Background
The Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB) is an โarmโs length bodyโ (ALB) of the UKโs Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (Defra),1โAbout us,โ Department for Environment Food & Rural Affairs. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/nYdo7 classified as a non-departmental public body (NDPB).As an NDPB, the AHDB has some operational control over policy, can collect levies, and accept grant-in-aid money.2โPublic Bodies Handbook โ Part 1,โ Cabinet Office. Archived June 15, 2021.
The AHDB is funded through statutory levies paid by โfarmers, growers and others in the supply chain,โ including beef, lamb, pork, and dairy producers.3โAbout the Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB),โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/GEtEs
The AHDB was formed in 2008 from five previous levy bodies: the Meat and Livestock Commission, the Milk Development Council, the British Potato Council, the Home-Grown Cereals Authority, and the Horticultural Development Council.4โThe Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board Order 2008, Article 17โ Legislation.gov.uk. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/n7Lz8 The boardโs legal purpose is to develop, improve, and increase the efficiency, productivity, marketing, services, and sustainability of the UKโs agriculture and horticulture industry.5โThe Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board Order 2008, Article 3โ Legislation.gov.uk. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/bpOHZ
Working with more than 100,000 farming and supply chain businesses across the UK, the AHDB employs both regional officers and an international team to โdevelop export markets in new countries such as China and the Far Eastโ.6โAbout the Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB),โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/GEtEs
In January 2021, the AHDB launched a ยฃ1.5 million advertising campaign titled โWe Eat Balancedโ to โprovide clear facts to help those reducing meat and dairy consumption to re-consider their choices and to promote a healthy, sustainable diet.โ7โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
Stance on Climate Change
The AHDB states: โOver the next 40 years, the global food system will have to feed more people with less impact. This will mean providing a higher quality diet whilst dealing with greater competition for land, water and energy and the economic and political pressures of globalisation as the climate changes.โ According to the organisation, โagriculture can also make a big contribution to mitigating climate change by storing carbon in soils and vegetation and by generating renewable energy.โ8โGreenhouse Gas Action Plan (GHGAP),โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/uR7UC
The AHDB is a member of the industry-led initiative Greenhouse Gas Action Plan (GHGAP), which aims to reduce its membersโ greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 3 megatonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent (Mt CO2e) per year from 2018 to 2022.9โGreenhouse Gas Action Plan (GHGAP),โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/uR7UC
In March 2021, the AHDB hosted a webinar series titled โCarbon Week.โ One session titled โSupply chain requirements โ building a narrativeโ10โCarbon Week,โ AHDB, January 29, 2021. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/sh343 explored why AHDB members โshould invest time and effort in measuring and reporting our sustainability and environmental performanceโ in order to โdemonstrate that its products are sustainable in a way that is transparent, assured and timely, to continue to ensure consumer, investor and retailer confidence.โ11โCarbon Week: Supply chain requirements โ building a narrative,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/vRjsL
In January 2021, the AHDB wrote in a press release in response to Veganuary, a campaign that encourages people to eat plant-based during January, that โthere is a belief that the month is now โownedโ by those who follow alternative lifestyle choices and set out to convert others while spreading misinformation and mischief around livestock farming.โ The board announced plans โto use social media to push positive messages about our meat and dairy sectors, supported by advertorials in high-profile titles, and working behind the scenes with social media influencers.โ12โItโs time the livestock sector reclaimed January,โ AHDB, January 2, 2020. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/PFPci
The same month, AHDB launched a campaign titled โWe Eat Balancedโ to โprovide clear facts to help those reducing meat and dairy consumption to re-consider.โ13โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
In December 2020, the AHDB responded to the Sixth Carbon Budget report published by the UK Climate Change Committee, stating that โdespite the UK having some of the worldโs most sustainable red meat and dairy production systems, it is clear that in order for us to continue production and consumption, significant carbon savings must be made.โ14โAHDB responds to UK Climate Change Committee report,โ AHDB, December 9, 2020. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/Bt0rt
In late 2020, the AHDB announced the launch15โAHDB launches on-farm carbon footprinting,โ AHDB, November 18, 2020. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/UZQAi of a โFarm Excellenceโ network โ a program to assess the carbon footprints of member farms, including 10 beef and lamb producers and four pork producers.16โFarm Excellence,โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/3MlxP
Livestock emissions
In a 2020 presentation,17โHaving positive conversations about meat & dairy, January 2020,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/z6QTk the AHDB stated that โwhile emissions of the entire agricultural sector (including livestock and aquaculture) account for 10% of the [UKโs] total emissions, those due to the use of fossil fuels represent a far more important 64%.โ The organisation also argues that โit is commonly cited that livestock emit more emissions than transport, but this is untrue.โ18โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
During the same year, Greenpeace published a report estimating that animal farming in the EU, including the UK, emitted 704 Mt CO2e in 2018, more than โall EU cars and vans combined.โ19โFarming for Failure,โ Greenpeace. Archived June 26, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/RYzSK In the report, Greenpeace considered not only the livestock sectorโs direct emissions and energy consumption emissions, known as scope 1 and 2 emissions, but also indirect emissions caused by livestock farming, such as land use and land-use change associated with animal feed production. These types of emissions, which are also referred to as scope 3 emissions, account for the majority of the meat industryโs emissions and are not included the 10 percent estimate given by the AHDB.20Fiona Harvey. โEUโs farm animals โproduce more emissions than cars and vans combinedโ,โ The Guardian. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/hKn5J
Key Narratives
The AHDB promotes a number of narratives to justify the meat industryโs business model. Find out more about how the meat industry is climate-washing its activities in our investigation. And you can read counter-arguments and criticisms of these narratives in our factsheet.
โAnimal agriculture isnโt a serious driver of climate changeโ
โAnimal agricultureโs climate impact is exaggeratedโ
In 2020, the AHDB criticised the BBC for rewarding children for going meat-free for at least two weeks, as part of childrenโs TV show Blue Peterโs โclimate hero challenge.โ The AHDB claimed that โphrases including โreducing the amount of meat you eat, especially beef and lamb, is known to be even better for the climate than reducing the amount you travel in a carโ is incorrect, misleading and based on widely-debunked data.โ21โAHDB, QMS and HCC respond to CBBCโs Blue Peter Green Badge campaign,โ AHDB, April 13, 2021. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/56RHn In 2020, Greenpeace published a report estimating that animal farming in the EU, including the UK, emitted 704 Mt CO2e in 2018, more than โall EU cars and vans combined,โ considering both the sectorโs direct and indirect emissions.22โFarming for Failure,โ Greenpeace. Archived June 26, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/RYzSK
Other meat industry groups also criticised the BBCโs โclimate hero challengeโ, including Quality Meat Scotland (QMS), a member of SAI Platform,23โAHDB, QMS and HCC respond to CBBCโs Blue Peter Green Badge campaign,โ AHDB, April 13, 2021. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/56RHn a food industry initiative that encompasses the European Roundtable for Beef Sustainability, and Hybu Cig Cymru/Meat Promotion Wales, a member of the Global Roundtable on Sustainable Beef.24โHCC joins global push for sustainable meat,โ Meat Management, March 16, 2021. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/RlmgW
โBritish meat is environmentally friendlyโ
According to the AHDB, โthe UK is one of the most sustainable places in the world to produce beef and lamb.โ25โRed meat and the environment: The facts,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/Zwo5L The organisation notes that โland and water are different across the world, so while livestock require large quantities in comparison with plant-based foods, they are often being used for their ideal purpose.โ26โWhat would happen if the world converted to veganism?,โ We Eat Balanced. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/tLApS
According to a 2019 study by environmental scientists from Harvard University, transitioning to a more plant-based food production system in the UK has the potential to extend the UKโs 1.5ยฐC carbon budget by 75% to 103% up to 2050 while still meeting the populationโs nutrition requirements.27โEating Away at Climate Change With Negative Emissions,โ Harvard Law School, April 11, 2019. Archived July 14, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/Jfgjy
โGrazing supports biodiversity and sequesters carbonโ
In a 2020 presentation, the AHDB stated that โgrasslands [used for livestock grazing] capture and store carbon from the atmosphere, provide a habitat for wildlife and aid biodiversity.โ28โHaving positive conversations about meat & dairy, January 2020,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/z6QTk
The AHDB states elsewhere that โby taking a more holistic approach to measuring the carbon footprint of livestock farming, the emissions from cattle and sheep are likely to be largely offset through carbon sequestration, or carbon absorption.โ It supported this claim by referring to an unspecified study from New Zealand โshowing how sustainable red meat production can be in temperate climates such as the UK.โ The AHDB further notes that โwhile carbon sequestration would occur without cattle and sheep grazing, their existence allows us to produce food from this land while in harmony with nature.โ29โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
When contacted by DeSmog, the AHDB specified that it was referring to a 2020 study by ecologists from Auckland University of Technology (AUT) commissioned by the meat industry group Beef + Lamb New Zealand, showing that โwoody vegetation on NZ sheep and beef farms is offsetting between 63% and 118% of their on farm agricultural emissions.โ30โAnalysis of carbon stocks and net carbon position for New Zealand sheep and beef farmland,โ Beef + Lamb New Zealand. Archived June 15, 2021
The AHDB later deleted the original document that included these statements, telling DeSmog that โas the campaign activity has now ended, the [campaigns conversation] pack has been removed.โ
In 2021, New Zealandโs Ministry for the Environment stated in a separate report that the AUT study included โsome fundamental limitations in how the estimates of carbon sequestration were derivedโ and concluded that the proportion of emissions being offset was only 33 percent.31โNet emissions and removals from vegetation and soils on sheep and beef farmland,โ Ministry for the Environment. Archived June 15, 2021. A study on the concept of โgrazed ecosystems,โ also known as โholistic management,โ has found that โthe application of HM [holistic management] principles of trampling and intensive foraging are as detrimental to plants, soils, water storage, and plant productivity as are conventional grazing systems.โ32John Carter et al. โHolistic Management: Misinformation on the Science of Grazed Ecosystems,โ International Journal of Biodiversity. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/jvg3j
โLivestock graze on land unsuitable for other usesโ
In a 2020 presentation, the AHDB argued that โjust over 60% of UK agricultural land is grassland, less suitable economically and environmentally for anything other than livestock grazing.โ33โHaving positive conversations about meat & dairy, January 2020,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/z6QTk
University of Oxford environmental researcher Marco Springmann argues that โif everybody were to make the argument that โour pastures are the best and should be used for grazingโ, then there would be no way to limit global warming.โ34Damian Carrington. โWhy you should go animal-free: 18 arguments for eating meat debunked,โ The Guardian, June 19, 2020. Archived July 9, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/zVUwT A 2020 study by biodiversity experts from Aarhus University on how rewilding can serve as a climate mitigation strategy identified plant-based diets as a key means of freeing up land for this purpose.35Jens-Christian Svenning. โRewilding should be central to global restoration efforts,โ One Earth, December 18, 2020. Archived June 30, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/Q4qpv
โPlant-based diets do not solve the problem of climate changeโ
โDietary change is an ineffective climate strategyโ
As part of the โWe Eat Balancedโ campaign, the AHDB states that โshould livestock production be dramatically reduced due to more people becoming semi-vegetarian, emissions are unlikely to reduce very much. This is due to the emissions of any replacement foods and products. This is supported by a Swedish study which shows the carbon footprint of lifelong vegans is only 4% lower than meat eaters.โ36โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
When contacted by DeSmog, the AHDB specified that it was referring to a 2014 study by economists from the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (SLU). According to the study, switching to vegetarianism could reduce GHG emissions associated with diet by 20 percent. The study hypothesised that if consumers spend the income they save by not buying meat โaccording to their current preferences, they would forego 96% of potential energy savings and 49% of greenhouse gas emission savings.โ The AHDB later deleted the original document that included these statements, telling DeSmog that โas the campaign activity has now ended, the [campaigns conversation] pack has been removed.โ37Janina Grabs. โThe rebound effects of switching to vegetarianism. A microeconomic analysis of Swedish consumption behavior,โ Ecological Economics, August 2015. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/RbPPK
The organisation further states: โStudies suggest removing animal products from western diets could reduce personal carbon footprints by around 2%. Care must be taken to avoid replacing sustainably and locally produced foods such as red meat and dairy with imported goods, with potentially wider environmental implications.โ38โWill reducing the UKโs red meat consumption improve our environmental impact?,โ We Eat Balanced. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/SFHIq
However, a systematic review based on multiple studies concluded that GHG emissions โdiffer considerably per diet, with a vegan diet having the lowest CO2eq production per 2000 kcal consumed.โ39Bingli Chai et al. โWhich Diet Has the Least Environmental Impact on Our Planet? A Systematic Review of Vegan, Vegetarian and Omnivorous Diets,โ Sustainability, July 2019. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/ICLxh According to an analysis published by Oxford Universityโs Our World in Data project, the transport of food accounts for only a small share of emissions, while most GHG emissions caused by animal agriculture result from the production of the meat itself.40Hannah Ritchie. โYou want to reduce the carbon footprint of your food? Focus on what you eat, not whether your food is local,โ Our World in Data, January 24, 2020. Archived July 13, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/wJHsU
โLess meat is wasted than fruit and vegetablesโ
In response to the publication of the EAT-Lancet report, which calls for a reduction in food waste to decrease food demand, the AHDB cites the UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), stating that โfood waste from meat and dairy is one of the lowest at 20%, with up to 45% of fruit and vegetables wasted, 30% of cereals and 30% of fish.โ41โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
Studies have found โplant-based diets are also more climate friendly when they are wasted,โ42Bingli Chai et al. โWhich Diet Has the Least Environmental Impact on Our Planet? A Systematic Review of Vegan, Vegetarian and Omnivorous Diets,โ Sustainability, July 2019. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/ICLxh however. Researchers from the University of Michigan43Martin Heller & Gregory Keoleian. โGreenhouse Gas Emission Estimates of U.S. Dietary Choices and Food Loss,โ Journal of Industrial Ecology, September 4, 2014. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/IsaIH showed that โfruits and vegetables which comprise 33 percent of food waste [in the U.S.], account for only 8 percent of carbon dioxide emissions,โ while animal products โaccount for 33 percent of food waste by mass and 74 percent of carbon dioxide emissions.” 44Bingli Chai et al. โWhich Diet Has the Least Environmental Impact on Our Planet? A Systematic Review of Vegan, Vegetarian and Omnivorous Diets,โ Sustainability, July 2019. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/ICLxh
A 2021 study by researchers from Freiburg University and Vienna University of Economics and Business concluded that โan exclusive focus on food waste would potentially mislead policymakers and prevent them from addressing diets, despite [dietary change towards more plant-based diets] being the more effective strategy for reducing resource use.โ45Hanna Helander et al. โEating healthy or wasting less? Reducing resource footprints of food consumption,โ Environmental Research Letters, February, 2021. Archived June 30, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/d2J7R
โMeat is needed for a healthy diet and to feed the worldโ
โMeat is crucial to feeding a growing global populationโ
The AHDB states on its website: โOver the next 40 years, the global food system will have to feed more people with less impact.โ46โGreenhouse Gas Action Plan (GHGAP),โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/uR7UC It argues elsewhere that โresponsible and strategic livestock farming is a highly productive industry that produces a large amount of nutritious food for the population.โ47โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
AHDB Head of Market Specialists for Livestock and Dairy Chris Gooderham stated in 2019: โAny cap on [the sectorโs] production would be a misguided and meaningless tactic for tackling climate change. Our farmers need support to further improve productivity and reduce their carbon footprint while continuing to produce vital, nourishing food for a growing population.โ48โAHDB responds to โPeak Meatโ by 2030,โ AHDB, December 16, 2019. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/5WEat
According to the World Resources Institute (WRI), a sustainable development organisation,49โWorld Resources Report: Creating a Sustainable Food Future,โ World Resources Institute, December 2018. Archived July 14, 2021 feeding 10 billion people by 2050 without transitioning to a more plant-based global diet would necessitate the destruction of the worldโs remaining forests and โagriculture alone would produce almost twice the emissions allowable from all human activities.50โDamian Carrington. โBeef-eating โmust fall drasticallyโ as world population grows,โ The Guardian, December 5, 2018. Archived July 14, 2021. Archive.ph URL: โโhttps://archive.ph/wip/0CheC
โDiet is a personal choiceโ
As part of the AHDBโs โWe Eat Balancedโ campaign, which aims to โhelp those reducing meat and dairy consumption to re-consider [sic] their choices,โ the AHDB stated that โchoosing to exclude all animal products is a personal choice,โ noting that โthe majority of people in the UK include animal products like red meat and dairy.โ51โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
โMeat is particularly nutrient-denseโ
In 2020, the AHDB criticised the BBC for encouraging children to reduce their meat consumption as part of an environmental initiative by childrenโs TV show Blue Peter, stating that โthe minerals and vitamins found in red meat should form an important part of a growing young personโs diet.โ52โAHDB, QMS and HCC respond to CBBCโs Blue Peter Green Badge campaign,โ AHDB, April 13, 2021. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/56RHn
As part of the AHDBโs โWe Eat Balancedโ campaign, the AHDB notes that vitamin B12 is โfound naturally in red meat […] and in dairy […], as well as eggs and fish and can be more difficult to source from foods of plant origin.โ53โVitamin B12,โ We Eat Balanced. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/xGIws
Will Jackson, AHDBโs Strategy Director for Beef & Lamb, responded to the EAT-Lancet Commission report stating: โ[Dairy and red meat] are an important nutritional part of a healthy, balanced diet. […] Government guidelines suggest we should have 70g of red meat a day. Average population intake in the UK is currently below this figure. Any suggestion that we should further reduce our intake could have unintended detrimental consequences on health.โ54โAHDB response to Eat Lancet Commission report,โ AHDB, January 16, 2019. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/ZxQKP The UKโs official dietary guidelines, however, recommends reducing the intake of red and processed meat to โno more than 70 grams per day.โ55โThe Eatwell Guide: Helping you eat a healthy, balanced diet,โ Public Health England. Archived June 15, 2021.
Nutrition associations, including the British Nutrition Foundation, approve of meat-free diets.56โPlant-based diets,โ British Nutrition Foundation. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/jcaHh According to the American Dietetic Association, โappropriately planned vegetarian diets, including total vegetarian or vegan diets, are healthful, nutritionally adequate, and may provide health benefits in the prevention and treatment of certain diseases.โ57Winston Craig & Ann Reed Mangles. โPosition of the American Dietetic Association: vegetarian diets,โ Journal of the American Dietetic Association, July, 2009. Archived July 14, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/WdQYV
The AHDB states elsewhere that โfoodโs carbon footprint is typically calculated by weight and doesnโt factor in nutrient availability.โ58โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021. According to an analysis by Oxford Universityโs Our World in Data, beef, lamb, and mutton also have significantly higher carbon footprints per 100 grams of protein than plant-based sources of protein such as tofu and other pulses.59Hannah Ritchie & Max Roser. โEnvironmental impacts of food production,โ Our World in Data, January, 2020. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/C7seZ
โInnovations in animal agriculture will tackle climate changeโ
โSlaughtering and livestock management innovations will cut emissionsโ
The AHDB suggests reducing farmsโ carbon footprint by slaughtering animals earlier, the use of anaerobic digesters, and better slurry and manure management.60โEnvironment FAQs for farming, growing and the industry,โ AHDB. Archived July 4, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/O1WeB
Environmental organisations GRAIN and the Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy (IATP) argue โthat the large gains in โefficiencyโ realised by industrial farming in the twentieth century will be hard to repeat without major ecological, social and health impacts.โ They describe the efficiency of intensive livestock production as โa myth.โ61โEmissions impossible: How big meat and dairy are heating up the planet,โ GRAIN & Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy (IATP), July 18, 2018. Archived July 14, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/3T9Zz
โNew grazing techniques can sequester carbonโ
In a 2020 presentation, the AHDB stated that โresearch is currently underway which looks at the extent of carbon neutrality when responsible and strategic grazing methods are used to produce red meatโ and that โthe early results have been promising, demonstrating that managing livestock effectively can sequester tons of atmospheric carbon in soils.โ62โHaving positive conversations about meat & dairy, January 2020,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/z6QTk
Environmental scientists from the University of Oxford have criticised the idea of using cattle grazing to capture carbon for only offsetting 20-60 percent of annual average emissions from the grazing ruminant sector, concluding that โgrass-fed cattle remain net contributors to warming.โ63Tara Garnett et al. โGrazed and confused?,โ FCRN. Archived June 30, 2021.
Funding
The Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB) is an โarmโs length bodyโ of the UKโs Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (Defra), classified as a non-departmental public body (NDPB).64โAbout us,โ Department for Environment Food & Rural Affairs. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/nYdo7 The AHDB is funded through statutory levies paid by โfarmers, growers and others in the supply chain,โ including beef, lamb, pork, and dairy producers.65โAbout the Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB),โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/GEtEs
For the financial period 2019/20, the AHDB reported a total income of ยฃ67.2 million.66โAgriculture and Horticulture Development Board,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. According to a 2018 Defra report, the AHDB also has โnon-levy income of around ยฃ10 million per year from EU grants, fees for services, and from its commercial subsidiary, Meat and Livestock Commercial Services Ltd (MLCSL).โ67โRequest for Views on the Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board,โ Department for Environment Food & Rural Affairs, August, 2018. Archived June 15, 2021.
A ยฃ1 million dairy marketing campaign the AHDB launched in 2020, titled โMilk Your Moments,โ was co-funded by Defra, the Scottish government, the Welsh government, and the Northern Ireland Executive.68Philip Case. โMilk Your Moments campaign reaches millions,โ Farmers Weekly, June 17, 2020. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/UYPGy
Lobbying
According to LobbyFacts.eu, the AHDB spent โฌ300,000-399,999 on lobbying EU institutions every year between 2015 and 2019, declared four full-time lobbyists, and has held at least one meeting with the European Commission since 2014. According to the database, the AHDB Brussels office โmonitoredโ a range of policies, including the ongoing Common Agricultural Policy simplification, policies on animal and plant health, promotion of agricultural products, climate and energy framework and air quality proposals, and food labelling.69โAgriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB),โ LobbyFacts.eu. Archived December 31, 2020. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/9IzDT
Starting from 2017, the AHDB participated in an EU-funded campaign, โaiming to convince millennial consumers (aged 25-35) across four EU markets (France, Ireland, Germany and the UK) to โLove Lamb,โโ alongside Interbev, Franceโs leading cattle association, and Bord Bia, the Irish Food Board.70โEU LAMB CAMPAIGN,โ REA. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/NXacX
The AHDB co-developed the UKโs national dietary guidelines with Public Health England (PHE), an executive agency of the Department of Health and Social Care, as a member of the guidelinesโ โexternal reference group.โ71โFrom Plate to Guide: What, why and how for the eatwell model,โ Public Health England. Archived June 15, 2021. It is also a โsustaining memberโ of the British Nutrition Association, another organisation involved in shaping governmental nutrition policies.72โCurrent members,โ British Nutrition Foundation. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/qeUyg
In 2020, the AHDB launched a ยฃ1 million dairy marketing campaign titled โMilk Your Moments,โ co-funded by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra), the Scottish government, the Welsh government, and the Northern Ireland Executive.73Philip Case. โMilk Your Moments campaign reaches millions,โ Farmers Weekly, June 17, 2020. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/UYPGy
The same year, along with meat industry groups Quality Meat Scotland (QMS) and Hybu Cig Cymru / Meat Promotion Wales (HCC), the AHDB criticised the BBC for suggesting that children reduce their meat consumption as part of childrenโs TV show Blue Peterโs โclimate hero challenge.โ74โAHDB, QMS and HCC respond to CBBCโs Blue Peter Green Badge campaign,โ AHDB, April 13, 2021. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/56RHn The BBC subsequently changed the challenge from asking children to go โmeat-freeโ for at least two weeks to choosing a couple of vegetarian meals a week.75Ben Webster. โBlue Peter drops anti-meat message after farmerโs beef with BBC,โ The Times, April 13, 2021. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/z34wu Vegan campaign group Surge criticised the BBC for bowing to meat industry pressure, arguing that critics of the campaign perpetuated โthe false narrative that land can either produce crops or, if it canโt, it must be used to produce meat.โ76Claire Hamlett. โBlue Peter bends to flesh industry bullying,โ Surge, April 14, 2021. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/x7eiJ
In 2017, Mick Sloyan, Senior Director for Pork at AHDB, stated that a meat tax would be โan incredibly blunt tool for a complex problem,โ in response to Jeremy Coller, founder of the Farm Animal Investment Risk & Return (FAIRR) Initiative, who had suggested that โif policymakers are to cover the true cost of livestock epidemics like avian flu and human epidemics like obesity, diabetes and cancer, while also tackling the twin challenges of climate change and antibiotic resistance, then a shift from subsidisation to taxation of the meat industry looks inevitable.โ77Lauren Dean. โMeat tax โincreasingly probableโ to keep within 2degc Paris agreement,โ Farmers Guardian, December 16, 2017. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/b25Nr
Affiliations
The AHDB is an affiliate of the European Livestock Voice,78โMeat the Facts,โ European Livestock Voice. Archived 14 July 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/aeJnj an EU-level campaign started in 2019 by the farming association COPA-COGECA and 10 other livestock organisations.79โCOPA-COGECA,โ DeSmog. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/nbSnC
The AHDB is also a member of the International Meat Secretariat,80โTransparency Register: Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board,โ EUROPA. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/tS3jL a nonprofit organisation representing the red meat sector at a global level.81โAbout the IMS,โ International Meat Secretariat. Archived June 16, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/N8PoV
Phil Bicknell, Market Intelligence Director at AHDB,82โPhil Bicknell,โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: โโhttps://archive.ph/wip/XXZm9 is the former Head of Food and Farming at the National Farmersโ Union (NFU), an organisation representing farmers in England and Wales.83โNational Farmersโ Union (UK),โ DeSmog. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/1xbhd
As part of the AHDBโs โWe Eat Balancedโ campaign, the organisation partnered with food standards scheme Red Tractor84โEnjoy the food you eat We Eat Balanced,โ We Eat Balanced. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/3AJPv and launched the Food Advisory Board (FAB) at the Food Matters Live 2019 event, an annual health and nutrition exhibition.85โ17 million consumers informed about health benefits of meat,โ Farmers Guide, July 1, 2020. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/0ivwH
The AHDBโs Chair Nicholas Saphir was formerly employed by dairy company Dairy Crest (now Saputo Dairy UK) and the Organic Milk Producersโ Cooperative (Omsco). According to the organisationโs website, Saphir โhas a long and successful record of chairing industry and government bodies in the food and farming sector, including being the chair of the Central Council for Agricultural and Horticultural Cooperation, founder chair of Food from Britain, president of the Fresh Produce Consortium and chair of the Agricultural Forum.โ86โManagement Team,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/lidyc
Speakers at the AHDBโs 2021 โCarbon Weekโ webinar series included Sarah Haire, Head of Agriculture at Dawn Meats and former Chair of the European Roundtable for Beef Sustainability; Harriet Wilson, agriculture and sustainable sourcing manager at McDonaldโs; and multiple speakers from agricultural and environmental consultancy ADAS Climate and Sustainability.87โCarbon Week: Supply chain requirements โ building a narrative,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/vRjsL
Research Collaborations
According to the EU Transparency Register,88โTransparency Register: Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board,โ EUROPA. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/tS3jL the AHDB participated in Euro Dairy,89โEuroDairy,โ EuroDairy. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/O4qxe EU Pig,90โHome Page,โ EU PiG Innovation Group. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/kmgR2 Dairy-4-Future91โPropagating Innovations For More Resilient Dairy Farming in the Atlantic Area,โ Dairy-4-Future. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/G8zQz and Innovation for Sustainable Sheep and Goat Production in Europe (iSAGE), EU-funded projects aiming to improve the efficiency, resiliency and sustainability of EU livestock farming.92โHome,โ iSAGE: Innovation for Sustainable Sheep and Goat Production in Europe. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/ES0ys
Other Resources
Resources
- 1โAbout us,โ Department for Environment Food & Rural Affairs. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/nYdo7
- 2โPublic Bodies Handbook โ Part 1,โ Cabinet Office. Archived June 15, 2021.
- 3โAbout the Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB),โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/GEtEs
- 4โThe Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board Order 2008, Article 17โ Legislation.gov.uk. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/n7Lz8
- 5โThe Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board Order 2008, Article 3โ Legislation.gov.uk. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/bpOHZ
- 6โAbout the Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB),โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/GEtEs
- 7โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
- 8โGreenhouse Gas Action Plan (GHGAP),โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/uR7UC
- 9โGreenhouse Gas Action Plan (GHGAP),โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/uR7UC
- 10โCarbon Week,โ AHDB, January 29, 2021. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/sh343
- 11โCarbon Week: Supply chain requirements โ building a narrative,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/vRjsL
- 12โItโs time the livestock sector reclaimed January,โ AHDB, January 2, 2020. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/PFPci
- 13โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
- 14โAHDB responds to UK Climate Change Committee report,โ AHDB, December 9, 2020. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/Bt0rt
- 15โAHDB launches on-farm carbon footprinting,โ AHDB, November 18, 2020. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/UZQAi
- 16
- 17โHaving positive conversations about meat & dairy, January 2020,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/z6QTk
- 18โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
- 19โFarming for Failure,โ Greenpeace. Archived June 26, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/RYzSK
- 20Fiona Harvey. โEUโs farm animals โproduce more emissions than cars and vans combinedโ,โ The Guardian. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/hKn5J
- 21โAHDB, QMS and HCC respond to CBBCโs Blue Peter Green Badge campaign,โ AHDB, April 13, 2021. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/56RHn
- 22โFarming for Failure,โ Greenpeace. Archived June 26, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/RYzSK
- 23โAHDB, QMS and HCC respond to CBBCโs Blue Peter Green Badge campaign,โ AHDB, April 13, 2021. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/56RHn
- 24โHCC joins global push for sustainable meat,โ Meat Management, March 16, 2021. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/RlmgW
- 25โRed meat and the environment: The facts,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/Zwo5L
- 26โWhat would happen if the world converted to veganism?,โ We Eat Balanced. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/tLApS
- 27โEating Away at Climate Change With Negative Emissions,โ Harvard Law School, April 11, 2019. Archived July 14, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/Jfgjy
- 28โHaving positive conversations about meat & dairy, January 2020,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/z6QTk
- 29โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
- 30โAnalysis of carbon stocks and net carbon position for New Zealand sheep and beef farmland,โ Beef + Lamb New Zealand. Archived June 15, 2021
- 31โNet emissions and removals from vegetation and soils on sheep and beef farmland,โ Ministry for the Environment. Archived June 15, 2021.
- 32John Carter et al. โHolistic Management: Misinformation on the Science of Grazed Ecosystems,โ International Journal of Biodiversity. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/jvg3j
- 33โHaving positive conversations about meat & dairy, January 2020,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/z6QTk
- 34Damian Carrington. โWhy you should go animal-free: 18 arguments for eating meat debunked,โ The Guardian, June 19, 2020. Archived July 9, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/zVUwT
- 35Jens-Christian Svenning. โRewilding should be central to global restoration efforts,โ One Earth, December 18, 2020. Archived June 30, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/Q4qpv
- 36โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
- 37Janina Grabs. โThe rebound effects of switching to vegetarianism. A microeconomic analysis of Swedish consumption behavior,โ Ecological Economics, August 2015. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/RbPPK
- 38โWill reducing the UKโs red meat consumption improve our environmental impact?,โ We Eat Balanced. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/SFHIq
- 39Bingli Chai et al. โWhich Diet Has the Least Environmental Impact on Our Planet? A Systematic Review of Vegan, Vegetarian and Omnivorous Diets,โ Sustainability, July 2019. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/ICLxh
- 40Hannah Ritchie. โYou want to reduce the carbon footprint of your food? Focus on what you eat, not whether your food is local,โ Our World in Data, January 24, 2020. Archived July 13, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/wJHsU
- 41โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
- 42Bingli Chai et al. โWhich Diet Has the Least Environmental Impact on Our Planet? A Systematic Review of Vegan, Vegetarian and Omnivorous Diets,โ Sustainability, July 2019. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/ICLxh
- 43Martin Heller & Gregory Keoleian. โGreenhouse Gas Emission Estimates of U.S. Dietary Choices and Food Loss,โ Journal of Industrial Ecology, September 4, 2014. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/IsaIH
- 44Bingli Chai et al. โWhich Diet Has the Least Environmental Impact on Our Planet? A Systematic Review of Vegan, Vegetarian and Omnivorous Diets,โ Sustainability, July 2019. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/ICLxh
- 45Hanna Helander et al. โEating healthy or wasting less? Reducing resource footprints of food consumption,โ Environmental Research Letters, February, 2021. Archived June 30, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/d2J7R
- 46โGreenhouse Gas Action Plan (GHGAP),โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/uR7UC
- 47โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
- 48โAHDB responds to โPeak Meatโ by 2030,โ AHDB, December 16, 2019. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/5WEat
- 49โWorld Resources Report: Creating a Sustainable Food Future,โ World Resources Institute, December 2018. Archived July 14, 2021
- 50โDamian Carrington. โBeef-eating โmust fall drasticallyโ as world population grows,โ The Guardian, December 5, 2018. Archived July 14, 2021. Archive.ph URL: โโhttps://archive.ph/wip/0CheC
- 51โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
- 52โAHDB, QMS and HCC respond to CBBCโs Blue Peter Green Badge campaign,โ AHDB, April 13, 2021. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/56RHn
- 53โVitamin B12,โ We Eat Balanced. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/xGIws
- 54โAHDB response to Eat Lancet Commission report,โ AHDB, January 16, 2019. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/ZxQKP
- 55โThe Eatwell Guide: Helping you eat a healthy, balanced diet,โ Public Health England. Archived June 15, 2021.
- 56โPlant-based diets,โ British Nutrition Foundation. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/jcaHh
- 57Winston Craig & Ann Reed Mangles. โPosition of the American Dietetic Association: vegetarian diets,โ Journal of the American Dietetic Association, July, 2009. Archived July 14, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/WdQYV
- 58โEat Balanced: Having Positive Conversations About Meat & Dairy 2021โ, AHDB. Archived January 30, 2021.
- 59Hannah Ritchie & Max Roser. โEnvironmental impacts of food production,โ Our World in Data, January, 2020. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/C7seZ
- 60โEnvironment FAQs for farming, growing and the industry,โ AHDB. Archived July 4, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/O1WeB
- 61โEmissions impossible: How big meat and dairy are heating up the planet,โ GRAIN & Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy (IATP), July 18, 2018. Archived July 14, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/3T9Zz
- 62โHaving positive conversations about meat & dairy, January 2020,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/z6QTk
- 63Tara Garnett et al. โGrazed and confused?,โ FCRN. Archived June 30, 2021.
- 64โAbout us,โ Department for Environment Food & Rural Affairs. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/nYdo7
- 65โAbout the Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB),โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/GEtEs
- 66
- 67โRequest for Views on the Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board,โ Department for Environment Food & Rural Affairs, August, 2018. Archived June 15, 2021.
- 68Philip Case. โMilk Your Moments campaign reaches millions,โ Farmers Weekly, June 17, 2020. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/UYPGy
- 69โAgriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB),โ LobbyFacts.eu. Archived December 31, 2020. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/9IzDT
- 70
- 71โFrom Plate to Guide: What, why and how for the eatwell model,โ Public Health England. Archived June 15, 2021.
- 72โCurrent members,โ British Nutrition Foundation. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/qeUyg
- 73Philip Case. โMilk Your Moments campaign reaches millions,โ Farmers Weekly, June 17, 2020. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/UYPGy
- 74โAHDB, QMS and HCC respond to CBBCโs Blue Peter Green Badge campaign,โ AHDB, April 13, 2021. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/56RHn
- 75Ben Webster. โBlue Peter drops anti-meat message after farmerโs beef with BBC,โ The Times, April 13, 2021. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/z34wu
- 76Claire Hamlett. โBlue Peter bends to flesh industry bullying,โ Surge, April 14, 2021. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/x7eiJ
- 77Lauren Dean. โMeat tax โincreasingly probableโ to keep within 2degc Paris agreement,โ Farmers Guardian, December 16, 2017. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/b25Nr
- 78โMeat the Facts,โ European Livestock Voice. Archived 14 July 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/aeJnj
- 79
- 80โTransparency Register: Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board,โ EUROPA. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/tS3jL
- 81โAbout the IMS,โ International Meat Secretariat. Archived June 16, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/N8PoV
- 82โPhil Bicknell,โ AHDB. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: โโhttps://archive.ph/wip/XXZm9
- 83โNational Farmersโ Union (UK),โ DeSmog. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/1xbhd
- 84โEnjoy the food you eat We Eat Balanced,โ We Eat Balanced. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/3AJPv
- 85โ17 million consumers informed about health benefits of meat,โ Farmers Guide, July 1, 2020. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/0ivwH
- 86
- 87โCarbon Week: Supply chain requirements โ building a narrative,โ AHDB. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/vRjsL
- 88โTransparency Register: Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board,โ EUROPA. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/tS3jL
- 89
- 90โHome Page,โ EU PiG Innovation Group. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/kmgR2
- 91โPropagating Innovations For More Resilient Dairy Farming in the Atlantic Area,โ Dairy-4-Future. Archived July 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/G8zQz
- 92โHome,โ iSAGE: Innovation for Sustainable Sheep and Goat Production in Europe. Archived June 15, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/wip/ES0ys