Andrew W. Montford
Credentials
- Bsc, Chemistry, St Andrews University.1Bruce Robbins. โBishop Hill: the blogger putting climate science to test,โ The Courier, April 4, 2010.
- Registered Accountant.
Background
Andrew W. Montford is an English writer, editor, chartered accountant, and the voice behind climate change skeptic blog Bishop Hill. He is also the author of The Hockey Stick Illusion (2010). He currently lives in Scotland.
Montford set up the company Anglosphere in 2004 which provides editing services to the publishing industry and business.
Montford was named the Deputy Director of the Global Warming Policy Foundation in 2017.2(Press Release). โANDREW MONTFORD APPOINTED GWPF DEPUTY DIRECTOR,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, May 2, 2016. Archived May 3, 2017. Archive.is URL:https://archive.is/d0Hm7
Montford is also the director of Net Zero Watch, a campaign group launched and managed by the Global Warming Policy Forum (GWPF).3“Who We Are,” Net Zero Watch. Archived October 30, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/K2T5D
Stance on Climate Change
September 29, 2022
In an article titled โThe Headlong Rush to โNet Zeroโ Makes a New Great Depression a Racing Certaintyโ published by The Daily Sceptic, a climate denial blog edited by Toby Young, Montford wrote:4Andrew Montford. โThe Headlong Rush to โNet Zeroโ Makes a New Great Depression a Racing Certainty,โ The Daily Sceptic, September 29, 2022. Archived October 31, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/OnsDZ
โThe man in the street has been led to believe that global warming is a crisis. Make no mistake, this is a lie.โ
He continued, arguing that โthe worst that the climate might throw at us will only cause a small loss of wealthโ and that โthe biggest impacts of climate change – sea-level rise and flooding – can be addressed through simple and relatively cheap adaptation measuresโ.
Montford said that โthe idea of a โclimate emergencyโ is now received opinion, despite the lack of supporting evidenceโ, because of โrelentless scaremongering by green activists and hate campaigns launched against naysayersโ.
Similarly, Montford claimed that the renewables industry and green activists have played a trick on the public by persuading them โthat an energy transition is possibleโ.
He also called environmentalists โthe green blobโ and suggested that the plan to build more offshore windfarms – including โthe peer-reviewed literatureโ in support of them, are โa scam to fool the politicians into keeping the renewables boondoggle goingโ.
He summarised his hypothesis, saying:
โThe public has thus been caught in a pincer movement between two huge lies, and politicians, who only survive if they respond to public concerns, have wasted countless billions on renewables and have strangled the fossil fuel industry, the only sure way of keeping the lights onโ.
April 4, 2010
โI believe that CO2, other things being equal, will make the planet warmer. The six million dollar question is how much warmer. I’m less of a sceptic than people think. My gut feeling is still sceptical but I don’t believe it’s beyond the realms of possibility that the AGW hypothesis might be correct. It’s more the case that we don’t know and I haven’t seen anything credible to persuade me there’s a problem.โ5Bruce Robbins. โBishop Hill: the blogger putting climate science to test,โ The Courier, April 4, 2010.
Key Quotes
August 31, 2024
Montford appeared on GB News where he labelled the Labour government’s net zero plans “dangerous,” calling Ed Miliband and the Labour government “lunatics.”6Ben Chapman. “โFanatics!โ Ed Miliband and Keir Starmer savaged over โdangerousโ net zero plans,” GB News, August 31, 2024. Archived 31, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/Hj1Ev He said:
โKeir Starmerโs plans for net zero are wild and dangerous, I think itโs fair to say. Itโs really going to get quite dangerous. Ed Miliband and Keir Starmer in particular are fanatics on this.โ
Montford also argued that the rollout of renewable energy was driving up energy prices, adding:
โThe more renewables on the grid, the more prices go up. As more capacity comes onto the grid, weโre starting to see period where weโre producing more electricity than we actually need.”
August 23, 2024
In an opinion piece published in Conservative Home, Montford argued that the Conservative Party would continue to lose voter to Reform UK if they stuck with net zero, saying that it was “undoubtedly one of the key factors behind the loss of support to Reform UK.” In the piece he attacks net zero, calling it “economically damaging, and outright irrational.”7Andrew Montford. “Andrew Montford: Reform UK will profit if the Conservatives remain trapped in their Net Zero policy,” Conservative Home, August 23, 2024. Archived September 5, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/gCese
August 23, 2024
In an article published in Spiked, Montford accused the BBC of bias over its climate change reporting, citing a report from Net Zero Watch which claims to have found “more than 30 of the most egregious errors in the BBCโs climate reporting throughout 2023.”8Andrew Montford. “Is there nothing the BBC wonโt blame on climate change?,” Spiked, August 23, 2024. Archived August 28, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/dAVkS Montford concluded the piece by arguing that at the BBC “clearly, activism has almost entirely replaced journalism.”
February 13, 2022
In a Spectator article titled โHow Britainโs fracking industry was regulated into irrelevanceโ, Montford accused environmentalists of launching a โscare campaign against the industryโ, which he characterised as โastonishing in its brazennessโ.9Andrew Montford. โHow Britainโs fracking industry was regulated into irrelevance,โ Spectator, February 13, 2022. Archived May 2, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/j4vqc
He also criticised โenvironmental correspondents across the mainstream mediaโ for relaying information about fracking โto a mostly credulous public, with not a note of doubt raisedโ, before claiming that micro tremors arising from fracking drilling operations were โof a size smaller than a lorry rumbling past your windowโ.
In concluding, he wrongly suggested that windfarms and heat pumps take several decades to build, saying: โEnvironmentalists will say that we should instead build more windfarms and install more heat pumps […] but these projects would take several decades to deliver, so they are of little help in the near futureโ.
February 21, 2021
Montford wrote an article for The Spectator which stated:10Andrew Montford. โThe good news on climate,โ The Spectator, February 21, 2021. Archived February 25, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/S7Fo1
โAs I watch the snow blow past my window, itโs hard not to scoff at the idea of a โclimate emergencyโ. However, Iโm probably in a minority. The idea that we are currently experiencing a dangerous deterioration in our weather has been pushed so hard, and for so long, that the man in the Clapham Uber is now thoroughly convinced.โ
Elsewhere in the article, he wrote:
โGlobal warming doesnโt seem to have damaged crops either. The food supply continues to grow, with fossil-fuel-derived fertilisers and the beneficial effects of higher carbon dioxide levels delivering new record yields across the globe almost every year.โ
Montford cited a paper written by science policy analyst Dr. Indur Gokhlany in the Global Warming Policy Foundation, which stated that: โThe detrimental effects of carbon dioxide and fossil fuels are overwhelmed by other concurrent changes that are beneficial.โ11Indur M. Goklany. โImpacts of Climate Change: Perception and Reality,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation. Archived February 25, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/vOZKB
June 12, 2019
In an article for the Conservative Woman, a right-wing blog closely linked to the anti-BBC group, News-watch, Montford attacked alleged bias from the BBC on the issue of climate change and energy policy, writing:12Andrew Montford. โThe BBCโs biased guide to renewable energy,โ Conservative Woman, June 12, 2019.Archived June 19, 2019. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/e4SbB
โIn the political bubble, every major political party is hell-bent on driving us on to their centrally planned renewable future, regardless of the cost.โ
โโฆ like so many trips to promised lands, you can be sure that the journey to a renewables-powered future will exact a heavy cost.โ
August 24, 2010
โโฆ of course mankind has always affected the climate. If I had my time over again, I would have made this point more clearly. I don’t think you can get away from the radiative physics arguments for AGW. It seems likely to me that it has some effect, but as I tried to make clear in my 10 secs, we just don’t know how big.โ13โNewsnight reactions,โ Bishop Hill, August 24, 2010.
โThe CRU disclosures demonstrate that the peer review process can be subverted by a small but influential group of scientists.โ14โMemorandum submitted by Andrew Montford (CRU 36),โ Parliament.uk, February, 2010.
Key Actions
August 1, 2022
During the Conservative leadership election, TCW published an article by Andrew Montford titled, โEnergy: Is reality starting to dawn?โ in which he wrote: โone canโt help but wonder if members of the Green Blob have belatedly started to come to terms with the scale of the disaster they have unleashed upon the country.โ15Andrew Montford. โEnergy: Is reality starting to dawn?โ, TCW, August 1, 2022. Archived August 8, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/Wkdf9
He continued:
โThe web of green measures that are quickly strangling the economy and driving households into penury were put in place in response to the Climate Change Act […] Repealing the Act may therefore be the single most important step for the new administrationโ.
Otherwise, Montford wrote, โthe Climate Change Act will continue to grind British families into the dustโ.
July 25, 2022
A Spectator article co-written by Benny Peiser and Andrew Montford titled โCan the new PM survive the looming winter energy disaster?โ outlined their support for Kemi Badenoch and Suella Bravermanโs โdesire for meaningful changeโ after they both called for a โsuspension of net zero targetsโ during the Conservative leadership election.16Benny Peiser and Andrew Montford. โCan the new PM survive the looming winter energy disaster?โ The Spectator, July 25, 2022. Archived July 25, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/4XOow
Peiser and Montford continued by arguing that climate and energy policy โhas been built on the unfair demonisation of dissentersโ and that while โmost people assume that climate and environment policy emerge at the end of some rational decision-making processโ, we are, they claim, โin the grip of an irrational race to the bottomโ.
They also agreed with the statement that โonly a rapid return to fossil fuels will be able to stave off civil unrest and economic disasterโ and accused the UK government of โa fit of virtue signallingโ for allowing a recently closed coal-fired power station to be demolished.
They concluded by calling on the next Prime Minister, Liz Truss or Rishi Sunak, to โbe the one who frees the economy from the green shackles that are threatening to bring the country to its kneesโ.
April 25, 2021
Montford wrote an article for The Telegraph criticising the governmentโs plans for a โGreen Industrial Revolution,โ to achieve net zero carbon emissions by 2050, stating that it could be โthe white elephant to end all white elephants.โ17Andrew Montford. โNet zero is a disaster waiting to happen.โ The Telegraph, April 25, 2021. Archived April 26, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/trUDj
Criticising proposals to deliver 40 GW of offshore wind power by 2030, Montford wrote: โDecarbonisationโs big secret is that we still have no zero-carbon technology that can balance the electricity grid when it is driven by offshore wind farms.โ He added: โContrary to common belief, batteries are not even a plausible solution, and hydrogen is so absurdly expensive as to make its use unacceptable.โ
April 14, 2021
Montford wrote an article for the Global Warming Policy Foundation criticising the costs of offshore wind subsidies, which the government had implemented as part of a strategy to achieve a 40 GW wind power target by 2030. He described the Beatrice offshore wind farm, located off the north east coast of Scotland, as a โfinancial basketcase,โ stating: โThe subsidy is of course an ongoing payment, so electricity bill payers are going to have to continue to cough up on the same scale far into the future.โ 18Andrew Montford. โHornsea and the ocean of offshore windfarm subsidies,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, April 14, 2021. Archived April 19, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.ph/Yq7pm
April 1, 2021
Montford wrote an article for Spiked arguing that public concern about the impact of climate change was much lower than predicted, and that the dangers of climate change had been overestimated. He wrote: โNet Zero is already negatively impacting on the economy, and the fear spread by the green doom-mongers is harming our mental health and faith in the future.โ19Andrew Montford. โClimate alarmism is misleading the public,โ Spiked, April 1, 2021. Archived April 6, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/iONJZ
Montford cited a press release from the Global Warming Policy Foundation, which showed the results of a poll by market research consultancy Savanta ComRes, commissioned by the GWPF. The poll found that โthere is also a significant minority of the public who say they are โnot veryโ or โnot at allโ concerned by climate change.โ20(Press Release.) โPerceptions of climate impacts at odds with scientific data,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, April 1, 2021. Archived April 6, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/5qrRH
April 1, 2021
Montford wrote an article for The Conservative Woman commenting on a hearing in which Helen Quayle, policy officer for charity the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds, had warned the House of Lords Environmental Committee about the dangers of offshore wind farm expansion for marine life. Montford wrote: โPerhaps, after all these years, they are getting close to confronting the evidence of the harm their support for wind farms has done to birds.โ He concluded the article: โIf we are going to cause an environmental catastrophe, I suppose we should at least record all the gory details.โ21Andrew Montford. โThe RSPB, wind farms and a change of direction,โ The Conservative Woman, April 1, 2021. Archived April 6, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/v8cKQ
March 8, 2021
Montford wrote an article for The Spectator which commented on revelations that the government had misled the public about the cost of reaching net zero carbon emissions by 2050. An email from the Treasury to then-Chancellor Phillip Hammond, published after a two year freedom of information dispute, said it considered an estimate for the annual cost of decarbonisation by the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy as โmore realisticโ than the government-backed estimate published by the Climate Change Committee: ยฃ70 billion, as opposed to ยฃ50 billion. However, it said the cost of transition was โhighly uncertainโ.22Andrew Montford. โThe hidden cost of Net Zero,โ The Spectator, March 8, 2021. Archived March 9, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/iVl77
Montford criticised the governmentโs spending plans, writing: โForcing taxpayers and consumers to spend sums like this seems the height of economic and social foolishness.โ He added: โTo do so only to deliver a world in which you will not know from one moment to the next whether there will be any energy to heat your home or even to keep the lights on defies comprehension.โ
March 2, 2021
Montford wrote an article for The Conservative Woman stating that he would never again vote for the Conservative Party, which he argued had been taken over by green ideologues. He cited a paper written in the Global Warming Policy Foundation by its energy editor John Constable, which criticised a Statutory Regulation implemented in April 2019 making it illegal for businesses to misreport their carbon dioxide emissions. Montford said: โThe idea that criminal offences can be introduced in this way is monstrous, of course, and something that might once have been seen as a feature of banana republics rather than developed nations.โ23Andrew Montford. โWhy Iโll Never Vote Tory Again,โ The Conservative Woman, March 2, 2021. Archived March 2, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/kK4BZ 24John Constable. โA Little Nudge With A Big Stick,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation. Archived February 23, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/xeMod
Elsewhere in the article, Montford wrote: โIโve voted Conservative all my adult life, but having read Constableโs paper, itโs hard to imagine doing so again. If I wanted authoritarian, collectivist environmentalism, I would have voted for Caroline Lucas and the Greens.โ
March 1, 2021
Montford wrote an article for The Conservative Woman, which commented on criticisms that climate science fact checking website Climate Feedback had made of an article written by Breitbart columnist James Delingpole. The article cited a report written for the Global Warming Policy Foundation by long-time analyst at the US Interior Department Dr Indur Goklany. Climate Feedback had claimed that Delingpoleโs article โincludes several inaccurate claims and cherry-picks information in a way that misleads readers about the scientific understanding of climate change.โ25Andrew Montford. โThe farcical climate โfact-checkersโ who donโt check facts,โ The Conservative Woman, February 25, 2021. Archived March 1, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/jtr3H 26โBreitbart article makes numerous false claims about the impacts of climate change, based on Global Warming Policy Foundation post,โ Climate Feedback, February 12, 2021. Archived February 22, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/1LQZR 27James Delingpole. โStudy Disputes that Earth is in a Climate Emergency,โ Breitbart, February 7, 2021. Archived February 9. 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/SI1Xp
Montfordโs article described Climate Feedbackโs criticisms as โa hasty, amateur hit-job,โ adding: โBut this car crash of an article does at least allow us to see that misrepresentation and deception have become the tool-in-trade of the internet fact-checker. It allows us to see these people for what they are.โ
November 27, 2020
Montford wrote a report for the GWPF questioning the cost implications of decarbonising public transport, which stated that: โpoliticians seem to agree that battery electric vehicles (BEVs) are the way forward, although without apparently having considered the challenges involved.โ28Andrew Montford. โCost of decarbonising cars,โThe Global Warming Policy Forum. Archived November 30, 2020. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/US8CE
An article accompanying the report quoted Montford disputing the costs associated with electric vehicles. Montford stated: โSeveral aspects of EVs make them more costly than petrol cars โ the need to renew batteries, the time wasted at charging points, the need to find alternative transport when their range is inadequate. Thatโs only going to get worse as electricity prices soar in future. We could easily see the cost of motoring double. The working classes are going to be driven off the roads.โ29โMotorists face ยฃ700 billion bill for going electric,โ The Global Warming Policy Forum, November 27, 2020.Archived November 30, 2020. Archive.vn URL:https://archive.vn/pizdu
October 6, 2020
Montford criticised a pledge by Boris Johnson that the UK would become โthe world leader in clean wind energyโ, after the PM pledged that investment in offshore wind farms would generate enough electricity to power every home in the UK by 2030.
Writing in The Spectator, he claimed the implications for business and households in the UK were โhorrifyingโ. He asked: โWho would want to live in a country that was set on such a destructive path? Who would want to invest in it? And when the Prime Minister claims that heโs going to create 60,000 jobs with his green spending spree, you have to wonder how many jobs he will destroy along the way. We can only hope and pray that he is playing to the crowd again.โ30Andrew Montford. โBorisโs wind power pledge wonโt be cheapโ, The Spectator, October 6, 2020. Archived October 6, 2020. Archive URL:https://archive.vn/El32g 31โBoris Johnson: Wind farms could power every home by 2030โ, BBC News, October 6, 2020. Archived October 8, 2020. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/d1RrD
April 6, 2020
Writing in The Conservative Woman, GWPF Deputy Director Andrew Montford stated that โwith the data refuting the climatologistsโ predictions so clearly, it isnโt time that hydrologists shifted their attention away from prophecies of doom, and back on to making a real contribution to peopleโs lives?.โ Montford, arguing that the amount of water vapour in the air was only increasing at a third of the rate predicted by the IPCC, denied that droughts or increased flooding could result from an intensification of the hydrological cycle.32Andrew Montford. โFlood and drought predictions donโt hold water,” The Conservative Woman, April 6th 2020. Archived September 7, 2020. Archive URL: https://archive.fo/HoFyg
March 5, 2020
In an article for The Conservative Woman, Montford disputed that polar bear numbers are dwindling as a result of climate change, writing that they โcontinue to be a tool for politically motivated activists and green-minded scientists who, it is clear, they are happy to deceive and mislead to advance their causeโ.33Andrew Montford. โPolar bear disaster? Show us the evidence!โ The Conservative Woman, March 5, 2020. Archived December 15, 2020. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/4Jn7P
Montford cited a paper written by Susan Crockford for the GWPF, which claimed that:34Susan Crockford. โState of the Polar Bear Report 2019,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation. Archived December 15, 2020. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/lrJL1
โIt can hardly be claimed that lack of sea ice is causing Western and Southern Hudson Bay polar bear numbers to decline as a result of poor cub survival and reduced weights of adult females when breakup and freeze-up dates have been so advantageous for the last three years.โ
February 24, 2020
Montford authored a paper for the GWPF titled โยฃ3 Trillion and Countingโ (PDF), which summarised a series of four reports on the cost of the UK reaching โNet Zeroโ emissions. The paper claimed that attempting to meet the 2050 net-zero target in the way the governmentโs Committee on Climate Change and National Grid envisaged, will โdo more harm than goodโ and concluded by suggesting that renewables โrepresent a monumentally expensive dead endโ.35Andrew Montford. โยฃ3 Trillion and Countingโ (PDF), The Global Warming Policy Foundation, 2020. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog. 36โCost of โNet Zeroโ Will Be Astronomical, New Reports Warn,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, February 24, 2020. Archived February 25, 2020. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/ocScu
At the same time, a second paper authored by Montford was published which covered two alternative technologies for reducing carbon emissions instead of what it called the UKโs โextremely sillyโ wind and solar-centric policy โโsmall-scale nuclearโ, which involves putting a system of smaller reactors in factories, and the use of carbon dioxide from fossil fuels to drive turbines. Montford concluded the paper by suggesting we are at โthe threshold of a revolution in the way we generate electricityโ. He went on to say:37Andrew Montford. โReducing Emissions Without breaking the bankโ (PDF), The Global Warming Policy Foundation, 2020. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
โNot a manufactured revolution, like the one that has brought the environmental horrors of wind and solar, and has filled the pockets of rent-seekers at the expense of everyone else, but a real revolution that makes power cheaper and more reliable, and one that rewards innovation and risk-taking rather than political influence. What a pity it would be if we were to cover our landscapes with unreliable wind turbines at just the moment when a better way forward emerged.โ
The GWPF reports and subsequent coverage were strongly criticised for being misleading.38Simon Evans. โThe UK is aiming for net-zero emissions by 2050 Because climate change is โthe greatest and most pressing challenge facing the modern worldโ (UK govt Jan20) But what will it cost to get there? Letโs take an โhonestโ look at the evidence, shall we? (source,โ Tweet by @DrSimEvans, February 25, 2020. Retrieved from Twitter.com. Archived .png on file at DeSmog.
October 15, 2019
Montford wrote an article for the right-wing blog site the Conservative Woman claiming that renewables subsidies were costing UK households an average of ยฃ340 each. The article was based on a post by the GWPF‘s Energy Editor John Constable.39Andrew Montford. “On your utility bill, the soaring price of green gesture politics,โ Conservative Woman, October 15, 2019. Archived October 15, 2019. Archive.fo URL:http://archive.fo/TCPXx
He ended by saying:
โItโs worth remembering why we are doing this. Itโs certainly not going to make any difference to the Earthโs temperature: our carbon dioxide emissions are a tiny fraction of the global total, and smaller than annual increases in China and India. No, we are doing this as a gesture: a way to show our leadership on climate change, setting an example to the rest of the world.โ
In August, the GWPF announced one of the editors of the Conservative Woman, Kathy Gyngell, had joined its board of trustees.40Richard Collett-White. โCambridge Professor and Anti-BBC Campaigner Join Board of Climate Science Denial Campaign Group,โ DeSmog, August 9, 2019.
April 9, 2019
Montford wrote an article for The Spectator, claiming that a famous scene in a new documentary by David Attenborough, showing walruses falling off a cliff as a result of shrinking Arctic sea ice, was โnot quite what it seems.โ Called the programme โan eight-part, multi-million pound fundraiserโ for the environmental organisation WWF, which co-produced it, Montford refers to work by well-known climate science denier, Susan Crockford.41Andrew Montford. โHas Netflixโs Our Planet hidden the real cause of walrus deaths?โ The Spectator, April 9, 2019. Archived April 24, 2019. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/2zcvi
The Global Warming Policy Foundation has published a number of pieces of work by Crockford, largely revolving around Crockford’s claim that polar bear populations are โcontinuing to thriveโ and changes in their populations are not linked to climate change. Crockford has worked for the free-market, Koch-funded thinktank the Heartland Institute and gave a presentation to the 2019 annual meeting of the Canadian climate science denial group, the so-called Friends of Science.
A similar article by the director of the GWPF, Benny Peiser, was published on the Conservative Woman website.42Benny Peiser. โAttenborough and a shaggy walrus story,โ Conservative Woman, April 10, 2019. Archived April 24, 2019. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
The director of the documentary explained the โheartbreakingโ scene in a Telegraph article.43Joe Shute. โOur Planetโs director reveals the heartbreaking truth behind its dying walrus scene,โ The Telegraph, April 9, 2019.Archived April 24, 2019. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/hUoBl
March 15, 2019
Montford was invited onto BBC Scotland’s โNineโ news programme on the day of a global climate strike by school students. The move led to green groups refusing to appear on the show and the segment was eventually cancelled.44Mike Small. โComment: The BBC Broke More Than its Editorial Guidelines in Inviting a Climate Science Denier to Discuss the School Strikes,โ DeSmog, March 18, 2019.
On the same day, the Global Warming Policy Forum, campaigning wing of the Global Warming Policy Foundation, re-published a 2014 report by Andrew Montford and John Shade, entitled โClimate Control: Brainwashing In Schools,โ which argued that โeco-activismโ was being given โfree rein in many UK schools.โ The report warned:45Andrew Montford, John Shade. โClimate Control: Brainwashing In Schools,โ Global Warming Policy Forum, March 15, 2019. Archived March 19, 2019. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/YiYh6
โThere are clear grounds for very serious concern. We therefore call upon the Secretary of State for Education and his counterparts in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland to undertake urgent inquiries into climate change education in our schools.โ
Michael Gove, then Education Secretary, said he had โread with concernโ the report, with a spokesperson of his saying:46Daniel Martin. โHeads are breaking the law if they preach eco agenda, warns Gove: Education Secretaryโs โconcernโ at report that accuses โactivistโ teachers,โ Daily Mail, April 10, 2014. Archived March 11, 2019. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/kj2gC
โSchools should not teach that a particular political or ideological point of view is right โ indeed it is against the law for them to do so.โ
The report includes a foreword by Professor Terence Kealey, then vice-chancellor of the private University of Buckingham. Kealey joined the GWPF as chair of a so-called international temperature data review project in April 2015, with the aim of investigating the reliability of current temperature data. It was accused of attempting to create a โfake controversyโ ahead of the Paris climate summit later in the year by Bob Ward, policy and research director at the London School of Economics’ Grantham Institute on Climate Change and the Environment.47Ben Tufft. โLeading group of climate change deniers accused of creating โfake controversyโ over claims global temperature data may be inaccurate,โ The Independent, April 26, 2015.Archived March 26, 2019. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/bIk9R
November 23, 2017
After the GWPF published a book by Bernie Lewin titled โSearching for the Catastrophe Signal: The Origins of The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change,โ Montford interviewed the book’s author in a GWPF video (see below).48โSearching for the Catastrophe Signal: The Origins of The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change,โ Amazon.co.uk. Accessed December 4, 2017. 49โThe Climate Policy Cart Led Climate Science Horse,โ YouTube video uploaded by user GWPF, November 23, 2017. Archived .mp4 on file at DeSmog.
โIt was only when the IPCC was threatened with alienation from the climate treaty process that it suddenly concluded โa discernible human influence on global climate,โ the GWPF press release reads.50โNEW BOOK: CLIMATE POLICY CART LED CLIMATE SCIENCE HORSE,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, November 23, 2017. Archived with FreezePage December 4, 2017.
November 25-26, 2011
Montford appeared at EIKE‘s International Climate and Energy Conference in Munich, Germany. His speech was on โClimategateโ and the Hockey Stick graph.51โAndrew Montford, Bishop Hill blog,โ YouTube Video. Uploaded by user EikeKlimaEnergie, April 2, 2012.
The European Institute for Climate and Energy is a German climate skeptic organization with possible connections to the Committee for Constructive Tomorrow (CFACT).
September 2010
Montford was commissioned by the Global Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF) to write an inquiry into the โClimategateโ e-mails. He was compensated ยฃ3000 for his services, and GWPF released the results in September, 2010.52Andrew Montford. โThe Climategate Inquiries,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, September 14, 2010. Archived January 24, 2016. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmogBlog. 53Fred Pearce. โMontford lands some solid blows in review of โclimategateโ inquiries,โ The Guardian, September 14, 2010.
Three British enquiries, one by the House of Commons Science and Technology Committee, one an independent panel chaired by Lord Oxburgh, and an independent review led by Sir Muir Russell, had all exonerated CRU scientists from any misconduct or fraud before GWPF insisted on the additional effort.
According to Montford’s own report, the other three enquiries were โrushed, cursory and largely unpersuasive.โ He also criticizes the enquiries’ lack of climate change skeptics on their panels, despite the fact that at least one known climate change skeptic, Graham Stringer, was present.
Montford could not be ignorant of this fact, as he recorded a conversation with Stringer on his blog, who he described as โthe sole dissenter from the majority opinion represented by the report.โ54โA chat with Graham Stringer,โ Bishop Hill, April 10, 2010.
The GWPF also submitted a Memorandum by Nigel Lawson and Benny Peiser, while Andrew Montford submitted one of his own.
March 2010
Montford released The Hockey Stick Illusion, published by Stacey International.
The book received mixed reviews. RealClimate concluded that โthe real goal of those whose story Montford tells is not to understand past climate, itโs to destroy the hockey stick by any means necessary.โ55โThe Montford Delusion,โ RealClimate, July 22, 2010.
The Guardian also examined Montford’s book and found numerous โglaring inaccuraciesโ that would be cause โto treat with some scepticism Montford’s assessment of the validity of the inquiries into the hacked email messages.โ56Bob Ward. โDid climate sceptics mislead the public over the significance of the hacked emails?โ, The Guardian, August 19, 2010.
Alastair McIntosh, writing for the Scottish Review of Books, concluded that โMontfordโs analysis might cut the mustard with tabloid intellectuals but not with most scientists. The Hockey Stick Illusion might serve a psychological need in those who can’t face their own complicity in climate change, but at the end of the day it’s exactly what it says on the box: a write-up of somebody elseโs blog.โ57Alastair McIntosh. โReviews: THE HOCKEY STICK ILLUSION,โ Scottish Review of Books, Volume Six, Issue Three (2010).
According to a review by Geoscientist, โMontford’s book presents McIntyre’s case, complete with speculations about his opponents’ motives, and gives little space to the detailed rebuttals provided by Mann and his co-authors. Indeed Montford admits in his Preface that the book grew out of a summary of postings on McIntyreโs blog ‘Climate Audit’. This explains the bias in his story.โ58Bob Ward. โNot so jolly hockey stick,โ Geoscientist, Vol. 20, Number 10 (October, 2010). Retrieved from The Geological Society website.
The book received positive reviews from sources including Matt Ridley in The Spectator and Christopher Booker in The Telegraph.
September 2006
Andrew Montford began posting at his blog Bishop Hill.
While the blog first focused on British politics, it later devoted a large portion of coverage to โClimategate,โ and Montford has since called his site โone of the main websites for global warming sceptics in the UK.โ59โMemorandum submitted by Andrew Montford (CRU 36),โ Parliament.uk, February, 2010.
Montford said that his interest in the issue surrounding the โHockey Stickโ graph was piqued when he came across Climate Audit, a website run by Steve McIntyre โ a climate change skeptic and past mining-industry executive.60Bruce Robbins. โBishop Hill: the blogger putting climate science to test,โ The Courier, April 4, 2010.
Affiliations
- Global Warming Policy Foundation (GWPF) โ Deputy Director. Previously commissioned to perform โClimateGateโ enquiry61(Press Release). โANDREW MONTFORD APPOINTED GWPF DEPUTY DIRECTOR,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, May 2, 2016. Archived May 3, 2017. Archive.is URL:https://archive.is/d0Hm7 62James Randerson. โโClimategateโ inquiries were โhighly defectiveโ, report for sceptic thinktank rules,โ The Guardian, Septebmer 14, 2010.Archived May 3, 2017. Archive.is URL:https://archive.is/dpfep
- Anglosphere โ Helped start company in 2004.
- Bishop Hill โ Owner and blogger.
Social Media
- @ADissitient on Twitter.
Publications
Andrew Montford has never published an article in a peer-reviewed journal.
His most notable publication has been his 2010 book The Hockey Stick Illusion, published by Stacey International.
Other Resources
- โ‘Climategate’ inquiries were ‘highly defective’, report for sceptic thinktank rules,โ The Guardian, September 14, 2010.
- โQuestions for Climategate boss facing MPs,โ Channel 4 News, March 1, 2010.
- โAndrew Montford,โ SourceWatch profile.
- โAndrew Montford,โ Wikipedia entry.
- โThe Hockey Stick Illusion,โ Wikipedia entry.
- Matt Ridley. โThe Global Warming Guerrillas,โ The Spectator, February 3, 2010. Archived January 24, 2016.
Resources
- 1Bruce Robbins. โBishop Hill: the blogger putting climate science to test,โ The Courier, April 4, 2010.
- 2(Press Release). โANDREW MONTFORD APPOINTED GWPF DEPUTY DIRECTOR,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, May 2, 2016. Archived May 3, 2017. Archive.is URL:https://archive.is/d0Hm7
- 3“Who We Are,” Net Zero Watch. Archived October 30, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/K2T5D
- 4Andrew Montford. โThe Headlong Rush to โNet Zeroโ Makes a New Great Depression a Racing Certainty,โ The Daily Sceptic, September 29, 2022. Archived October 31, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/OnsDZ
- 5Bruce Robbins. โBishop Hill: the blogger putting climate science to test,โ The Courier, April 4, 2010.
- 6Ben Chapman. “โFanatics!โ Ed Miliband and Keir Starmer savaged over โdangerousโ net zero plans,” GB News, August 31, 2024. Archived 31, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/Hj1Ev
- 7Andrew Montford. “Andrew Montford: Reform UK will profit if the Conservatives remain trapped in their Net Zero policy,” Conservative Home, August 23, 2024. Archived September 5, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/gCese
- 8Andrew Montford. “Is there nothing the BBC wonโt blame on climate change?,” Spiked, August 23, 2024. Archived August 28, 2024. Archive URL: https://archive.is/dAVkS
- 9Andrew Montford. โHow Britainโs fracking industry was regulated into irrelevance,โ Spectator, February 13, 2022. Archived May 2, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/j4vqc
- 10Andrew Montford. โThe good news on climate,โ The Spectator, February 21, 2021. Archived February 25, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/S7Fo1
- 11Indur M. Goklany. โImpacts of Climate Change: Perception and Reality,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation. Archived February 25, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/vOZKB
- 12Andrew Montford. โThe BBCโs biased guide to renewable energy,โ Conservative Woman, June 12, 2019.Archived June 19, 2019. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/e4SbB
- 13โNewsnight reactions,โ Bishop Hill, August 24, 2010.
- 14โMemorandum submitted by Andrew Montford (CRU 36),โ Parliament.uk, February, 2010.
- 15Andrew Montford. โEnergy: Is reality starting to dawn?โ, TCW, August 1, 2022. Archived August 8, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/Wkdf9
- 16Benny Peiser and Andrew Montford. โCan the new PM survive the looming winter energy disaster?โ The Spectator, July 25, 2022. Archived July 25, 2022. Archive URL: https://archive.ph/4XOow
- 17Andrew Montford. โNet zero is a disaster waiting to happen.โ The Telegraph, April 25, 2021. Archived April 26, 2021. Archive.ph URL: https://archive.ph/trUDj
- 18Andrew Montford. โHornsea and the ocean of offshore windfarm subsidies,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, April 14, 2021. Archived April 19, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.ph/Yq7pm
- 19Andrew Montford. โClimate alarmism is misleading the public,โ Spiked, April 1, 2021. Archived April 6, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/iONJZ
- 20(Press Release.) โPerceptions of climate impacts at odds with scientific data,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, April 1, 2021. Archived April 6, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/5qrRH
- 21Andrew Montford. โThe RSPB, wind farms and a change of direction,โ The Conservative Woman, April 1, 2021. Archived April 6, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/v8cKQ
- 22Andrew Montford. โThe hidden cost of Net Zero,โ The Spectator, March 8, 2021. Archived March 9, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/iVl77
- 23Andrew Montford. โWhy Iโll Never Vote Tory Again,โ The Conservative Woman, March 2, 2021. Archived March 2, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/kK4BZ
- 24John Constable. โA Little Nudge With A Big Stick,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation. Archived February 23, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/xeMod
- 25Andrew Montford. โThe farcical climate โfact-checkersโ who donโt check facts,โ The Conservative Woman, February 25, 2021. Archived March 1, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/jtr3H
- 26โBreitbart article makes numerous false claims about the impacts of climate change, based on Global Warming Policy Foundation post,โ Climate Feedback, February 12, 2021. Archived February 22, 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/1LQZR
- 27James Delingpole. โStudy Disputes that Earth is in a Climate Emergency,โ Breitbart, February 7, 2021. Archived February 9. 2021. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/SI1Xp
- 28Andrew Montford. โCost of decarbonising cars,โThe Global Warming Policy Forum. Archived November 30, 2020. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/US8CE
- 29โMotorists face ยฃ700 billion bill for going electric,โ The Global Warming Policy Forum, November 27, 2020.Archived November 30, 2020. Archive.vn URL:https://archive.vn/pizdu
- 30Andrew Montford. โBorisโs wind power pledge wonโt be cheapโ, The Spectator, October 6, 2020. Archived October 6, 2020. Archive URL:https://archive.vn/El32g
- 31โBoris Johnson: Wind farms could power every home by 2030โ, BBC News, October 6, 2020. Archived October 8, 2020. Archive URL: https://archive.vn/d1RrD
- 32Andrew Montford. โFlood and drought predictions donโt hold water,” The Conservative Woman, April 6th 2020. Archived September 7, 2020. Archive URL: https://archive.fo/HoFyg
- 33Andrew Montford. โPolar bear disaster? Show us the evidence!โ The Conservative Woman, March 5, 2020. Archived December 15, 2020. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/4Jn7P
- 34Susan Crockford. โState of the Polar Bear Report 2019,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation. Archived December 15, 2020. Archive.vn URL: https://archive.vn/lrJL1
- 35Andrew Montford. โยฃ3 Trillion and Countingโ (PDF), The Global Warming Policy Foundation, 2020. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 36โCost of โNet Zeroโ Will Be Astronomical, New Reports Warn,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, February 24, 2020. Archived February 25, 2020. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/ocScu
- 37Andrew Montford. โReducing Emissions Without breaking the bankโ (PDF), The Global Warming Policy Foundation, 2020. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 38Simon Evans. โThe UK is aiming for net-zero emissions by 2050 Because climate change is โthe greatest and most pressing challenge facing the modern worldโ (UK govt Jan20) But what will it cost to get there? Letโs take an โhonestโ look at the evidence, shall we? (source,โ Tweet by @DrSimEvans, February 25, 2020. Retrieved from Twitter.com. Archived .png on file at DeSmog.
- 39Andrew Montford. “On your utility bill, the soaring price of green gesture politics,โ Conservative Woman, October 15, 2019. Archived October 15, 2019. Archive.fo URL:http://archive.fo/TCPXx
- 40Richard Collett-White. โCambridge Professor and Anti-BBC Campaigner Join Board of Climate Science Denial Campaign Group,โ DeSmog, August 9, 2019.
- 41Andrew Montford. โHas Netflixโs Our Planet hidden the real cause of walrus deaths?โ The Spectator, April 9, 2019. Archived April 24, 2019. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/2zcvi
- 42Benny Peiser. โAttenborough and a shaggy walrus story,โ Conservative Woman, April 10, 2019. Archived April 24, 2019. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmog.
- 43Joe Shute. โOur Planetโs director reveals the heartbreaking truth behind its dying walrus scene,โ The Telegraph, April 9, 2019.Archived April 24, 2019. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/hUoBl
- 44Mike Small. โComment: The BBC Broke More Than its Editorial Guidelines in Inviting a Climate Science Denier to Discuss the School Strikes,โ DeSmog, March 18, 2019.
- 45Andrew Montford, John Shade. โClimate Control: Brainwashing In Schools,โ Global Warming Policy Forum, March 15, 2019. Archived March 19, 2019. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/YiYh6
- 46Daniel Martin. โHeads are breaking the law if they preach eco agenda, warns Gove: Education Secretaryโs โconcernโ at report that accuses โactivistโ teachers,โ Daily Mail, April 10, 2014. Archived March 11, 2019. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/kj2gC
- 47Ben Tufft. โLeading group of climate change deniers accused of creating โfake controversyโ over claims global temperature data may be inaccurate,โ The Independent, April 26, 2015.Archived March 26, 2019. Archive.fo URL: http://archive.fo/bIk9R
- 48โSearching for the Catastrophe Signal: The Origins of The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change,โ Amazon.co.uk. Accessed December 4, 2017.
- 49โThe Climate Policy Cart Led Climate Science Horse,โ YouTube video uploaded by user GWPF, November 23, 2017. Archived .mp4 on file at DeSmog.
- 50โNEW BOOK: CLIMATE POLICY CART LED CLIMATE SCIENCE HORSE,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, November 23, 2017. Archived with FreezePage December 4, 2017.
- 51โAndrew Montford, Bishop Hill blog,โ YouTube Video. Uploaded by user EikeKlimaEnergie, April 2, 2012.
- 52Andrew Montford. โThe Climategate Inquiries,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, September 14, 2010. Archived January 24, 2016. Archived .pdf on file at DeSmogBlog.
- 53Fred Pearce. โMontford lands some solid blows in review of โclimategateโ inquiries,โ The Guardian, September 14, 2010.
- 54โA chat with Graham Stringer,โ Bishop Hill, April 10, 2010.
- 55โThe Montford Delusion,โ RealClimate, July 22, 2010.
- 56Bob Ward. โDid climate sceptics mislead the public over the significance of the hacked emails?โ, The Guardian, August 19, 2010.
- 57Alastair McIntosh. โReviews: THE HOCKEY STICK ILLUSION,โ Scottish Review of Books, Volume Six, Issue Three (2010).
- 58Bob Ward. โNot so jolly hockey stick,โ Geoscientist, Vol. 20, Number 10 (October, 2010). Retrieved from The Geological Society website.
- 59โMemorandum submitted by Andrew Montford (CRU 36),โ Parliament.uk, February, 2010.
- 60Bruce Robbins. โBishop Hill: the blogger putting climate science to test,โ The Courier, April 4, 2010.
- 61(Press Release). โANDREW MONTFORD APPOINTED GWPF DEPUTY DIRECTOR,โ The Global Warming Policy Foundation, May 2, 2016. Archived May 3, 2017. Archive.is URL:https://archive.is/d0Hm7
- 62James Randerson. โโClimategateโ inquiries were โhighly defectiveโ, report for sceptic thinktank rules,โ The Guardian, Septebmer 14, 2010.Archived May 3, 2017. Archive.is URL:https://archive.is/dpfep