Court Order Pausing Bayou Bridge Pipeline Only Applies to Path Through Cypress Swamp

Julie-Dermansky-022
on

A federal judgeโ€™s recent order stopping construction of the Bayou Bridge pipeline โ€” though only in Louisianaโ€™sย Atchafalaya Basin โ€” has successfully prevented further sections of the National Heritage Area from being destroyed, forย now.

On February 27, the same day U.S. District Judge Shelly Dick explained her previous weekโ€™s ruling to halt work on the pipeline,ย Dean Wilson, executive director of theย Atchafalaya Basinkeeper,ย surveyed the oil pipeline’s route in the basin. He was relieved to find cypress trees recently identified as โ€œlegacy treesโ€ โ€” ย those which were alive before 1803 โ€” stillย standing.

I spoke to Wilson after he toured the pipeline route. He told me he was relieved to discover much of the routeย through the basinโ€™sย east side still intact. The damage done on the west side was heartbreaking, but at least the pipeline has yet to be put in theย ground, heย said.


Watch: Aerial view of Bayou Bridge pipeline construction through Atchafalayaย Basin

Drone video shot byย Phin Percy, an independent camera operator,ย shows the pipeline route on the west side of the basin, where a swath of trees up to 75 feet deep hasย already beenย pulverized.ย 

In a 60-page decision, Judge Dick clarified her reasoning for granting the request to stop pipeline work in the basin, despite the protest of Bayou Bridge Pipeline LLCโ€™s main owner Energy Transfer Partners. โ€œThe Court finds the temporary delay in reaping economic benefits does notย outweigh the permanent harm to the environment that has been established as a result of the pipeline construction,โ€ย Dickย wrote.ย 

The judge ruled in favor of the environmental groups, which include Atchafalaya Basinkeeper and are represented by EarthJustice, inย theirย lawsuit seekingย to revoke aย U.S. Army Corps of Engineersย permit for the Bayou Bridge pipeline.ย Earthjusticeย argued that running the pipeline throughย the Atchafalayaย Basinย risks permanent and irreparable damage to the basin’s water flow and will destroy old growth cypress trees that would not regrow along the pipelineย route.ย 

The February 27 ruling makes clear that the injunction only halts work on the pipeline in the Atchafalaya Basin. Construction along the rest of the 162.5-mile route, which began in January, can continue.ย The Bayou Bridge pipelineโ€™s proposed route from Lake Charles to St. James, Louisiana, is set to cut through the Atchafalaya Basin, a National Heritage Area and theย countryโ€™s largest river swamp. The next question for the courts is whether Energy Transfer Partners will be forced to reroute the pipeline to avoid the environmentally sensitiveย basin.

Old growth cypress tree saved in the Atchafalaya Basin
One of the old growth cypress trees saved by the injunction on the Atchafalaya Basinโ€™s eastย side.

Wilson told me that detouring the pipeline around the basin couldย preserveย the environmentally sensitive area. He estimated such a detour might be roughly 65ย miles.

Alexis Daniel, a spokesperson for Energy Transfer Partners, which is also behind the Dakota Access pipeline, wouldnโ€™t comment on whetherย the company has considered re-routing the pipeline following theย judgeโ€™s ruling,ย citingย pendingย litigation.ย 

โ€œBayou Bridge Pipeline respectfully disagrees with the District Courtโ€™s ruling that the Army Corps of Engineers did not properly consider the limited impacts of construction in the Atchafalaya Basin during the extensive [National Environmental Policy Act] process the Corps conducted,โ€ย according to a statement Daniel provided. The company plans โ€œto seek immediate relief from this decision in the appropriateย courts.โ€

According to Energy Transfer Partners, โ€œThe Corps issued two comprehensive environmental assessments, both of which had a โ€˜Finding of No Significant Impact to the Basin.โ€™โ€ And its lawyers pointed out that the permit compels the company to restore the basin’s โ€œpre-existing wetland contours and conditionsโ€ after completingย construction.

At the same time, Judge Dick wrote that the Corps failed to demonstrate it took a โ€œhard lookโ€ at โ€œcumulativeโ€ environmental impacts, including those in the past and future. โ€œThe Corps’ and (company’s) myopic view that they are only required to consider the impacts of this singular project is not consistent with the regulations or applicable jurisprudence,โ€ sheย wrote.

The lawsuitย Earthjustice filedย against the Corpsย in federal court on January 11 alleges that the Corps is not enforcing existing permits for oil and gas pipeline companies already operating in the basin. Considering this weekโ€™s ruling, Earthjusticeโ€™s lawsuit may need to be heard before the injunction isย lifted.

That lawsuit also contends that the Corpsโ€™ assessment wasnโ€™t the onlyย oneย needed before the agency could issue a permit, claiming that an Environmentalย Impact Study (EIS) was needed first. An EIS is required by the National Environmental Policy Act for actions that significantly affect the quality of the environment and is used as a tool for federal agencies to assess theย environmental effects of their proposed actions prior to makingย decisions.

Who Is Monitoring Construction of the Bayou Bridgeย Pipeline?

Rick Boyett, Chief Public Affairs Spokesperson for the Corps, listed the agencies responsible for monitoring construction of theย pipeline.

โ€œMultiple agencies, such as the Pipeline and Hazardous Material Safety Administration (PHMSA), Office of Pipeline Safety (OPS), LaDEQ [Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality], and DNRย [The Department of Natural Resources]ย will also beย overseeing the construction of the pipeline. Additionally, tribal monitors will be onsite during construction,โ€ he wrote in anย email.

I followed up with the state and federal agencies Boyett listed, asking what their roles might be in pipeline constructionย projects.

Gregory Langley, spokesperson for LDEQ, said, โ€œLDEQ does not have a specific role in oversight of the construction ofย pipelines.โ€ย 

As for DNR, the agency is only involved with the โ€œapproximately 17-mile section of the project that is within the Coastal Zone,โ€ according to Patrick Courreges, DNRโ€™s public affairsย spokesperson.ย 

Boyett wonโ€™t say exactly whoย the โ€œtribal monitorsโ€ he mentions are. I asked Earthjustice if the organization knew who the tribal monitors might be. My sources told me they checked with everyone they could think of, but no one knew who might play a role in monitoring theย construction.

PHSMA has yet to clarifyย its role in overseeing the installation of the Bayou Bridge pipeline. Darius Kirkwood, a representative with PHMSA, emailed me on January 29, saying that they were working on getting me an answer, but the agency has been non-responsive since then.ย 

Despite the apparent ambiguity around which agencies should be overseeing this project, the pipelineโ€™s construction is not going unobserved. The environmental groups involved in the lawsuit against the Corps, along with the Louisiana Bucket Brigade and participants in the L’eau Est La Vie (Water is Life)ย protest camp, have taken to monitoring the pipelineโ€™s installation on theirย own.ย 

โ€œWe have reports from our members that construction on Bayou Bridge Pipeline is filling in Bay Barron and Crocodile Bayou with sediment. This is illegal according to construction permits,โ€ Scott Eustis of Gulf Restoration Network, which is involved in the lawsuit, told me via email. โ€œThe flow of water needs to beย restored to the Atchafalaya Basin to bring this sediment to the coast.โ€ย ย 

Dean Wilson reported to the Corps that he found a pile of branches left by construction workers that blocks a bayou. And Cherrie Foytlin, a founder of the Lโ€™eau Est La Vie camp, contacted the Corps after she found oil sheen in wetlands next to a site she monitored near the basinโ€™s westย side.

โ€˜Water Protectorsโ€™ Push Back Against Pipelineย Construction

Activists hang a sign on Bayou Bridge pipeline construction equipment to stop work
Direct action taken to shut down construction of the Bayou Bridge pipeline inย Belle Rose, Louisiana, outside of the Atchafalaya Basin.

Three activists were arrested by police after refusing to get off a piece of pipeline during a Bayou Bridge protest
Three people removed by police after refusing to get off a piece of pipeline during aย protest against the Bayou Bridgeย pipeline.

Meanwhile, direct actions against the oil pipeline project have begun. On February 26, around two dozen protesters calling themselves โ€œwater protectorsโ€ shut down a construction site outside of the Atchafalaya Basin for two hours. Three of them were arrested after refusing police orders to disperse and were charged with resisting arrest and trespassing. They were released, pending hearings set in May, according to Renate Heurich with the climate justice group 350 New Orleans, who also took part in the directย action.ย 

Main image: Rae-Lynn Cazelot of the United Houma Nation, holding a sign during a protest at a Bayou Bridge pipeline construction site. Credit: All photosย ยฉ Julieย Dermansky

Julie-Dermansky-022
Julie Dermansky is a multimedia reporter and artist based in New Orleans. She is an affiliate scholar at Rutgers Universityโ€™s Center for the Study of Genocide and Human Rights. Visit her website at www.jsdart.com.

Related Posts

Future nature talks must be protected from โ€œintense industry pressureโ€ say campaigners.

Future nature talks must be protected from โ€œintense industry pressureโ€ say campaigners.
on

As Prime Minister Justin Trudeau once said back in 2015, โ€˜the atmosphere doesnโ€™t care where carbon is emitted.โ€™

As Prime Minister Justin Trudeau once said back in 2015, โ€˜the atmosphere doesnโ€™t care where carbon is emitted.โ€™
on

Immad Ahmed explains how "human-centered design" is helping displaced people in South Sudan and Bangladesh overcome daunting odds.

Immad Ahmed explains how "human-centered design" is helping displaced people in South Sudan and Bangladesh overcome daunting odds.
on

Oil and gas majors are splashing the cash in order to have a presence at the flagship climate talks in Azerbaijan.

Oil and gas majors are splashing the cash in order to have a presence at the flagship climate talks in Azerbaijan.