Clash Over the Bayou Bridge Pipeline Ratchets up After Louisiana Pipeline Explosion

Julie-Dermansky-022
on

On February 13 environmental advocates urged Louisiana agencies to deny permits for theย Bayou Bridge pipeline at aย press conference in front of the Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) office in Batonย Rouge.ย 

Five days earlier, a Phillips 66ย natural gas pipeline in Paradis, Louisiana, exploded, presumably killing one worker andย injuring two. The explosion occurredย one night after the Louisianaโ€™s Department of Natural Resources (DNR) held a public permit hearing for the Bayou Bridge oil pipeline at a community center in Napoleonville,ย Louisiana.

Fire blazes at the site of a Phillips natural gas pipeline explosion in Louisiana
Fire continued raging February 10, the day after an explosion at a Phillips 66 natural gas pipeline in Paradis,ย Louisiana.

Anne Rolfes holds a newspaper while talking about a pipeline explosion at a press conference
Anne Rolfes of the Louisiana Bucket Brigade talking about the pipeline explosion at a press conference in front of Louisiana Department of Environmental Qualityโ€™sย office.ย 

Building the Bayou Bridgeย Pipeline

Two permits are required for construction of the Bayou Bridge pipeline, which has been proposed byย Energy Transfer Partners in conjunction withย Phillips 66 and Sunoco Logistics. One isย from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the DEQ, which must sign off on water quality impacts. The second is fromย the DNR for the projectโ€™s last 16 miles of pipeline, which requireย special attention under the stateโ€™s Coastal Zoneย program.

If built, the163-mile-longย pipeline would stretch across south Louisiana from Lake Charles through the Atchafalaya Basin to St. James, a community on the Mississippi River. It would link Louisiana refineries to a major oil-and-gas hub in Texas and connect to larger pipelines throughout North America. The project would be the tail end of Energy Transferโ€™s Dakota Access pipeline, carryingย oil frackedย in North Dakota to Louisiana.ย ย 

The first permit hearing on Januaryย 12 in Baton Rouge seemed like a precursor toย war. Industry brought out its top guns, including former U.S. Senator Mary Landrieu, who testified on behalf of Energy Transfer Partners. Activists describing themselves as โ€œwater protectorsโ€ who came from as far as California warned that if a permit is granted, the battle to stop the pipeline could turn the Atchafalaya Basin into the next Standingย Rock.ย 

A man holding a t-shirt in support of the Bayou Bridge pipeline
Supporters of the pipeline giving out t-shirts that support the Bayou Bridge pipeline project before the second permit hearingย began.ย 

Two law enforcement officers stand among the stands of pipeline opponents holding signs at a permit hearing
Law enforcement officers next to pipeline opponents at the Louisiana DNR‘s permit hearing for the Bayou Bridge projectย on Februaryย 8.ย 

The Dividingย (Pipe)line

Tensions were even higherย at the second public permit hearing on February 8 in Napoleonville, Louisiana. At times, civil discourse broke downย completely.ย 

Bayou Bridge pipeline manager Cary Farber speaks at the hearing
Bayou Bridge pipeline manager Cary Farber gives comments at the Louisianaย DNR‘s permit hearing on Februaryย 8.

Pipeline project manager Cary Farberย set a confrontational tone by citing the political climate. โ€œThe Bayou Bridge pipeline project is exactly the type of pipeline project that our new president โ€” President Trump โ€” envisioned when he issued the recent presidential orders for infrastructure and pipeline development for our country,โ€ heย said.

Farber was followed by politicians who spoke in support of the project, including former Sen. Mary Landrieu.ย Her testimony reiterated what the politicians who spoke in favor of the project before her said: Pipelines are the safest mode to transport oil and gas, and that the Bayou Bridge pipeline was good for Louisianaโ€™sย economy.

Pipeline opponents heckle former Sen. Mary Landrieu for her support of the Bayou Bridge pipeline
Opponents of the pipeline heckling former Sen. Maryย Landrieu.ย 

Women sit in the stands at the permit hearing, holding signs opposing the Bayou Bridge pipeline
Pipeline opponents at the February 8 permit hearing, many of whom also took to calling themselves โ€œwater protectorsโ€ in the way that those opposing the Dakota Access pipeline at Standing Rock haveย been.ย 

Joseph Lopinto, an attorney from the Jefferson Parish Sheriffโ€™s office who spoke on behalf of the National Sheriffsโ€™ Association,ย seemed to relish enraging projectย opponents. โ€œThe federal government failed to provide local law enforcement [in Standing Rock, North Dakota] with support to control hostile, often violent protestersย that caused millions of dollars in property damage and shot at law enforcement officers,โ€ย he said, while the pipelineย opponents yelled so loudย his testimony wasย almostย inaudible.ย 

โ€œWe donโ€™t want the same thing occurring here in Louisiana,โ€ heย said.ย 

Pipeline Opponents Pushย Back

Cherri Foytlin, director of the environmental advocacy group Bold Louisiana, objected to Lopintoโ€™s claim that water protectors shot at anyone in Standing Rock, saying that was a lie. She also countered the claim that the pipeline was a great job creator, pointing out that โ€œthe jobs will come and go faster than it took to clean the Kalamazoo River,โ€ which is still feeling the impacts of a tar sands spill that happened six yearsย ago.ย 

She further pointed out that Energy Transfer and Sunoco had reported 69 spills in two years and alleged that they had committed human rights violations at Standing Rock. โ€œWe are rewarding terrorist [sic] to this country,โ€ Foytlin said before issuing a warning: ย โ€œWe will protect our water. We will protect ourย people.โ€

Kathleen Patton, wearing a t-shirt emblazoned with the word โ€œUnarmed,โ€ told the audience she wore the sameย t-shirt when she went to Standing Rock. She was moved to come to the hearing that evening by President Trumpโ€™s remark thatย the Dakota Access pipeline wasn’t controversial because he hadnโ€™t received a single phone call aboutย it.ย 

โ€œI am here, as are many of you are, to show for the historical record that people are opposed to these pipelines,โ€ Patton said.ย When she drove toย town, she passedย a welcome sign as she drove to the hearing that said โ€œWelcome to the Bayou La Fouche Watershed, ours to protectโ€ andย urged the DNR to do just that, protect the water by rejecting the permitย request.ย 

Jessica Parfait of the United Houma Nation raised concerns about possible damage to sites that hold archeological significance to her tribe along the Bayou Bridge projectย route.

Environmental groups called for an environmental impact study and more stringent construction standards for the pipeline. Andย others raised questions about what product would be moved in the pipeline, wondering if it would only be heavy and light crude, as the permit application states, or whether the pipeline also would be permitted to transport Canadian tarย sands.ย 

Pastor Joseph from St. James, where the pipeline will end, said his community is already plagued with pollution problems. โ€œPeople are sick from the smell of the oil tanks. People are sick from the plants that are already there,โ€ heย said.ย 

Future of theย Pipeline

After the meeting Patrick Courreges, communications director for DNR, told DeSmog that he was encouraged by the turnout. โ€œThe public comments can play a role in the shape permits take,โ€ heย said.ย 

When I asked if DNR had rejected a pipeline permit request in the last ten years, Courreges said heโ€™d have to get back to me on that. He explained that projects are more likely to be withdrawn than rejected.ย ย 

Both sides drew their battle lines on the Bayou Bridge pipeline deeper in the sand at the second permit hearing. Butย at least one claim made at the hearing already is no longerย true.

A representative from Philips 66 stated that the company currently has 18,000 miles of pipeline โ€œthat move product across this country and do it safely every singleย day.โ€

The pipeline explosion in Paradis on Feb 9 nixed the companyโ€™s safetyย claim.ย 

Cherri Foytlin and Josh Fox stand in front of the fire raging at the Phillips 66 natural gas pipeline explosion site
Bold Louisiana Director Cherri Foytlin with Gasland documentary filmmaker Josh Fox, at the site of the Phillips 66 pipeline explosion on Febย 10.ย 

Darryl Malek-Wiley gives comment at the permit hearing
Darryl Malek-Wiley, speaking on behalf of the Sierra Club, asked DNR not to help Texas millionaires become Texas billionaires by approving the Bayou Bridgeย pipeline.ย 

Main image: Opponents of the Bayou Bridge pipeline walk toward the entrance of Louisiana DNRโ€™s permit hearing on Februaryย 8.

Julie-Dermansky-022
Julie Dermansky is a multimedia reporter and artist based in New Orleans. She is an affiliate scholar at Rutgers Universityโ€™s Center for the Study of Genocide and Human Rights. Visit her website at www.jsdart.com.

Related Posts

on

UCP pledges to abandon the provinceโ€™s net zero targets, and remove the designation of CO2 as a pollutant.

UCP pledges to abandon the provinceโ€™s net zero targets, and remove the designation of CO2 as a pollutant.
on

Speaking at the UCP annual general meeting, the Premier took shots at the federal government and vowed not to โ€œbudge an inch.โ€

Speaking at the UCP annual general meeting, the Premier took shots at the federal government and vowed not to โ€œbudge an inch.โ€
on

One candidate has sworn off taking money from regulated companies

One candidate has sworn off taking money from regulated companies
on

Findings by InfluenceMap highlight mismatch between communication agencies' climate pledges, and their work on behalf of major polluters.

Findings by InfluenceMap highlight mismatch between communication agencies' climate pledges, and their work on behalf of major polluters.