant, environmental, and economics research, are โcommissioned by the government, commercial businesses and non-profit organisations.โ4โResearch Institutes,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/uSJKZ
WUR has been criticized by its own students and academics for the organizationโs connections to the agribusiness and fossil fuel industries, for producing research and impact assessments that appear to align with industry interests, and for a lack of transparency by WUR staff about their work for companies like Bayer.5Brigitte W.. โFossil Fuelลed WUR,” The Jester, June 10, 2022. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ZJndO
The organization justifies its collaboration with โbusinesses, governments and civic organisationsโ by writing that โresearch results only have an impact once they find their way into practical application in society.โ6โValue Creation & Cooperation,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/yKEJp
Questions Over Impartiality of Research and Teaching
Students and faculty at Wageningen University & Research, as well as news outlets and civil society organizations, have raised concerns that corporate ties could influence research and teaching at the university.
According to a list of WUR professors published in July 2022, Unilever has funded four professorships at WUR, BASF has also funded a professorship, and Shell has funded a professorship in โEnvironmental Health and Human Biomonitoring of Contaminants.โ7โProfessors of Wageningen University โ July 2022,โ Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
BASFโs funding is not listed on the November 2022 list of WUR professors.8โProfessors of Wageningen University โ November 2022,โ Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 19, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
In 2020, investigative journalism outlet Zembla reported that a WUR professor of immunology, Huub Savelkoul, had publicly misrepresented the findings of a research project that he himself had helped conduct. While the study found immunological benefits to feeding chickens organically, Savelkoul wrote an article for an academic journal claiming the reverse. His article may have contributed to the governmentโs decision not to fund follow-up studies, Zembla reported.9โConclusies belangrijk onderzoek naar biologisch eten afgezwakt onder druk van onderzoeksinstituut TNO,โ Zembla, October 22, 2020. Archived October 27, 2021. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/Ni7S8
Lead researcher Machteld Huber told Zembla that the studyโs findings did not support Savelkoulโs conclusions. According to Huber, Savelkoul said later that โit doesnโt fit my scientific image that organically-fed chicken is healthier.โ Savelkoul denied Huberโs version of events to Zembla, and had stated in the academic article that the chickens had developed a โhyperactive immune system.โ10โConclusies belangrijk onderzoek naar biologisch eten afgezwakt onder druk van onderzoeksinstituut TNO,โ Zembla, October 22, 2020. Archived October 27, 2021. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/Ni7S8
A December 2020 WUR report examining โthe role that WUR can play in fostering transformative social-environmental changeโ stated:11โ71 Visions on our role in social-environmental transformative change,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
โDivergent perspectives were expressed around WUR funding flows, often related to tensions around whether it is ok to view research as a โserviceโ. Many researchers felt this โimpedes us from having a counter-narrative to โour clientsโ or challenging them in their thinkingโ. The research institutes (WR) were perceived as vulnerable to research that โdelivers what the client wants to have or wants to hear.โโ
According to the report, researchers raised dilemmas โaround the role of the private sector on campus that donโt have the best environmental reputation internationally.โ One employee was quoted regarding teaching practices: โThe more radical examples, we donโt do much on. We are paid by the big companiesโฆ we put plasters on the wounds.โ
The report also stated: โYet many researchers also pointed to benefits of โfacilitating partnerships with the bigger players’: โCompanies are realizing how dependent they are on this system, they realize resilience is needed, but they donโt know how to build itโฆ.We need to partner more with these sort of people.โโ12โ71 Visions on our role in social-environmental transformative change,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
WUR has defended receiving funds from companies for teaching and research activities in which they have a vested interest. In an interview published on the WUR website, Sebastiaan Berendse, WURโs director of โcorporate value creation,โ stated:13โโWe need companies in order to make an impact in practiceโ,” Wageningen University and Research, June 22, 2021. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/HmUqd
โThe scientific integrity of our research is regularly reviewed and the institutes are externally evaluated for quality. All the research financed by public money is public and accessible to everyone. And the government remains the most important financer of WUR research: 4% of the research done at the university is financed by companies. This is 15% at Wageningen Research, and the government has specifically instructed us to raise that percentage…โ
Berendse added that WUR does not โwork with parties who are damaging to public health, such as the tobacco industry or the weapons industry.โ
When asked specifically about calls by students for the university to stop working with chemical companies, Berendse replied:14โโWe need companies in order to make an impact in practiceโ,” Wageningen University and Research, June 22, 2021. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/HmUqd
โI think itโs unwise to exclude [chemical companies] a priori since that means that you no longer have any influence. Itโs better to have them be an active part of your research so you can discover how the ecological influence of, for example, pesticides can be reducedโฆUnfortunately, pesticides are still necessary if we want to feed the world. Thatโs the difficulty of our domain: there are no easy solutions. On the one hand, the solution seems to be to stop using the pesticides but, on the other hand, this endangers the food supply or food safety.โ
Scientists and civil society organizations have questioned claims that pesticides are necessary to meet global food needs.15Damian Carrington. โUN experts denounce ‘myth’ pesticides are necessary to feed the world,” The Guardian, March 7, 2017. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ZP5yl
A 2019 report published on the WUR website, titled โAchieving responsibility at Wageningen University & Research,โ stated that the universityโs integrity code โdoes not mention how to deal with those tensionsโ around public-private partnerships.16โAchieving responsibility at Wageningen University & Research,” Wageningen University and Research, 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive .pdf on file at DeSmog.
In 2016, Follow the Money wrote that WUR was โincreasingly becoming a subsidized research laboratory for large food multinationals.โ17โWageningen wordt een verlengstuk van de voedingsindustrie,” Follow the Money, October 15, 2016. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/8CAvS
Stance on Climate Change
WUR writes on its website that climate change is โone of the biggest challenges of our time,โ and that the organization โexplores the impacts on society and ecosystems, and develop [sic] evidence-based, integrated solutions and technology.โ18โClimate change,โ Wageningen University & Research. Archived August 19, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/FK68v
WUR also states that it โdifferentiatesโ itself from โother parties which offer climate solutionsโ by focusing on โnature-based solutionsโ to climate change, which it says are โworking with โ rather than against โ long-term natural processes.โ19โClimate Change,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/FK68v
The Wageningen Climate Solutions magazine, a digital publication that โfeatures background stories about the research being done at [WUR],โ highlights climate โsolutionsโ including โtinkering with the plantโs engineโ โ meaning genetic modification or specialized plant breeding of food crops20Marion de Boo. โTinkering with the plantโs engine,โ Wageningen Climate Solutions, September 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/sgUsk โ โthe climate friendly cow,โ21Albert Sikkema. โThe climate-friendly cow,โ Wageningen Climate Solutions, September 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/cLs5y and โclimate-smart agriculture.โ22Hanny Roskamp. โHow climate-smart agriculture makes farmers resilient,โ Wageningen Climate Solutions, September 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/PXoDV
Links to Fossil Fuel Industry
In June 2022, WURโs student newspaper, The Jester, published a story about the university’s ties to the fossil fuel industry.23Brigitte W., โFossil Fuelลed WUR,โ The Jester, June 10, 2022. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ZJndO The Jester reported that Shell had sponsored Dr. Peter Boogaardโs position as professor of toxicology, which was confirmed in the universityโs 2022 published list of professors. Louise Fresco, who was president of WURโs executive board from 2014 to July 2022, was a trustee of the Shell Foundation for three years before joining WURโs board.24Press Release. โWUR bids Louise O. Fresco farewell after an eight-year tenure,โ Wagnerian University and Research, June 1, 2022. Archived December 19, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wip/u3Hbg
The article documented multiple collaborative research projects between WUR and fossil fuel industry members on topics including bioplastics, biofuels, and water management. A project that investigated the impacts of petroleum developments on marine ecosystems listed Equinor, Shell, Eni, ConocoPhillips, ExxonMobil, and BP as the projectโs clients.25Brigitte W., โFossil Fuelลed WUR,โ The Jester, June 10, 2022. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ZJndO
Impact Assessments of EU Farm to Fork Strategy
In 2021, COPA-COGECA and CropLife Europe commissioned WUR to conduct two impact assessments of the EU Farm to Fork Strategy. Other agricultural industry trade groups such as Euroseeds and Fertilizers Europe also contributed funding for the studies.26โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
One of the studies included modeling based on the EUโs targets to reduce the use of agrichemicals, including pesticides, and the percentage of land that would be left to nature. This assessment predicted an average 10-20 percent drop in food production. Its key recommendation was โremoving legislative barriers to new breeding techniques,โ referring to gene editing of crop species.27Johan Bremmer, Ana Gonzalez-Martinez, Roel Jongeneel, Hilfred Huiting, Rob Stokkers, Marc Ruijs, โImpact Assessment of EC 2030 Green Deal Targets for Sustainable Crop Production,โ Wageningen University and Research, December 2021. Archived December 14, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
WUR published the findings of this impact assessment in October 2021, a week before MEPs voted on Farm to Fork, according to reporting from campaign group Corporate Europe Observatory (CEO). WUR published the full study in January 2022.28โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
The methodology and findings of this WUR impact assessment have been criticized by other scientists, and one author of the report highlighted its limitations.29โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
The study did not include any modeling for simultaneous changes in the food system such as dietary change, future innovation,30โFactsheet: Green Deal targets for 2030 and agricultural production studies,โ European Commission, February 2022. Archived October 5, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog. or changes in the global food system.31Magdalena Pistorius, โFarm to Fork studies do not give โwhole pictureโ, agri stakeholders warn,โ Euractiv, October 29, 2021. Archived December 14, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ibXPF The study also did not consider the potentially positive impacts if EU pesticide reduction targets were met,32Magdalena Pistorius, โFarm to Fork studies do not give โwhole pictureโ, agri stakeholders warn,โ Euractiv, October 29, 2021. Archived December 14, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ibXPF or the potential consequences of no action being taken to transform Europeโs food production.33โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
Lobby watchdog Corporate Europe Observatory asked why expected environmental benefits of the Farm to Fork strategy had not been included. WUR stated that doing a full impact assessment was โunfortunately beyond the scope of the projectโ and that โpartial assignments are part and parcel of WURโs work, specific areas, such as economic impact are investigated this time, environmental impacts the next.โ
Corporate Europe Observatory also asked WUR whether its impact assessment was being used in an industry lobbying campaign against Farm to Fork, to which WUR responded: โWe execute projects commissioned by a client in a scientific correct [sic] and transparent way.โ34โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
The impact assessmentโs preface states that representatives from CropLife Europe and CropLife International โguidedโ and โsupervisedโ the study.35Johan Bremmer, Ana Gonzalez-Martinez, Roel Jongeneel, Hilfred Huiting, Rob Stokkers, Marc Ruijs. โImpact Assessment of EC 2030 Green Deal Targets for Sustainable Crop Production,โ Wageningen University and Research, December 2021. Archived December 14, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Corporate Europe Observatory also cataloged industry-sponsored events and articles that shared the WUR findings, and reported on a leaked communication strategy from Copa-Cogeca which planned to โamplifyโ the research.36โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.,โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
In response to questions from CEO, WUR said: โThe way our customers use the results in lobbying for their interest is beyond the boundaries of our influence.โ
However, CEO reported that Wageningen researchers โpresented the studies as key speakers in various industry-led lobby events.โ When asked by CEO โwhether their participation to lobby events was an obligatory part of the CropLife Europe job, the answer from WUR was no.โ WUR added that it is โcustomary for our researchers to present their results for the organizations that have commissioned the research.โ37โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
Jeroen Candel, an associate professor of food and agricultural policy at WUR, criticized the research, writing on Twitter that the framing and headline of the research were โhighly unfortunate,โ and that although the reportโs researchers โacknowledge that the benefits of climate and biodiversity have not been included, that is precisely what the entire [Farm to Fork] strategy is intended for.โ Candel added that because the research was framed around whether or not Farm to Fork would impact agricultural yields, it was โnot surprising that such studies are used as ammunition against the F2F by status quo forces.โ38โFraming van het onderzoek, ook in de kop, is daarmee hoogst ongelukkig. Onderzoekers erkennen weliswaar dat voordelen klimaat en biodiversiteit niet zijn meegenomen, maar daar is die hele strategie nu juist voor bedoeld.,โ tweet from user @JeroenCandel, October 12, 2021. Retrieved from twitter.com. Archived October 18, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/7svOI
The second study conducted by Wageningen on Farm to Fork was funded by Copa-Cogeca, farm animal breeders lobby EFFAB, Animal Health Europe, poultry lobby group AVEC, feed manufacturers lobby FEFAC, and dairy lobby EDA โ all members of European Livestock Voice.
The study modeled the possible impacts of Farm to Fork on livestock farmersโ income, finding that the Green Deal objectives could reduce livestock production by 10 to 15 percent. However, the report also found that almost half of farmers could see an increase in income.39Roel Jongeneel, Huib Silvis, Ana Gonzalez Martinez, Jakob Jager, โImpact of the EUโs Green Deal on the livestock sector: Executive Summary,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Like the first WUR impact assessment, the report did not examine ecological advantages that could result from the policy.40Albert Sekkema. โFarm to Fork strategy decreases agricultural production in Europe,โ Resource, October 13, 2021. Archived October 25, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/B0sII
Albert Sekkema, a co-author of the livestock report, commented that, โCropLife was interested in the impact at the sector level, while Copa-Cogeca was particularly interested in the effects [of F2F] on farmersโ incomes.โ He added: โIf we conclude that this policy could benefit the financial position of half of the livestock farmers, I donโt know whether Copa-Cogeca is happy with such a conclusion. The results may be more positive than they expected.โ41Albert Sekkema. โFarm to Fork strategy decreases agricultural production in Europe,โ Resource, October 13, 2021. Archived October 25, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/B0sII
Links to Agribusiness Industry
Wageningen University & Research has substantial links to the agribusiness industry, particularly with agrichemical companies Bayer and Syngenta, as well as consumer goods company Unilever, and livestock industry trade groups including the European Roundtable for Beef Sustainability.
WUR is one of three universities responsible for coordinating the Sustainability Consortium, a nonprofit organization that has โdeveloped a globally harmonised measurement and reporting system that allows companies to monitor the sustainability of consumer products supply chains.โ42โThe Sustainability Consortium: achieving sustainability together with supply chain partners,โ Wageningen University & Research. Archived May 25, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/C3sLM Members of the Sustainability Consortium include agrichemical companies Bayer, Corteva, BASF, and Syngenta, chemical company ExxonMobil Chemical, major food suppliers including Walmart, Unilever, and Pepsico, and NGOs including the Nature Conservancy, World Resources Institute, and WWF.43โOur Members,โ The Sustainability Consortium. Archived November 7, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/esNm7
Wageningen University & Research has working relationships with a number of major agrochemical companies, particularly Bayer, Syngenta, and BASF. WUR also carries out research for agribusiness trade groups, including Euroseeds.
In 2020, the Dutch investigative journalism outlet Follow the Money reported that at least 16 projects carried out by WUR in โrecent yearsโ had involved Bayer or Syngenta as collaborators. This included WURโs research into neonicotinoids and bee deaths, which was conducted collaboratively with Bayer โ a major producer of neonicotinoids.44Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,” Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM
Follow the Money also reported that between 2008 and 2012, Bayer and Syngenta funded a WUR chair of โchemical stress ecology and ecotoxicology.โ45Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,” Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM
In 2018, Dutch journalism outlet OneWorld went to court to attempt to access correspondence between Wageningen University & Research and Bayer, Syngenta, and Monsanto regarding WUR research on neonicotinoids and other pesticides.46Vincent Harmsen. โONEWORLD NAAR RECHTER OM GEHEIME CONTACTEN WAGENINGEN UNIVERSITEIT EN BAYER,โ OneWorld, June 25, 2018. Archived July 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/ASww4 WUR told OneWorldthat it did not need to comply with the Netherlandsโ Government Information Act โ in Dutch, the Wet openbaarheid van bestuur โ or supply the documents, because its research institutes are private companies rather than government entities.
Bayer and Syngenta have been listed among the โpartnersโ of WUR research involving โon-site detection of plant pathogens,โ47โOn-site detection of plant pathogens,โ Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/v5iuy the development of cultivation systems to โhelp outdoor cultivators become less dependent on chemical crop protections,โ48โ‘PPS GROEN’: Public-Private Partnership project ‘Gewasbescherming Robuust Optimaal En Natuurlijk’,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/59e0Q and investigation of โswitching on relevant genesโ to โenhanceโ plantsโ โrecognition of harmful insect eggs.โ49โHow do plants identify the harmful insect egg?,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/s5Nf6
Both the private research arm Wageningen Research Foundation โ in Dutch, Stichting Wageningen Research โ and the public university arm are listed as โmain collaboration partnersโ of seed association Euroseeds on the EU Funding & Tenders portal.50โEuroseeds,โ European Commission Funding and Tender Opportunities. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/AoqkX
Several global food companies, such as Unilever, Upfield, and FrieslandCampina, also maintain research facilities on the WUR campus.51Het Onderzoekslab. โHoe Wageningen University & Research in de tang van het bedrijfsleven zit,โ VN, December 23, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/Ejn0B
Students have criticized the presence of these companies on campus.52โConditional prison sentence for WUR student activists,” The Jester, December 14, 2021. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/Nlzlg
WUR has defended its close collaboration with agribusiness companies on its website:53โโWe need companies in order to make an impact in practiceโ,โ Wageningen University and Research, June 22, 2021. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/HmUqd
โYou need the business community to translate WURโs knowledge into practice. [โฆ] Companies look for answers to scientific questions that they canโt answer themselves. Then itโs indeed very handy if youโre situated close to each other. But this doesnโt mean that the companies located here are โfinancing WURโ or determining WURโs agenda.โ
Links with Syngenta
WUR has considerable links to Swiss agrichemical company Syngenta. Both Syngenta and the Syngenta Foundation name WUR as a research and development partner on their websites.54โResearch and development,โ Syngenta. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/7T4uM 55โSyngenta Foundation Partners,โ Syngenta. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/mvkEu
In 2019, Louise O. Fresco, the president of the WUR executive board from 2014 to 2022, became a member of the Syngenta board of directors in 2019.56โSyngenta adds new Director to the Board,โ Syngenta, April 15, 2019. Archived September 12, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/v0KjC
Fresco was criticized by multiple faculty members within the university. WUR soil biology researcher Thom Kuijper said: โYou are combining positions that canโt be reconciled. In the academic community there is a lot of discussion about the role of companies such as Syngenta in making agriculture sustainable. That community needs to be certain of the freedom to develop a diverse range of views.โ
Fresco defended her appointment, saying: โI am not part of Syngenta. I advise Syngenta.โ57โFrescoโs Syngenta board position controversial,” Resource โ WUR from within, June 6, 2019. Archived December 17, 2017. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/KuxUr
Links with Bayer
Bayer funded at least one Ph.D. program at WUR in the 2020-2021 academic year.58โFunding University Research,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/KQjF1
In 2021, WUR organized a symposium titled โWhen Wizards meet Prophetsโ that aimed to โbring togetherโ the two โpolarizedโ camps in agriculture, featuring representatives from Greenpeace, BASF, and Bayer, researchers from WUR, WURโs then-board president Louise O. Fresco, and the Louis Bolk Institute.59โWizards and Prophets meet each other,” Wageningen University and Research, May 20, 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/1KOK9
In a post about the event, WUR wrote that โIt’s time to put a stop to polarisation in the agriculture debate.โ
The post continued:60โWizards and Prophets meet each other,” Wageningen University and Research, May 20, 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/1KOK9
โWe feel that the solutions for a truly sustainable food system will not be found solely in one camp or the other. And all the arguing is getting in the way of any genuine action. Weโre not going to win this โwarโ by fighting over genetic modification, or about whether to eat organically, or to cut out meat.โ
Bayer and WUR are partners on a number of agricultural projects, including research to make vertical farming more energy-efficient,61โSky High – Plant flats with LEDs,โ Wageningen University & Research, November 7, 2019. Archived May 14, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/na4iK designing technology to โre-designโ and increase the efficiency of photosynthesis,62โConsortium,โ Wageningen University & Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/pxlVo 63โPhotosynthesis, the green engine of life on Earth,โ Wageningen University & Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/4YQLS and using sensors to track and improve the quality of perishable food in the supply chain.64โFuture sensors and digital twins to improve perishable food quality,โ Wageningen University & Research, November 2, 2021. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/NE2YY
Bayer is one of 26 partners of a WUR program called AGROS โ โEvolution to sustainable AGRicultural Operation Systemsโ โ which is โdeveloping agrotechnologies to support ecological and biological processes in the greenhouse horticulture, arable farming and dairy industries.โ According to WUR, the main goal of the program is โto develop tools that can steer production towards more efficiency in the deployment of energy, water, plant protection products and labour.โ65โAGROS programme launched: businesses work with WUR to optimise agroecology with technology,โ Wageningen University & Research, May 26, 2020. Archived May 25, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/oacnf
Neonicotinoid Report Controversy
According to 2020 reporting by Dutch investigative journalism outlet Follow the Money, in 2011 Henk Bleker, then the Dutch State Secretary for Economic Affairs, Agriculture and Innovation, asked Wageningen University & Research to draw up independent advice for the Dutch House of Representatives on neonicotinoids and their impact on bee mortality rates.66Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,โ Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM Follow the Money reported that a literature review of neonicotinoid studies led by a WUR researcher, โPlant Researchers Ph.D.โ Tjeerd Blacquiรจre, found that โthe advent of neonics has not created an ‘unacceptable risk’ for bees,โ instead naming a parasite called the Varroa mite as the primary cause of bee die-offs.
Follow the Money reported that Blacquiereโs conclusion was disputed โbehind the scenesโ by two Utrecht University scientists: Jereon Van der Sluijs and Marie Josรฉ Duchateau. Van der Sluijs told Follow the Money that the review had missed 14 key studies and relied on โmethodically incorrectly designed field trials by…Bayer Cropscience.โ Despite writing a letter to Bleker, their criticisms were omitted from the advice given to the Dutch House of Representatives, โdespite the explicit promise of State Secretary Henk Bleker that they would be involved in the preparation of the report,โ according to Follow the Money.67Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,โ Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM
Follow the Money also examined additional links between WUR and Bayer, finding that WURโs Bee Institute had been โworking together with the German pesticide manufacturer Bayer for many years,โ including โhelp[ing] Bayer with the marketing authorization of neonicotinoids.โ
Follow the Money added that WURโs Bee Institute was โconducting research within the chemical company’s Bee Care program,โ and that the university โdoes not want to disclose the exact financial ties between Bayer and the bee institute.โ
One WUR researcher, Professor of Nature Conservation and Plant Ecology Frank Berendse,68โโPlant roots exhibit starling behaviourโ, Farewell lecture of prof. Frank Berendse,โ Wageningen University & Research, April 1, 2016. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/FhZqk told Follow the Money that WUR should have โmuch more activelyโ investigated the ecological damage caused by neonicotinoids, and that he had โraised this internally [with WUR] six years ago.โ69Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,โ Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM
Berendse also told Follow the Money that he had contacted ecotoxicologists from WURโs environmental research institute Alterra, who told Berendse โthey could not research the harmfulness of neonicotinoids to bees because there was no interest in that from the business community or the government.โ Alterra has since been renamed the Wageningen Environmental Research, and is a part of WUR.
Blacquiรจreโs assessment was later cited on the Bayer website as evidence for the safety of neonicotinoids, and an interview with Blacquiรจre was featured in Bayerโs annual magazine for its Bee Care program. According to Follow the Money, upon being asked about his role in the โPR for a pesticide giant,โ Blacquiรจre said that WUR is โnot a universityโ and that the organization โwork[s] as a company for assignments.โ70Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,โ Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM
In 2012, Dutch magazine Zjik questioned the impartiality of neonicotinoid research conducted by Wageningen Professor of Chemical Stress Ecology Paul Van den Brink, whose professorship was partly funded by Syngenta and Bayer:
โVan den Brink developed a method for estimating the risks of pesticides in surface water. ‘The industry has made good use of his method in stretching the standards for neonicotinoids,’ says [Utrecht University researcher] Van der Sluijs. In 2011, ecotoxicologists from the University of Leipzig published an article in which they argued that the method developed by the Wageningen professor fails and that harmful effects have already been observed at concentrations a thousand times lower.โ
Van den Brink defended his research, stating that his academic independence was not in question.71Tomas Vanheste. โDode bij, stille lente; Gif op de bloemen,” Vrij Nederlands, December 1, 2021. Archived June 26, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
According to Follow the Money, former WUR executive board president (2002-2014) Aalt Dijkhuizen was also a โsupervisory directorโ at Incotec, a Enkhuizen, Netherlands-based company that โsells seed coated with neonicotinoid.โ72Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,” Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM Dijkhuizen was a member of the Incotec supervisory board from 2004-2015, according to his LinkedIn.73โAalt Dijkhuizen,โ LinkedIn. Archived December 19, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
In 2012, Vrij published an article on agrichemical industry influence of WUR research into neonicotinoids. Vrij reported that Syngenta, Bayer, and Alterra โ an environmental research institute affiliated with Wageningen since renamed Wageningen Environmental Research โ had co-financed Paul van den Brinkโs WUR professorship.74Tomas Vanheste. โDode bij, stille lente; Gif op de bloemen,โ Vrij Nederlands, December 1, 2021. Archived June 26, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
Links with BASF
In 2013, the environmental campaign group Pesticide Action Network Europe (PAN) criticized WUR for giving a professorship to Bernhard van Ravenzwaay, an employee of agrochemical company BASF.75โTHE SILENT TAKEOVER: Dutch Wageningen University moves on to sell their independence to industry,โ Pesticide Action Network Europe, May 3, 2013. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/JmAus PAN Europe alleged that the professorship was given in exchange for BASF funding. PAN commented: โSince he joined BASF, Mr. Van Ravenzwaay has a track record of studies published with a favorable outcome for industry.โ As of 2022, Ravenzwaay still held this position at WUR.
Links with Unilever
Unilever funded three Ph.D. programs at WUR in the 2020-2021 academic year.76โFunding university research,โ Wageningen University & Research. Archived December 16, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/KQjF1
In December 2020, Dutch magazine VN published an article about WURโs close relationship with the โbusiness world,โ and detailed in particular its relationship with Unilever.
VN reported that WURโs former president, Louise Fresco, had been a board member of Unilever from 2009-2017, and that the company funded four endowed professorships at WUR, more than any other company.77Het Onderzoekslab. โHoe Wageningen University & Research in de tang van het bedrijfsleven zit,โ VN, December 23, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/Ejn0B 78โCurrent positions,โ Louise O. Fresco. Archived December 19, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/ZlJ5G
In its investigation of WUR research funded by private companies, VN found that โcompanies such as Unilever have a say in every step of the [research] process,โ and that โthe responsibility for safeguarding scientific integrity is placed with the individual researcher, whose scope to operate independently is becoming increasingly smaller.โ79Het Onderzoekslab. โHoe Wageningen University & Research in de tang van het bedrijfsleven zit,โ VN, December 23, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/Ejn0B
Links with Livestock Industry
In 2021, the European Roundtable for Beef Sustainability announced that it was working with WUR to compile a โtoolkitโ of โthe most impactful processes to mitigate farm greenhouse gas emissions for beef and dairy,โ which involved carrying out a โsurvey to identify the most effective interventions by leading companies to reduce farm footprints in their supply chains.โ80โERBS Updates,โ ERBS Newsletter, April 2021. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/3qq48
WURโs animal welfare initiative, Sustainable Animal Stewardship, run collaboratively with theUtrecht University, lists Vion Food Group โ one of the largest meat producers in Europe โ as a member.81โSustainable Animal Stewardship,โ University of Utrecht. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/YQgn8
In 2019, WUR hosted the International Symposium on Dairy Cattle Nutrition in cooperation with Bayer Animal Health, animal feed additive company Diamond V, and animal health company Zinpro.82โTowards โperfectโ heifer management (summary),โ Wageningen University and Research, February 13, 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/eMUCT
Funding
On a web page titled โIndependence research: Finding Answers Together,โ WUR wrote that in 2019, it had a turnover of 344 million euros. The page provided a breakdown of funding sources by Wagnerian entity.83โIndependence research: Finding Answers Together,โ Wageningen University and Research.Archived November 26, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/cGVVB
Wageningen Research Foundationโs 2019 funding from public authorities, public funds, and the European Union made up 55 percent of WURโs budget while income from โcontract research [for] public authoritiesโ made up 15 percent, 18 percent came from commercial businesses, and 12 percent from โsales and rentals.โ
Wageningen Universityโs 2019 funding from public authorities, public funds, and the EU made up 73 percent of its budget, while โcontract research [for] public authoritiesโ made up 7 percent, funding from commercial businesses made up 4 percent, and 6 percent came from โsales and rentals.โ The remaining 7 percent was covered by tuition fees.
Key People
Sjoukje Heimovaara โ Heimovaara became the president of the WUR executive board in July 2022. She was previously the Managing Director of the Agrotechnology & Food Sciences Group (AFSG) within WUR.84โSjoukje Heimovaara new President Wageningen University & Research,โ Wageningen University and Research, March 14, 2022. Archived March 14, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/sunU3
Louise O. Fresco โ Fresco was the president of the WUR executive board from 2014 to 2022. After stepping down from WUR, she became a board member of Syngenta. She was a board member at Unilever from 2009-2017.85Het Onderzoekslab. โHoe Wageningen University & Research in de tang van het bedrijfsleven zit,โ VN, December 23, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/Ejn0B
Affiliations
Wageningen University & Researchโs plant breeding research institute is a member of the European Association on Plant Breeding (EUCARPIA). EURCARPIA hosts meetings and aims to โpromote scientific and technical co-operation in the field of plant breeding in order to foster its further development.โ86โCorporate members of EUCARPIA,” EUCARPIA. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/lCzmF
BASF and Syngenta are also members of the group.
Resources
- 1โAbout Wageningen University and Research,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/U7wi3
- 2โManagement & Organisation,โ Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 16, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/GEMKD
- 3โAbout Wageningen University and Research,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/U7wi3
- 4โResearch Institutes,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/uSJKZ
- 5Brigitte W.. โFossil Fuelลed WUR,” The Jester, June 10, 2022. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ZJndO
- 6โValue Creation & Cooperation,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/yKEJp
- 7โProfessors of Wageningen University โ July 2022,โ Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 8โProfessors of Wageningen University โ November 2022,โ Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 19, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 9โConclusies belangrijk onderzoek naar biologisch eten afgezwakt onder druk van onderzoeksinstituut TNO,โ Zembla, October 22, 2020. Archived October 27, 2021. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/Ni7S8
- 10โConclusies belangrijk onderzoek naar biologisch eten afgezwakt onder druk van onderzoeksinstituut TNO,โ Zembla, October 22, 2020. Archived October 27, 2021. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/Ni7S8
- 11โ71 Visions on our role in social-environmental transformative change,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 12โ71 Visions on our role in social-environmental transformative change,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 13โโWe need companies in order to make an impact in practiceโ,” Wageningen University and Research, June 22, 2021. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/HmUqd
- 14โโWe need companies in order to make an impact in practiceโ,” Wageningen University and Research, June 22, 2021. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/HmUqd
- 15Damian Carrington. โUN experts denounce ‘myth’ pesticides are necessary to feed the world,” The Guardian, March 7, 2017. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ZP5yl
- 16โAchieving responsibility at Wageningen University & Research,” Wageningen University and Research, 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 17โWageningen wordt een verlengstuk van de voedingsindustrie,” Follow the Money, October 15, 2016. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/8CAvS
- 18โClimate change,โ Wageningen University & Research. Archived August 19, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/FK68v
- 19โClimate Change,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/FK68v
- 20Marion de Boo. โTinkering with the plantโs engine,โ Wageningen Climate Solutions, September 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/sgUsk
- 21Albert Sikkema. โThe climate-friendly cow,โ Wageningen Climate Solutions, September 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/cLs5y
- 22Hanny Roskamp. โHow climate-smart agriculture makes farmers resilient,โ Wageningen Climate Solutions, September 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/PXoDV
- 23Brigitte W., โFossil Fuelลed WUR,โ The Jester, June 10, 2022. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ZJndO
- 24Press Release. โWUR bids Louise O. Fresco farewell after an eight-year tenure,โ Wagnerian University and Research, June 1, 2022. Archived December 19, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/wip/u3Hbg
- 25Brigitte W., โFossil Fuelลed WUR,โ The Jester, June 10, 2022. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ZJndO
- 26โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
- 27Johan Bremmer, Ana Gonzalez-Martinez, Roel Jongeneel, Hilfred Huiting, Rob Stokkers, Marc Ruijs, โImpact Assessment of EC 2030 Green Deal Targets for Sustainable Crop Production,โ Wageningen University and Research, December 2021. Archived December 14, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 28โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
- 29โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
- 30โFactsheet: Green Deal targets for 2030 and agricultural production studies,โ European Commission, February 2022. Archived October 5, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 31Magdalena Pistorius, โFarm to Fork studies do not give โwhole pictureโ, agri stakeholders warn,โ Euractiv, October 29, 2021. Archived December 14, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ibXPF
- 32Magdalena Pistorius, โFarm to Fork studies do not give โwhole pictureโ, agri stakeholders warn,โ Euractiv, October 29, 2021. Archived December 14, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/ibXPF
- 33โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
- 34โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
- 35Johan Bremmer, Ana Gonzalez-Martinez, Roel Jongeneel, Hilfred Huiting, Rob Stokkers, Marc Ruijs. โImpact Assessment of EC 2030 Green Deal Targets for Sustainable Crop Production,โ Wageningen University and Research, December 2021. Archived December 14, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 36โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.,โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
- 37โA loud lobby for a silent spring: The pesticide industryโs lobbying tactics against Farm to Fork.โ Corporate Europe Observatory, March 17, 2022. Archived July 26, 2022. Archive PDF: https://archive.ph/hpFb3
- 38โFraming van het onderzoek, ook in de kop, is daarmee hoogst ongelukkig. Onderzoekers erkennen weliswaar dat voordelen klimaat en biodiversiteit niet zijn meegenomen, maar daar is die hele strategie nu juist voor bedoeld.,โ tweet from user @JeroenCandel, October 12, 2021. Retrieved from twitter.com. Archived October 18, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/7svOI
- 39Roel Jongeneel, Huib Silvis, Ana Gonzalez Martinez, Jakob Jager, โImpact of the EUโs Green Deal on the livestock sector: Executive Summary,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 40Albert Sekkema. โFarm to Fork strategy decreases agricultural production in Europe,โ Resource, October 13, 2021. Archived October 25, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/B0sII
- 41Albert Sekkema. โFarm to Fork strategy decreases agricultural production in Europe,โ Resource, October 13, 2021. Archived October 25, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/B0sII
- 42โThe Sustainability Consortium: achieving sustainability together with supply chain partners,โ Wageningen University & Research. Archived May 25, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/C3sLM
- 43โOur Members,โ The Sustainability Consortium. Archived November 7, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/esNm7
- 44Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,” Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM
- 45Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,” Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM
- 46Vincent Harmsen. โONEWORLD NAAR RECHTER OM GEHEIME CONTACTEN WAGENINGEN UNIVERSITEIT EN BAYER,โ OneWorld, June 25, 2018. Archived July 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/ASww4
- 47โOn-site detection of plant pathogens,โ Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/v5iuy
- 48โ‘PPS GROEN’: Public-Private Partnership project ‘Gewasbescherming Robuust Optimaal En Natuurlijk’,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/59e0Q
- 49โHow do plants identify the harmful insect egg?,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/s5Nf6
- 50โEuroseeds,โ European Commission Funding and Tender Opportunities. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/AoqkX
- 51Het Onderzoekslab. โHoe Wageningen University & Research in de tang van het bedrijfsleven zit,โ VN, December 23, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/Ejn0B
- 52โConditional prison sentence for WUR student activists,” The Jester, December 14, 2021. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/Nlzlg
- 53โโWe need companies in order to make an impact in practiceโ,โ Wageningen University and Research, June 22, 2021. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/HmUqd
- 54โResearch and development,โ Syngenta. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/7T4uM
- 55โSyngenta Foundation Partners,โ Syngenta. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/mvkEu
- 56โSyngenta adds new Director to the Board,โ Syngenta, April 15, 2019. Archived September 12, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/v0KjC
- 57โFrescoโs Syngenta board position controversial,” Resource โ WUR from within, June 6, 2019. Archived December 17, 2017. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/KuxUr
- 58โFunding University Research,” Wageningen University and Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/KQjF1
- 59โWizards and Prophets meet each other,” Wageningen University and Research, May 20, 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/1KOK9
- 60โWizards and Prophets meet each other,” Wageningen University and Research, May 20, 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/1KOK9
- 61โSky High – Plant flats with LEDs,โ Wageningen University & Research, November 7, 2019. Archived May 14, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/na4iK
- 62โConsortium,โ Wageningen University & Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/pxlVo
- 63โPhotosynthesis, the green engine of life on Earth,โ Wageningen University & Research. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/4YQLS
- 64โFuture sensors and digital twins to improve perishable food quality,โ Wageningen University & Research, November 2, 2021. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/NE2YY
- 65โAGROS programme launched: businesses work with WUR to optimise agroecology with technology,โ Wageningen University & Research, May 26, 2020. Archived May 25, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/oacnf
- 66Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,โ Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM
- 67Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,โ Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM
- 68โโPlant roots exhibit starling behaviourโ, Farewell lecture of prof. Frank Berendse,โ Wageningen University & Research, April 1, 2016. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/FhZqk
- 69Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,โ Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM
- 70Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,โ Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM
- 71Tomas Vanheste. โDode bij, stille lente; Gif op de bloemen,” Vrij Nederlands, December 1, 2021. Archived June 26, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 72Vincent Harmsen. โBelangenverstrengeling zaait twijfels over giftig zaad,” Follow the Money, January 10, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/rUErM
- 73โAalt Dijkhuizen,โ LinkedIn. Archived December 19, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 74Tomas Vanheste. โDode bij, stille lente; Gif op de bloemen,โ Vrij Nederlands, December 1, 2021. Archived June 26, 2022. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 75โTHE SILENT TAKEOVER: Dutch Wageningen University moves on to sell their independence to industry,โ Pesticide Action Network Europe, May 3, 2013. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/JmAus
- 76โFunding university research,โ Wageningen University & Research. Archived December 16, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/KQjF1
- 77Het Onderzoekslab. โHoe Wageningen University & Research in de tang van het bedrijfsleven zit,โ VN, December 23, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/Ejn0B
- 78โCurrent positions,โ Louise O. Fresco. Archived December 19, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/ZlJ5G
- 79Het Onderzoekslab. โHoe Wageningen University & Research in de tang van het bedrijfsleven zit,โ VN, December 23, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/Ejn0B
- 80โERBS Updates,โ ERBS Newsletter, April 2021. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/3qq48
- 81โSustainable Animal Stewardship,โ University of Utrecht. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/YQgn8
- 82โTowards โperfectโ heifer management (summary),โ Wageningen University and Research, February 13, 2019. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/eMUCT
- 83โIndependence research: Finding Answers Together,โ Wageningen University and Research.Archived November 26, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/cGVVB
- 84โSjoukje Heimovaara new President Wageningen University & Research,โ Wageningen University and Research, March 14, 2022. Archived March 14, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/sunU3
- 85Het Onderzoekslab. โHoe Wageningen University & Research in de tang van het bedrijfsleven zit,โ VN, December 23, 2020. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/Ejn0B
- 86โCorporate members of EUCARPIA,” EUCARPIA. Archived December 17, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/lCzmF