UVA Defends Against Ken Cuccinelli Attacks On Climate Science and Academic Freedom

Brendan DeMelle DeSmog
onOct 21, 2010 @ 14:40 PDT

The University of Virginia has filed two new responses in its ongoing court battleย fending off Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelliโ€™s politically-motivated witch hunt against climate scientist Michael Mann. ย UVA correctly alerts the court that crazy Cuccinelliโ€™s โ€˜investigationโ€™ is โ€œan unprecedented and improper governmental intrusion into ongoing scientific researchโ€ [PDF of filing].

Cuccinelliโ€™s relentless campaign to waste Virginia taxpayer moneyย attacking Mann continues, despite a total lack of evidence of any wrongdoing on UVAโ€™s or Mannโ€™s part. Instead the row hinges entirely on Cuccinelliโ€™s zeal to pollute public discourse with his own climate denial, clogging the courts with a thinly veiled attack on academic freedom that the Washington Post labeled โ€œa pernicious fishing expedition.โ€ ย 

UVA argues that Cuccinelliโ€™s latest demand for documents related to Mannโ€™s research repeats the exact same arguments that Albemarle County Circuit Court Judge Paul Peatross rejected in August. ย Cuccinelli merely recycled his previous non-starter of a complaint in an ongoing effort to woo the Tea Party and stoke the fire for his ambitions to run for higher office.

The Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS)ย examined Cuccinelliโ€™s original argumentsย and confirms they have been recycled again to further harass Mann and his colleagues.

โ€œScientists are proud of UVA for standing up to this relentless rubbish,โ€ said Francesca Grifo, director of UCSโ€™s Scientific Integrity Program. โ€œThis investigation has never been about fraud or the facts. Cuccinelli is abusing his power to fight a public relations war against scientific findings.โ€


UVA also issued a second filing [PDF]ย asking the county court to suspend the case while the Virginia Supreme Court resolves an appeal Cuccinelli filed seeking to overturn the August ruling rejecting his investigation on the basis that it โ€œlacked an objective basis.โ€ The university correctly suggests that putting the case on hold would save the court system time and money because the cases involve the same parties and the same arguments. UVA already has spent $350,000 fighting Cuccinelliโ€™sย investigation.ย 

โ€œUVA realizes more than anyone โ€“ save perhaps Michael Mann โ€“ what a waste of time and resources this investigation has become,โ€ Grifo said. โ€œItโ€™s ironic that Ken Cuccinelli, who so vociferously opposes increased government spending, can waste taxpayer money with anย entirelyย gratuitousย investigation.โ€

Brendan DeMelle DeSmog
Brendan is Executive Director of DeSmog. He is also a freelance writer and researcher specializing in media, politics, climate change and energy. His work has appeared in Vanity Fair, The Huffington Post, Grist, The Washington Times and other outlets.

Related Posts

onDec 16, 2025 @ 12:11 PST

New data show American capital now controls most of Canadaโ€™s oil and gas sector while jobs vanish, royalties lag, and billions flow south.

New data show American capital now controls most of Canadaโ€™s oil and gas sector while jobs vanish, royalties lag, and billions flow south.
onDec 16, 2025 @ 03:07 PST

Salmon wagons and boat trips for schoolkids distract from environmental damage, say campaigners.

Salmon wagons and boat trips for schoolkids distract from environmental damage, say campaigners.
onDec 15, 2025 @ 13:16 PST

Emails obtained by DeSmog show county officials continually met privately with Project Sail lobbyists, something denied to local residents opposing the $17 billion data center.

Emails obtained by DeSmog show county officials continually met privately with Project Sail lobbyists, something denied to local residents opposing the $17 billion data center.
onDec 12, 2025 @ 12:55 PST

As Trump pushes to slash the EPAโ€™s budget to its lowest level in four decades, 15 years of state-level cuts have already hollowed out environmental enforcement across the country.

As Trump pushes to slash the EPAโ€™s budget to its lowest level in four decades, 15 years of state-level cuts have already hollowed out environmental enforcement across the country.