On Januaryย 7, 2021, Energy Transfer was notified by its insurer, Westchester Fire Insurance Co. of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, that it had lost a $250,000 surety bond for the Dakota Access pipelineย (DAPL) โ a bond that Iowa, one of the four states it passes through, required the pipeline toย maintain.
That loss of insurance coverage comes as the Biden administration and a federal court each mustย confront a decision about whether to order DAPL to shut down, after a federal appeals court last week upheld a lower courtโs finding that the oil pipelineย still lacks a completed environmental review. Financial observers have been watching DAPL closely โ and a new report warns that DAPL is hardly alone in the oil and gas pipeline industry in facing major financial risks linked to projects’ environmentalย impacts.
โDakota Access Pipeline has no federal easement. It’s now losing insurance coverage on the state-level which is a requirement for Iowa’s state permit,โ the Indigenous Environmental Network said in a Januaryย 29 statement. โItโs time to end this saga and do whatโsย right.โ
Environmentalists predicted that the lost insurance coverage could be difficult for Energy Transfer to replace, particularly given DAPLโs incomplete federal review. โIt will be difficult because the bond holder will require the pipeline to comply with all legal requirements,โ attorney Carolyn Raffensperger, director of the Science and Health Network, told DeSmog. โIf it is operating without a permit, any spill would be a big, big legalย problem.โ
But as consequential as the DAPL fight โ which has raged for roughly a half-decade โ might be, Dakota Access is just one of hundreds of pipelines worldwide that a new report finds are at risk of early abandonment because theyโre โon a collision courseโ with climateย agreements.
The report, titled โPipeline Bubble 2021โ and published by the climate data nonprofit Global Energy Monitor, warns that pipeline construction projects worldwide have put $1 trillion worth of pipeline investment at risk of being rendered obsolete by the energy transition away from fossilย fuels.
The risky projects include over 131,000 miles of pipe, both oil pipelines like DAPL and โ to an even higher degree โ new natural gas pipelines. โ18 of the 20 longest pipelines in development and 82.7% of all pipelines in development globally will carry gas,โ the report finds, โreflecting the fossil fuel industryโs success in perpetuating the myth that gas can be a โbridge fuelโ to a clean energyย future.โ
Permian ‘Carbonย Bomb’
When it comes to the U.S. oil and gas industry, Global Energy Monitor’s report zeroes in on the productive Permian Basin straddling Texas and New Mexico, an oil and gas playย which it calls a potential โcarbon bomb,โ adding that by 2050, Permian gas โwould consume ten percent of the worldโs allowable carbon budget if we are to have a 50/50 chance of limiting global warming toย 1.5ยฐC.โ
The report adds that there are over 100 institutions providing financial support for the industry in the U.S. Permian Basin alone, including major backers based in Japan, France, the Netherlands, Canada, and the UK, as well as U.S. banks like Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan Chase, and Morgan Stanley. The authors tallied $102.3 billion in debt financing for the Permian Basinโs pipelines and gas export facilities alone sinceย 2014.
Enterprise WAHA gas plant in Reeves County, Texas.ย Credit:ย ยฉ2020ย Justinย Hamel
โThe ability of the oil and gas industry to overcome near-term challenges to its Permian Basin expansion plans, such as the COVID-19 pandemic and the collapse of prices, will depend in part on the appetite of banks and governments to continue funding midstream infrastructure,โ they wrote. โShould they decide to do so, it will be in spite of the industryโs long-term decline and growing concerns over the global climateย emergency.โ
The investment risks are compounded by fossil fuel divestment pressure from investors and financial institutions, which are increasingly wary of projects that fail to take climate risks into account โ a wariness the report predicts may growย beyond coal, Arctic drilling, and tar sandsย projects.
Just four major financial institutions (BNP Paribas, Rabobank, UniCredit, and US Bancorp) have restricted pipeline finance, the report finds โ so far. โFor the first time, exclusions affecting the entire spectrum of oil and gas extraction activities appeared in 2020, announced by Suncorp Group and Government Pension Fund Global (GPFG),โ Pipeline Bubble 2021 said. โBut examination of the policies of other institutions suggests that the scope is likely soon to widen to include pipelines and otherย infrastructure.โ
In January, the world’s largest investment fund manager, BlackRock, warned corporate executives that it would ditch investments in companies that fail to disclose plans to reach โnet zeroโ carbon emissions by 2050 โ though The Guardian reported that announcement only covers BlackRock’s โactively managedโ investments, representing about $616 billion of the firm’s $8.7 trillion under management, allowing the firm to retain major oil, gas, and coal investments.
Toll Booth on a Closingย Highway
The U.S. pipeline industry, often referred to as the โmidstreamโ oil and gas industry, was once marketed to investors as a safe bet, like running the โtoll boothโ on the shale rushโs highway. This past year, it’s been temporarily rocked by the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, which has led to pipeline construction deferrals and delayed start-ups.
โDuring 2020, developers completed 3,600 km [2,236 miles] of oil pipelines and 9,619 km [5,977 miles] of gas pipelines, or an overall average of 1,102 km [684 miles] per month for oil and gas pipelines combined,โ the report found. โThe decline in pipeline completions parallels a general financial decline in private-sector oil company balance sheets and market valueโ sinceย 2008.
The pandemic has also forced U.S. drillers to slow their activities. โThe rig count is less than half of what it was,โ RBN analyst Jason Ferguson told trade publication Natural Gas Intelligence in January. โProducers are not out spending, and the historical relationship of how many wells will be drilled at this price hasย changed.โ
EagleClaw’s East Toyah cryogenic processing plant for natural gas liquids in Reeve’s County, Texas. Credit:ย ยฉ2020ย Justinย Hamel
The pandemicโs impacts, Global Energy Monitor said, are expected to be temporary and may create little long-lasting deterrence to pipeline construction. โOverall, however, the expansion curve has been bent rather than broken, with pipelines continuing to enjoy both policy support and financial support by governments and major financial institutions,โ the Pipeline Bubble 2021 reportย said.
But the pipeline industry has also faced a political backlash that has created upheaval for the industry. โIntense opposition from landowners, [I]ndigenous groups,ย and climate activists is causing the cancellation or delay of high-profile pipelines, andย is changing perceptions of pipelines as a โsafeโย investment,โ Global Energy Monitor found. But worldwide, the report adds, many pipelines are owned by state-owned enterprises, the report adds, leading them to be โsomewhat insulatedโ from market forces, at least in the shortย run.
And the looming energy transition should reduce overall demand for the products carried by pipelines, the report warns. โFor oil, the main threat in the coming decade is the prospect of vehicle electrification, as more governments announce transitions away from internal combustion sales and manufacturers respond by shifting investments toward electric vehicles,โ Global Energy Monitor wrote. โFor gas, change is arriving most rapidly in the power sector, where combinations of renewables, batteries, and demand management now offer equivalent reliability at lower cost than gas-fired powerย plants.
It adds that worldwide, โgas supply chains are lengthening, which means larger investments in infrastructure and greater stranded assets if and when projects stall or are prematurelyย retired.โ
Boom And Bust Andย โฆ
Some energy analysts have been warning for years that the pipeline industry, especially in the Permian Basin, was on track toย over-build.
โIf we donโt overbuild this time, it will be the first time in the history of the industry,โ Wouter van Kempen, Chairman, President, and CEO of DCP Midstream, said at an April 2018 pipeline indusry conference, as DeSmog has previously reported. โThereโs absolutely, we will overbuild, thereโs no doubt aboutย it.โ
That excessive building is already creating financial difficulties, East Daley Capital Advisors reported this year. Those difficulties aren’t primarily from the sprawling network of small โgatheringโ pipelines that connect individual oil and gas wells to the large interstate pipes that form the backbone of the oil and gas transportation network, RBN Energy analyst Housley Carr said as he summarized a January 2021 East Daley report, instead โitโs volume and rate declines on large-diameter, long-haul crude oil and natural gas pipelines owned by midstream giants that present the main challenge to sustainable cash flow health inย aggregate.โ
Dozens of drilling rigs are stacked at the H&P yard in Midland, Texas, after the oil price went negative on April 20, 2020,ย Midland, Texas on May 28, 2020.ย Credit:ย ยฉ2020ย Justinย Hamel
Other forecasters predict that 2021 could bring higher oil prices and a turnaround for the financially struggling U.S. oil and gas industry โ which in turn could revitalize interest in new pipeline projects in the short term. For its part, the U.S. Energy Information Administration predicts that U.S. oil production in 2021 will be 11.1 million barrels a day in 2021, down from 11.3 million per day in 2020, with an average 2021 West Texas Intermediate spot price of $49.70 a barrel โ roughly $10 a barrel higher than the 2020ย average.
But while oil and gas prices might fluctuate in the short run, over the long run, the pipeline industry faces growing questions about whether itโs wise to build a massive network of pipelines that could become obsolete well within their projected 50-year-plusย lifespans.
The reportโs authors called on the Biden administration to carefully consider the ways that the U.S. energy industry has changed since Obama was in office, particularly with regards to natural gas, which is predominantly made up of the powerful greenhouse gasย methane.
โThe policy landscape facing the new administration in 2021 is radically different from the one that Biden left in 2017,โ James Browning, lead author of the report, said. โFossil gas is now recognized as a climate buster, not a climate solution. That means Biden faces the tough decision to rein in gas infrastructure, which is the most effective way to limitย emissions.โ
Main image: Pipeline, April 22, 2010.ย Credit: Ripperda,ย CC BYย 2.0
Subscribe to our newsletter
Stay up to date with DeSmog news and alerts