With the European elections around the corner, populists and right-wing parties are gathering momentum and teaming-up into a pan-Europeanย alliance.
The alliance is being established around a common anti-immigration and eurosceptic ideology but nationalist parties have something else in common: opposition to climateย action.
Research shows that dozens of candidates standing in the election are using climate science denial and anti-climate action rhetoric as a campaignย strategy.
In Germany, Alternative fรผr Deutschland (AfD) has embraced climate science denial to ramp-up support against environmental protection using online smear campaigns against the 16-year-old Swedish activist Gretaย Thunberg.
In Belgium, leader of the Peopleโs Party Mischaรซl Modrikamen, who believes climate change is โthe biggest orchestrated bullshit in the history of humanityโ, has joined ranks with former Trump chief strategist and Breitbart chief Steve Bannon and Italyโs Northern League leader Matteo Salvini to spread populist ideology acrossย Europe.
And from Estonia and Austria to France and the Netherlands, right-wing nationalist parties continue to carry climate science denial into the political conversation. Not all parties deny the scientific evidence behind human-caused climate change, but many have become platforms for such ideas toย spread.
DeSmog looks at where candidates for Europeโs key right-wing populist parties stand on climateย change:
- Alternative fรผr Deutschland (AfD)ย – Germany
- Peopleโs Party – Belgium
- Ukip and the Brexit Party – Unitedย Kingdom
- Party for Freedom (PVV) – Netherlands
- Freedom Party of Austria (FPร) – Austria
- National Rally – France
- Lega Nord – Italy
- Danish Peopleโs Party (DF) – Denmark
- Swedish Democrats – Sweden
- EKRE – Estonia
- Law and Justice Party (PiS) – Poland
- Fidesz –ย Hungary
- Freedom and Direct Democracy – Czechย Republic
- Vox – Spain
Alternative fรผr Deutschland (AfD) – Germany
Since entering Germanyโs parliament two years ago on an anti-Muslim and anti-immigration manifesto, the AfD has embraced climate science denial as a new campaign strategy.
Its election manifesto denies human-induced climate change and claims that rising levels of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has meant โworld food harvests have increasedย significantlyโ.
โWe doubt that man has significantly influenced or even managed the recent climate change, in particular the current warming. Climate protection policy is therefore a mistake,โ the manifestoย states.
As such, the AfD rejects โall EU measures that justify the reduction of CO2 emissions with the protection of the climateโ, including the Paris Agreement, which it describes as a โshift of funds from the highly industrialized countries to underdevelopedย countriesโ.
Most recently, the AfD has conducted a targeted smear campaigns against the climate school strike movement and the 16-year-old Swedish activist Gretaย Thunberg.
Climate change barely got a mention on the AfDโs social media channels when the party was founded in 2013. But it mentioned climate change more than 900 times in the past year alone, mainly promoting anti-Thunberg rhetoric, according to a joint investigation by the counter-extremism organisation the Institute for Strategic Dialogue (ISD) and Greenpeaceโsย Unearthed.
Party chairman Jรถrg Meuthen, the lead candidate standing in the election, has repeatedly attacked Green politics and described climate change as โa replacement religion of all left green world parties and patronisersโ.
Meuthen repeatedly accused those that want climate action of โGreta hypeโ, labelling them โCO2 believing disciplesโ.
Maximilian Krah, another AfD candidate, also targeted Thunberg 10 times in tweets between December 2018 and April 2019, describing the movement she inspired as a โpsychosisโ and the consequences of a post-Catholic age.
He also compared climate change to homeopathy, claiming the EU could soon declare the latter aย science.
Earlier this year, coal miner Guido Reil, also a candidate, defended the partyโs false claim that carbon dioxide is good for plants and that it is having no impact on theย climate.
The AfDโs anti-climate campaign efforts have been backed by the European Institute for Climate and Energy (EIKE), a German-based climate science denial which is known for co-hosting a climate conference with the Heartland Institute, a US-based think tank which has been at the forefront of denying the scientific evidence for man-made climateย change.
EIKEโs advisory board include Christopher Monckton, a former British politician and advisor to Margaret Thatcher, who was later affiliated with Ukip and a notorious climate scienceย denier.
Peopleโs Party – Belgium
The Peopleโs Party is a primarily Francophone, anti-Islam, right-wing party led by Mischaรซl Modrikamen.
The partyโs lurch to the far-right over the last few years has also seen its stance on climate change radicalised, rejecting climate action as a โcollective hysteriaโ and denying human-induced climateย change.
In a statement from February 2019, the party slammed Belgiumโs decarbonisation policies as โexcessiveโ. It described โthe infinitesimal increase of CO2โ as โby no means a pollutantโ that โallowed the globalized greening of our planet in the last thirty years as well as the yield ofย harvestsโ.
The Peopleโs Party says it is โdeeply attached to our landโ but says it will instead focus โon the real problems: soil pollution by nitrates, plastics in the oceans, excessive urbanisation, permaculture, short production circuits to avoidย wastage.โ
A staunch admirer of Donald Trump, Modrikamen is also an ally of his former chief strategist Steve Bannon. In 2018, Modrikamen re-launched The Movement, a Brussels-based far-right organisation that aims to galvanise far-right populist ideology and anti-EU sentiment, with Bannonโs official backing. The Peopleโs Party is officially affiliated to Theย Movement.
In September 2018, Modrikamen tweeted a picture with Bannon and Matteo Salvini, the leader of Italyโs populist Northern League in Italy, after Salvini joined Theย Movement.
Modrikamen previously shared articles from Bannonโs Breitbart website, written by climate science denier James Delingpole, which accused school climate strikers of being โignorant and manipulatedโ, shared denialist theories about โglobal coolingโ, and called Thunbergโs activism โthe biggest orchestrated bullshit in the history of humanityโ.
Secretary general of the Peopleโs Party and Modrikamenโs wife,Yasmine Dehaene- Modrikamen is also standing in theย election.
Dehaene-Modrikamen has cited the work of some of Europeโs most notorious climate science deniers, including Richard Tol, a former advisor to the UKโs most prominent climate science denying group the Global Warming Policy Foundation, Bjorn Lomborg, a Danish economist who argues it would be too expensive to tackle climate change in a meaningful way and French professor Francois Gervais, who argues that the climate emergency is โaย delusionโ.
Ukip and The Brexit Party – Unitedย Kingdom
Ukip has for long attracted climate science deniers into its ranks. And earlier this year, Ukipโs former leader Nigel Farage, who has a history of spreading misinformation about climate change, launched The Brexit Party to contest the Europeanย elections.
As DeSmog previously reported, the Brexit Party includes a number of opponents to measures to tackle climate change. including Ann Widdecombe, one of five MPs to oppose the Climate Change Act in the UK. Annunziata Rees-Mogg, who advocated investments in the Canadian tar sands and sister of climate science denying Tory MP Jacob Rees-Mogg is also a marquee candidate. She joins chairman of Turning Point UK George Farmer and Welsh MEP Nathan Gill, both of whom have questioned mainstream climate science and the need forย action..
In the meantime, Ukipโs candidates are continuing the partyโs climate science denialย tradition.
Ukip MEPs were among a small band of right-wing members to vote against the ratification by the European Parliament of the Paris Agreement in 2016. The partyโs current manifesto calls for the countryโs 2008 Climate Change Act to be scrapped, and promotes measures to rejuvenate the UKโs coalย industry.
Ukip leader Gerard Batten, also a candidate, has defended Ukipโs policy, suggesting there was no need for โa man-made climate change policyโ. Candidate Alan Graves Senior likewise confirmed the partyโs policy tweeting: โIt is not a case of denying climate change it is more that we do not accept it is allย man-madeโ.
And Ukip MEP Stuart Agnew previously described global warming as โa scamโ and used a series of cold winters to justify his belief that global warming is notย happening.
Other candidates in the elections, including Paul Oakley, Richard Braine, and Richard Elvin have also touted climate scienceย denial.
Party for Freedom (PVV) – Netherlands
Party for Freedom (PVV) is best known for the aggressive anti-immigration and anti-Islam rehtoric of its leader, Geert Wilders.
But the partyโs stance on climate change is no less zealous. The PVV argues that there is no independent evidence that humans cause climate change and slams the work of the IPCC as unable to prove thatย relationship.
It objects to climate action largely on cost grounds โ a blog post on its website claims that โCO2 reduction would be at least 30 times more expensive for the Netherlands than adapting to any occurring climate change.โ Its one-page manifesto for the European elections doesnโt mention climate change but promises โno more money for development, windmills, art, innovation orย broadcastingโ.
According to a report by the environmental think tank Adelphi, PVV MEPs have voted against all EU climate and energy policy proposals tabled in the European Parliament between 2009 and 2018, including the ratification of the Parisย Agreement.
Marcel de Graaff, a PVV MEP since 2014 who is standing again, and co-chair of the right-wing eurosceptic Europe of Nations and Freedom political grouping. He has previously called to โcut the crapโ, put an end to climate and decarbonisation policies and โgreen liesโ.
In a parliamentary question, his colleague, Olaf Stuger, another candidate in the election, argued global warming data had been โgrossly exaggeratedโ and โmanipulatedโ and asked the European Commission to review the EUโs policy on climateย change.
Freedom Party of Austria (FPร) – Austria
For the right-wing nationalists in Austriaโs FPร, climate change is perceived as a globalist threat. The party seeks to end its dependency on imported fossil fuels and transition to domestic and locally available energy sources, including solar, wind, hydrogen andย bioenergy.
However, party members continue to deny human-caused climateย change.
Party chairman Heinz-Christian Strache, a hardliner who pushed the FPร further to the right, has repeatedly argued that it is a natural phenomenon that cannot be prevented. In an 2017 interview with Australian national radio ORF, Strache claimed that โGreenland used to be a green country with vineyards,โ adding that โglobal warming cannot be corrected in the face of increasing solar flares and warming of theย sunโ.
FPรโs leading candidate in the elections, Harald Vilimsky, who has been an MEP since 2014, voted against the ratification of the Paris Agreement. And in March this year, Vilimsky submitted an amendment on proposed legislation to establish an asylum and migration fund, which deleted all mention of the โimportance of tackling climate changeโ, the Paris Agreement and the UN Sustainable Developmentย Goals.
National Rally – France
The National Front, now rebranded as the National Rally, has worked to relinquish its image as an anti-semitic and Holocaust-denying party founded in the 1970s by Jean-Marie Le Pen. Under Marine Le Penโs leadership, the party has worked to green its image and make the environment an issue of nationalย identity.
The party is keen to develop renewable energy sources to end Franceโs dependence on fossil fuel imports, but continues to cast doubt on the human causes of climateย change.
In a 2012 interview, Le Pen declared: โI am not sure human activities are the main source behind the [climate change] phenomenon โฆ The world has seen changes in the climate that had nothing to do with humanย activity.โ
In 2016, National Front MEPs abstained from the vote to ratify the Paris Agreement and have repeatedly abstained or voted against decarbonisation and emission reduction policies in the European parliament, according to research by French newspaper Le Monde.
Breaking with that tradition, the partyโs lead candidate in the election, 23-year-old Jordan Bardella, however, described environmental challenges, together with the immigration, as one of the two key issues of the 21st century. Bardella has so far stayed clear of any direct comments on climate change.ย ย
But others have been more outspoken. Nicolas Bay, former Secretary General of the National Front and co-chair of the Europe of Nations and Freedom group said in a 2017 interview that it is โvery difficult to tell whether, in the long-term, there is warming, to know the share of human activity in causing it and the capacity we [humans] have to influence theseย phenomenaโ.
Asked what he believed was the share of human activity in causing climate change, Bay said: โI think it exists but it may be more limited than sometimes saidโ. In the same interview, Bay rejected the idea he was a climate scienceย denier.
Speaking at the European Parliament in March 2019, MEP Joรซlle Mellin likewise acknowledged that while climate change was โa crucial problemโ for the worldโs inhabitants, climate policy should take into account both human responsibility of a โsavage industrialisation processโ and of โproven natural climateย cyclesโ.
Mellin also said activists had to โstop saying that humans [โฆ] are responsible for everythingโ and โrefute the idea that the Paris Accord is an angel-like solutionโ to the climateย crisis.
Addressing Greta Thunberg during her visit to the EU Parliament, Mellin praised the teenager for raising climate change awareness among her generation but said activists canโt only rely on shock sentences which have no other foundation besidesย emotion.โ
Read more –ย What the Rise of Right-Wing Populism in Europe Means for Climate Scienceย Denial
Lega Nord – Italy
Italyโs nationalist Northern League party is largely disengaged on the issue of climateย change.
Although the party manifesto mentions climate change in the context of developing renewable energy and advocates climate adaptation measures, the topic is mostly absent from official communications, according to research by Adelphi. The party supports an energy transition, energy efficiency measures and a ban on polluting cars with low energy prices a keyย priority.
But Northern League MEPs did vote against ratifying the Paris Agreement in the European Parliament, with MEP Gianluca Pini describing the agreement as a โdownward compromise in continuing to allow Chinese companies and developing countries to compete unfairly with Italian companies, who fully comply with environmentally friendlyย productionโ.
Italyโs deputy prime minister Matteo Salvini, who leads his partyโs list in the elections and is not shy about his support for Donald Trump, strongly opposed the EU parliamentโs recognition of the term โclimate migrantโ, and tweeted: โIt is crazy to exploit a serious subject like climate to legitimise illegalย immigrationโ.
Northern League candidates Mara Bizzotto and Angelo Ciocca have also consistently voted against decarbonisation and climate policies or simply avoided and abstained on environmental and climateย votes.
Danish Peopleโs Party (DF) –ย Denmark
Denmarkโs Dansk Folkeparti (also known as the Danish Peopleโs Party or DF) has seen its position on climate change evolve in recent years. While many of its most high profile members were previously happy to openly tout climate science denial, the partyโs MEPs have shown more willingness to engage with climateย policy.
The partyโs climate spokesperson said in 2018 that he was not convinced climate change was caused by humanย activity:
โI canโt rule out the thesis that they are man-made. But as long as there are reliable researchers who say one thing, and then some others say the other, I do not feel completely convinced that one explanation is more real than theย other.โ
And in August 2018, the partyโs former climate lead, Per Dalgaard, told Radio24 that there is โno one in the Danish Peopleโs Party who believes that climate change isย man-madeโ.
But the partyโs chairman, Peter Skaruup, said in March 2019 that he accepted โthe climate is changing quite markedly quite quicklyโ and that it was โprobablyโ due to humanย activity.
Nonetheless, the first and second candidates on the DFโs candidate list, Peter Kofod and Anders Primdahl Vistisen, have both criticised those that want to see faster climateย action.
In a letter to Information.dk criticising its coverage of DF Youth’s anti-climate action campaign in 2012, Kofodย said:
โThe climate debate in Denmark has created a variegated cluster of climate apostles led by Al Gore โฆ a new religion has come: climate fanaticism, whose warm air preachers include counts Rehling onย Information.โ
And Vistisen was behind a 2012 proposal to suspend the EUโs climate and energy package that seeks to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 20 percent by 2020, which failed to get sufficient support to be considered by the Europeanย Commission.
Swedish Democrats – Sweden
Like Franceโs National Rally and Italyโs Northern League, the Swedish Democrats, a nationalist and anti-immigration party with roots in the countryโs white nationalist movement, acknowledges the causal link between human activity and climate change. But it has repeatedly cast doubt on the risks linked to climateย change.
The partyโs manifesto states that environmental issues are often complex in nature and should be managed in the long term and calls for cooperation within Europe and globally. However, the Swedish Democrats were the only party to oppose the countryโs ambitious climate target to reach net-zero greenhouse gas emissions byย 2045.
Party spokesman Martin Kinnunen previously tweeted that โwarmer climates are positive for the opportunity to grow [food] in Sweden. That is a fact,โ and that one hot summer should not lead to climateย anxiety.
In the European Parliament, MEPs voting record on climate and energy issues has beenย mixed.
EKRE – Estonia
The Conservative People’s Party of Estonia (EKRE) currently has no seats in the European Parliament but doubled its vote in the countryโs national election in March, coming third with 17,8 percent of the vote. The right-wing nationalist party ran on a pledge to protect an โindeigenous Estoniaโ and now forms part of the countryโs coalitionย government.
The party is fielding nine candidates in the European election โ all whiteย men.
On climate change, EKRE leader Mart Helme has been keen to emphasise that Estoniaโs emissions were insignificant compared to the rest of the world. The party rejects the Paris Agreement, which Helme previously described as a โclassic left-wing actionโ.
Like his father, Martin Helme, who is also a candidate in the election, he has argued that there is no convincing evidence for linking human activity to climateย change.
โWe are told that there is a pause in climate warming, and if this long pause can no longer be explained, we simply talk about climate or heat fluctuations, but no one has been able to talk convincingly about what this is and has to do with human activity,โ he said in a 2016 statment.
In the same statement, Helme wrongly claimed that the Paris Agreement does not apply to coal emissions from China, India and the US.
The partyโs 2018 manifesto includes no mention of climate change but says it supports renewable energy provided that it does not increase energy prices for consumers and helps to reduce Estoniaโs energyย imports.
Read more – Meet The Brexit Party’s Climate Scienceย Deniers
Law and Justice Partyย – Poland
Polandโs Prawo i Sprawiedliwoลฤ (Law and Justice Party (PiS)) is a nationalist, pro-coal party that obstructs climate policies at home. However, on the global stage the party is engaged in the UN climate negotiations and considers the Paris Agreement aย success.
Under a PiS-government, Poland hosted last yearโs UN climate talks in Katowice. At the time, PiS Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki hailed Poland a leader in climate protection and PiS spokeswoman and candidate Beata Mazurek warned that โclimate action could not be postponed until laterโ.
However, Mazurekย has significantly less climate ambition at home. In May this year, she defended the partyโs pro-coal position declaring that ending the countryโs reliance on coal would lead to โdrastic rises in energy prices and an economic crisisโ. Poland consumes the second largest amount of coal per year in the EU, with around 80 per cent of its electricity production coming from what is the most polluting fossilย fuel.
PiS has also been a vocal critic of the EUโs climate policies and has repeatedly advocated for non-binding targets and deregulation. In the European Parliament, PiS MEPs voted against the majority of climate and energy proposals, according to research by Adelphi.
Some PiS politicians have also promoted climate scienceย denial.
In an 2018 interview, Tomasz Chruszczow, Polandโs top climate negotiator refused to confirm whether he backed the scientific consensus that human activity is the key driver of climateย change.
And in 2016, Education Minister Anna Zalewska proposed removing climate change and evolution theory from the biology curriculum. In 2014, she told a group of students โthere [was] no global warmingโ.
Fidesz – Hungary
Viktor Orbรกnโs right-wing party Fidesz is one of the few nationalists parties in Europe to actively support the Paris Agreement, partly using it as an excuse to be less ambitious at home.
Speaking in 2017, Prime Minister Orbรกn said: โIn Hungary, there is a consensus that climate change is real, that it is dangerous and since it is a global phenomenon, requires global action toย combat.โ
In 2016, Hungarian President Jรกnos Adรฉr wrote a letter to 10 heads of state from the worldโs top greenhouse gas polluters demanding they set an example and tighten their emissions reduction targets. Hungaryโs parliament then became the first in the EU to ratify the Parisย deal.
But critics and environmental NGOs have accused the Fidesz government of using calls for action on the international stage as an excuse ย to do little atย home.
Kรถvรฉr Lรกszlรณ, speaker of the Hungarian National Assembly, has recently attributed rising public concerns over climate change overtaking concerns about immigration to โthe brainwashing effect of independent and impartial mediaโ.
Freedom and Direct Democracy – Czechย Republic
The Freedom and Direct Democracy party is a staunchly Eurosceptic and anti-immigration party. It currently has no MEPs sitting in the European Parliament, but the party boasts of its links with Franceโs National Rally leader Marine Le Pen and Italyโs Northern League leader Matteoย Salvini.
On climate change, the party-co-founders Radim Fiala and Tomio Okamura, who are overseeing a list of 21 candidates, have sent mixedย messages.
In 2015, deputy leader Fiala, said that โunder the pretext of combating climate change, unprecedented economic atroci-ties are taking placeโ. But party leader Okamura admitted that โthe climate is really changingโ and added it was a question of โhow much a person contributes toย itโ.
The partyโs manifesto does not mention climate change but calls for energy security and the โefficient use of renewableย resourcesโ.
Vox – Spain
Spanish nationalist party Vox is expecting to do well in the European Parliament elections, having won 24 seats in Spainโs national election in April 2019, making it the first far-right grouping to win more than a single seat in congress since Spain returned to democracy inย 1975.
Vox believes that climate change is real and caused by humans, but is reluctant to commit many resources to tacklingย it.
The partyโs first candidate for the European Parliament, Jorge Buxadรฉ, told a recent debate, โthe rest of countries must meet the same commitments as Europeans in the fight against climate change. The current situation is anย injustice.โ
Additional research and reporting by Richard Collett-White and Matย Hope.
Main image credit:ย djsuffixย CC BY–NCย 2.0ย
Subscribe to our newsletter
Stay up to date with DeSmog news and alerts