To Save the Amazon, Lula Must Defeat an Old Foe

Brazilโ€™s next president will need to confront the ideological legacy of the Instituto Millenium, a think tank that played a leading role in Bolsonaro’s finance ministry and helped justify his rollback of environmental protections.
Analysis
Rich
on
Brazilian president-elect Luiz Inรกcio Lula da Silva speaking at a conference in Spain last year. Credit: Casa de Amรฉrica (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)

In his first speech after staging a stunning political comeback at Brazilโ€™s presidential elections, Luiz Inรกcio Lula da Silva vowed to halt the Amazon deforestation that surged under outgoing rival Jair Bolsonaro. 

In order to succeed, Lula wonโ€™t just need to face down farmers, loggers, and miners. He will also have to win a battle of ideas.

While libertarian think tanks have been a familiar feature of the North American and British political landscape for decades, Brazilโ€™s homegrown equivalents have risen to prominence more recently. 

Promoting a similar form of radical free-market economics to their English-speaking cousins, these groups provided the intellectual foundation for Bolsonaroโ€™s dismantling of environmental protections. Their international allies range from climate science denying organisations to former UK Prime Minister Liz Truss

None of Brazilโ€™s think tanks has been more influential during Bolsonaroโ€™s four-year presidency than Rio de Janeiro-based Instituto Millenium, or IMIL.

โ€œThey not only help shape the government’s economic policies, they also construct narratives to legitimise the environmental destruction occurring in Brazil’s main biomes โ€“ mainly in the Amazon,โ€ Carlos Milani, a professor of international relations at Rio de Janeiro State University, told DeSmog.

โ€œThese anti-environment stances also have human rights implications: continuous violations of the rights of the original Indian peoples in the Amazon, who are threatened by the expansion of agribusiness and extractivism in the region,โ€ Milani said.

IMILโ€™s chairman, Sebastiรฃo Ventura P. da Paixรฃo Jr, has cast Bolsonaroโ€™s defeat as a setback for the entire continent, writing that Latin America is โ€œsubmerging into a dangerous regression to socialism, guided by wrong-headed, backward economic ideas that never worked anywhere.”

The think tank has regularly defended Bolsonaroโ€™s moves to open up the Amazon, in line with its free-market philosophy. The former army captain argued that economic development would boost living standards for Indigenous communities, and said it was hypocritical of Western countries to criticise Brazil when they had cleared their own forests centuries ago.

Leading the Finance Ministry

IMIL figures have also played prominent roles in Bolsonaroโ€™s administration. At least eight founders or members of the organisation have served in the right-wing populistโ€™s government, most notably Paulo Guedes, his finance minister and a former student of the free-market economist Milton Friedman. 

Other IMIL members have been given key roles in Guedesโ€™ ministry, leading the drive to privatise state-owned companies such as oil giant Petrobras. 

Ricardo Salles, who used his position as environment minister to weaken policies to protect the Amazon, has also worked with IMIL through his right-wing movement, Movimento Endireita Brasil. Despite being forced to resign last year after obstructing a police investigation into illegal logging, Salles was re-elected in Septemberโ€™s legislative elections.

IMIL has many supporters in the media, too, including Joรฃo Roberto Marinho, executive president of Grupo Globo, Latin Americaโ€™s largest media conglomerate; Antonio Carlos Pereira, a former director of O Estado de S.Paulo (Estadรฃo), Brazilโ€™s third largest newspaper, and columnists at other major newspapers.

Neither IMIL, nor any of its founders or members, responded to DeSmogโ€™s requests for comment.

When DeSmog looked into IMILโ€™s funding, relying on a now-deleted page from its website, we found numerous donors linked to environmentally damaging industries. They include Daniel Feffer, the billionaire vice chairman of Suzano Papel e Celulose, a Brazilian pulp and paper company; Adriano Pires, chief executive of the Centro Brasileiro de Infraestrutura, a lobbying firm for the oil and gas sector; William Ling, who owns logging, plastics, and aluminium companies; and Jorge Gerdau, a steel magnate.

Suzano, the only one of these companies to respond to a request for comment, said it โ€œdoes not maintain any relationship with Instituto Milleniumโ€. A spokesperson said the company had a โ€œstrict zero deforestation policyโ€ as well as โ€œstrong commitments to action on climate changeโ€. A spokesperson for Feffer declined to comment.

Climate Denial

IMIL has been a prominent source of climate misinformation in Brazil, allowing it to downplay the vital role the Amazon plays as a carbon sink regulating the Earthโ€™s climate. The group shares this stance with fellow members of the Atlas Network โ€“ a global free-market umbrella organisation whose supporters have played a key role in promoting climate science denial, aided financially by the fossil fuel industry, with a particular presence in the United States.

Numerous IMIL figures have dismissed climate change โ€“ a stance for which Bolsonaro has faced international criticism during his presidency โ€“ both in articles on IMILโ€™s website and in other public arenas.

Helio Beltrรฃo, a founder of IMIL, columnist at Folha de S.Paulo, board member of fuel distribution company Grupo Ultra, and president of the Instituto Mises Brasil โ€“ another libertarian think tank โ€“ has said there is โ€œno consensusโ€ about the link between carbon dioxide emissions and climate change.

Rodrigo Constantino, another founder, columnist at Gazeta do Povo, and president of the libertarian Instituto Liberal, has accused scientists of deceptively using the term โ€œclimate changeโ€, rather than โ€œglobal warmingโ€, in order to blame all extreme weather events on the phenomenon.

Truss Visit

IMIL has a connection to the UK through Liz Truss, a darling of Britainโ€™s radical pro-business think tanks who resigned as prime minister last month after a tumultuous 44 days in office. Trussโ€™s downfall began shortly after her Chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng announced a โ€œmini-budgetโ€ of unfunded tax cuts. The move, which triggered market turmoil, was widely blamed on the policy prescriptions of groups such as the Institute of Economic Affairs, a long-time ally of Truss and another Atlas Network member.

Truss met with IMIL in April 2018, while serving as chief secretary to the Treasury โ€“ six months before Bolsonaro was elected president. Minutes from the meeting, obtained by DeSmog through a freedom of information request to the British government, show they discussed the upcoming elections, strategies for getting young people involved in politics, and Brazilโ€™s ambition to join the OECD. 

โ€œIt was noted that you donโ€™t need to win everyone over, ideas gain momentum,โ€ the minutes said.

Among the attendees was IMIL co-founder Marcos Troyjo, who went on to become Bolsonaroโ€™s deputy economy minister and special secretary for foreign trade and international affairs. Troyjo is now president of the New Development Bank, a multilateral development bank set up by Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa.

In the wake of the official visit, Truss praised IMIL as โ€œfree-thinkersโ€ in an article headlined โ€œTake heart from Latin American capitalists showing the wayโ€.

Truss wrote of how the UK โ€œstands to benefit from stable friendsโ€ and how Brazil was โ€œworking hard to keep control of their public financesโ€. There was a need to โ€œwork with like-minded allies to spread the messageโ€ of free markets, she said, crediting IMIL with helping to โ€œchange the cultureโ€ in the country. 

Truss did not meet any other political groups during her trip.

Christian Poirer, programme director at the Amazon Watch advocacy group, told DeSmog it was โ€œoutrageousโ€ for Truss to meet a think tank like IMIL. โ€œThe UK should have no role in promoting climate denial or the deregulation of the Amazon,โ€ he said.

One other item on Trussโ€™s itinerary was a trip to a multi-million pound research institute jointly-funded by Anglo-Dutch oil giant Shell that promotes natural gas and biofuels as sustainable, followed by a visit to an oil rig โ€œsimulatorโ€ run by Petrobras.

UK oil companies Shell and BP have major interests in Brazil, particularly in the vast deepwater reserves off the countryโ€™s southeast coast. Their growing presence, facilitated in part by lobbying from the UK government, has been warmly welcomed by Paulo Guedes.

The UK has also supported Brazilโ€™s Petrobras through its export credit agency โ€“ including two credits issued between 2018 and 2020 worth more than ยฃ300 million in total.

A Cabinet Office spokesperson declined to confirm whether Truss had had any contact with IMIL since her meeting or answer a series of other questions about the trip, saying that the government โ€œremains fully committed to its transparency agenda and releases more proactive publications than ever beforeโ€.

Old Foes

IMILโ€™s global links will come as little surprise to Lula, who has been squaring off against the think tank since his first stint as president from 2003-2011. 

Originally called the Instituto de Estudos da Realidade Nacional, or the Institute of National Reality Studies, the organisation was launched in 2005 with the express intention of countering Lulaโ€™s popular embrace of left-wing policies. 

In those days, there were only a handful of right-wing think tanks in Brazil. By the time Lulaโ€™s successor, Dilma Rousseff, was impeached in 2016, there were more than 30, according to Camila Vidal, professor of international relations at the Federal University of Santa Catarina. 

IMIL follows the model of many U.S. groups in advocating a mix of economic liberalism and social conservatism, while seeking academic backing and disseminating its ideas through magazines, newspapers, and increasingly social media, Vidal said. 

Numerous publications from the group reviewed by DeSmog support environmentally damaging activities and criticise efforts to tackle them. Recent publications argue that agribusinesses have nothing to do with widely-reported fires across the Amazon; that Brazil is a leader in protecting the environment and that international green organisations give it an unwarranted level of attention; that Brazilian cattle ranching suffers intense โ€œprejudice and misinformationโ€, including around its well-known contribution to climate change; and that greater investment is needed in fossil fuels. 

By contrast, no articles critical of Amazon deforestation in recent years have come up in the course of Vidalโ€™s research.

Pedro Allemand, a Ph.D. candidate at the Pontifical Catholic University of Rio de Janeiroโ€™s Institute of International Relations, said IMIL provides โ€œthe discourse and the narratives to sweep environmental destruction under the carpetโ€.

โ€œTheir position as a think tank allows them to offer justifications for the dismantling of the environmental preservation apparatus, even if they are not directly involved in the activities,โ€ he said.

While Lulaโ€™s victory has kindled hopes that the Amazon may yet be saved from irreversible damage, his government will have to contend with the influence of IMIL and other think tanks who have proved so influential in shaping Bolsonaroโ€™s policies.

โ€œWe are not interested in a war for the environment,โ€ Lula โ€“ whose time in office wasnโ€™t without criticism in this area โ€“ said on Sunday night. โ€œBut we are ready to defend it from any threat.”

Additional research by Lucas Araldi.

Rich
Rich was the UK team's Deputy Editor from 2020-22 and an Associate Editor until September 2023. He joined the organisation in 2018 as a UK-focused investigative reporter, having previously worked for the climate charity Operation Noah.

Related Posts

Future nature talks must be protected from โ€œintense industry pressureโ€ say campaigners.

Future nature talks must be protected from โ€œintense industry pressureโ€ say campaigners.
on

As Prime Minister Justin Trudeau once said back in 2015, โ€˜the atmosphere doesnโ€™t care where carbon is emitted.โ€™

As Prime Minister Justin Trudeau once said back in 2015, โ€˜the atmosphere doesnโ€™t care where carbon is emitted.โ€™
on

Immad Ahmed explains how "human-centered design" is helping displaced people in South Sudan and Bangladesh overcome daunting odds.

Immad Ahmed explains how "human-centered design" is helping displaced people in South Sudan and Bangladesh overcome daunting odds.
on

Oil and gas majors are splashing the cash in order to have a presence at the flagship climate talks in Azerbaijan.

Oil and gas majors are splashing the cash in order to have a presence at the flagship climate talks in Azerbaijan.