California Farmers File Suit Alleging Oil Companies' Faulty Wastewater Injection Caused Crop Loss

picture-14309-1371183830.jpg
onSep 23, 2014 @ 14:00 PDT

A farming company in Kern County, California, hasย sued four oil producersย over claims that their faulty wastewater injection methods led to the contamination of groundwater it uses for irrigation.

Palla Farms LLC, a ninety-two-year-old family farm operation, says it had to tear out hundreds of cherry trees due to high levels of salt and boron in the groundwater it has used to irrigate its crops for the past 25 years. The company claims its almond orchard has also experienced production declines.

Palla Farms’ suit alleges that the four oil companiesโ€”Crimson Resource Management Corp., Dole Enterprises Inc., E&B Natural Resources Management Corp. and San Joaquin Facilities Management Inc.โ€”violated state environmental regulations when disposing of produced water, drilling mud, and flowback water from fracking, which led to the contamination of the groundwater.

The Bakersfield Californian has the details on theย allegations:

Using aging and sometimes faulty injection wells, Palla alleges, the defendants disposed of water materials in violation of government rules for disposal operations. Its suit says Dole failed to report the pressure at which it was injecting fluids and neglected to conduct annual mechanical integrity tests.

Crimson not only failed to properly report injection pressure at 15 of its 18 disposal wells, Palla claims, but in well data the company did provide, the company apparently used excessive pressure.

The lawsuit also says the oil companies neglected to conduct a review to make sure there were no idle water wells nearby. In fact, Palla says there were three such wells within 200 feet of its farm and 20 or more within two miles.

The four companies also failed to provide fluid treatment plans, chemical analyses of liquid being injected or geological studies, all of which the suit says are required by law.

The lawsuit said the defendants knew or should have known their actions may have caused harm because of a 2011 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency audit finding California injection well operations were not up to federal groundwater protection standards.

Contamination of water sources from fracking operations has become an issue very much pushed to the forefront of the debate as California’s epic drought continues unabated.

On July 7, for instance, California’s Division of Oil, Gas and Geothermal Resources issued a shutdown order to seven different energy companies saying that they may have injected wastewater into aquifers that could be a source of drinking water,ย  posing a โ€œdanger to life, health, property, and natural resources.โ€

Environmental activists in the Golden State are calling on Governor Jerry Brown to put a stop to water-intensive fracking, claiming that it is making the drought worse.

Image Credit: NEW YORK CITYOCTOBER 19 2013: Food & Water Watch sponsors a rally against fracking in New York City by a katz /ย Shutterstock.com

picture-14309-1371183830.jpg
Mike Gaworecki is a San Francisco-based journalist who writes about energy, climate, and forest issues for DeSmogBlog and Mongabay.com. His writing has appeared on BillMoyers.com, Alternet, Treehugger, Change.org, Huffington Post, and more. He is also a novelist whose debut โ€œThe Mysticistโ€ came out via FreemadeSF inย 2014.

Related Posts

As the New York-based firm was preparing to work on the climate summit, it was also pushing for Brazilian oil and gas distributor Vibra Energia to help power it.

As the New York-based firm was preparing to work on the climate summit, it was also pushing for Brazilian oil and gas distributor Vibra Energia to help power it.
onNov 20, 2025 @ 16:02 PST

Trade groups lobbied ministers to promote a source of energy linked to massive environmental harms at the U.N. climate conference.

Trade groups lobbied ministers to promote a source of energy linked to massive environmental harms at the U.N. climate conference.
Analysis

Agribusiness companies generate huge quantities of greenhouse gas pollution โ€” and PR companies help them obscure it.

Agribusiness companies generate huge quantities of greenhouse gas pollution โ€” and PR companies help them obscure it.
onNov 19, 2025 @ 11:10 PST

Students from around the world attended the lobby groupโ€™s carbon capture curriculum at the University of Regina in July.

Students from around the world attended the lobby groupโ€™s carbon capture curriculum at the University of Regina in July.