On Tuesday, a federal judge in Washington, D.C. halted construction on a portion of the contentious Dakota Access Bakken oil pipeline route, which falls on federal land. However, because the court lacked jurisdiction, heย ruled that construction could continue on the area*ย that the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe had recently identified as sacred tribal burial ground, a site that was bulldozed over the Labor Day weekend by pipeline constructionย crews.
Discovered only recently,ย the ancient site’s location was filed just oneย day* before its destruction and was awaiting review by the state historic preservationย office.
At the judgeโs request, Dakota Access LLC agreed to halt construction on only a small area in contention until the judge issues a separate ruling this week on a preliminary injunction motion brought by the tribe over theย pipeline.
The tribe has been locked in a legal fight against Dakota Access and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers over a pipeline that would cross sacred sites and potentially affect water that the tribe depends on. The DAPL pipelineโs full path extends across North and South Dakota, Iowa, andย Illinois.
Standing Rock Sioux Chairman David Archambault II issued a statement saying the tribe was โdisappointed that the U.S. District Courtโs decision does not prevent DAPL from destroying our sacred sites as we await a ruling on our original motion to stop construction of theย pipeline.โ
The tribe had filed an emergency motion on Sunday, September 4 for the temporary restraining order to prevent further destruction of sacredย sites.
Tuesdayโs order isnโt the end of these legal battles. Federal Judge James Boasberg is expected to rule by Friday on an injunction that would halt all pipeline-related construction near the Standing Rock Siouxย Reservation.
Violence Againstย Protesters
On Saturday morning, September 3, members of the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe and their swelling numbers of supporters were on their way to a blockade wall near the DAPL construction site to sing and give prayers as the tribe had done every day for months. They would then march back to the site of their protestย camp.
On this morning, however, when they heard the roar of bulldozers from less than a mile away from the construction site, many of them ran to intervene. What they encountered was a scene, many of them say, out of civil rights clashes of theย 1960s.
Widely circulated video first aired by Democracy Now shows pipeline security workers using attack dogs and pepper spray on demonstrators who were protesting the bulldozing of recently identified sacred sites. By the time the security team backed down and drove off, several protesters โ including a child and a pregnant woman โ were bitten by security dogs and 30 suffered from the affects of pepperย spray.ย
Photo credit: Tomasย Alejo
Local authorities called it โa riotโ and blamed the protesters, not the security detail, for the incident. North Dakota Lt. Gov. Drew Wrigley has called protests by the tribe and supporters โunlawful.โ According to NPR, the Sheriffโs department said protesters stampeded into the construction area with horses, dogs, andย vehicles.
Cody Hall, a spokesperson for the Red Warrior Camp, a group allied with the Standing Rock Sioux, was on the front line of Saturdayโs demonstration and tells DeSmog that the security companyโs claims of injuries are โabsolutelyย false.โ
โThe company says they were hit with objects which just isnโt true,โ Hall says. โWe had no weapons, just our voices. The video doesnโt lie. One female security guard laughed and said, โI told you so,โ when her dog bit one ofย us.โ
Photo credit: Tomasย Alejo
Photo credit: Tomasย Alejo
What Hall found just as disturbing was the action of the state police present. โThe state police were sitting there watching the whole scene,โ he says. โNot once did the police move toย intervene.โ
All protest actions, ongoing since April, have been peaceful, according to a tribalย spokesperson.
Dakota Access LLCโs parent company, Energy Transfer Partners, has not responded to multiple requests forย comment.
Sacred Site Destruction as Fait Accompli
A huge question looms. Why would Dakota Access bulldoze lands that it knew โ or should have known โ wereย sacred?
For the Standing Rock Sioux and their supporters, the answer is clear: to project power and make the tribe giveย up.
Following Saturdayโs bulldozing, Standing Rock Sioux Tribal Chairman Dave Archaumbault II said in a statement:
โThey did this on a holiday weekend, one day after we filed court papers identifying these sacred sites. The desecration of these ancient places has already caused the Standing Rock Sioux irreparable harm. Weโre asking the court to halt this path ofย destruction.โ
After the initial destruction Saturday, Dakota Access workers returned to the area and dug up additional grounds before dawn on Sunday, Archambaultย said.
โThese grounds are the resting places of our ancestors. The ancient cairns and stone prayer rings there cannot be replaced. In one day, our sacred land has been turned into hollowย ground.โ
Dallas Goldtooth, executive director of the Indigenous Environmental Network, released a statement on Facebookย Sunday:
โDakota Access literally plowed through a burial site and a significant ceremonial site that was JUST identified by the landowner and tribal experts a few days before. This was off-reservation. The tribe filed the discovery with a federal judge that is deciding whether to grant an injunction against Dakota Access. However โฆ in order for construction to be halted, the ND State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) had to come and officially survey the site, because it was in their jurisdiction. So what did Dakota Access do?? They plowed through the land before the SHPO could come do theirย surveys.โ
Many tribe members and their supporters believe that โ because the company knew about the sacred sites โ the bulldozers were dispatched on Saturday as an act of psychological warfare against the tribe, a way of exerting power and projecting an air ofย inevitability.
โ(The company) knows they can just bulldoze the site, destroy the evidence and pay a fine,โ Ben-Alex Dupris, a member of the Cheyenne River Sioux, whose land abuts the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation, tells DeSmog. โThey can do whatever they want, but no amount of money can bring this siteย back.โ
Waterkeeper Alliance lawyerย Daniel E. Estrin expressed shock at Dakota Access LLC and its most recentย actions:ย
โBased uponย reports from the Standing Rock Sioux Tribeโs lawyers, on Friday, September 2, the tribe provided to the federal court in Washington, D.C. specific locations along the planned pipeline route where evidence of sacred burial and other culturally important sites had been identified by experts. The tribeโs intent was obviously to protect these irreplaceable sacred sites by requesting that the court consider them in connection with a pending motion for a preliminary injunction, on which a ruling is expected by this Friday. Shockingly, the day after the tribe notified the court of the specific locations of the sacred sites โ and knowing the tribe would not be able to get into court over Labor Day weekend โ Dakota Access LLC sent work crews with bulldozers and other heavy equipment out to the very locations that had been identified by the tribe and physically destroyed them. If these allegations against the pipeline company are true,ย in the 23 years that I have practiced and taught environmental law, I have never seen such an outrageous, unconscionable, and bad faith abuse of the legal process. It also plainly demonstrates that contrary to the pipeline companyโs spin, it is the company, not the tribe, that is the aggressorย here.โ
Two Years of โSteamrollingโ theย Tribe
Tribal members began protesting the pipeline construction as early as April 2016, when a group of young tribal members from Standing Rock ran from North Dakota to Washington, D.C., to present a petition in protest of the construction of Energy Transfer Partners’ Dakota Accessย pipeline.
On August 24, the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe filed suit in federal district court in Washington, D.C., against the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, which is the primary federal agency that granted permits needed for construction of theย pipeline.
According to the tribeโs legal counsel, Earthjustice, the Army Corps took an illegally narrow view of its responsibilities to protect and engage the tribe when it granted the fast-track permits. The tribe further purports that pipeline construction was approved by the Corps without consulting the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, or conducting a full review of crucial environmental or culturalย impacts.
The lawsuit alleges that the Corps violated multiple federal statutes, including the Clean Water Act, National Historic Preservation Act, and National Environmental Policy Act, when it issued the permits, and is demanding a halt to all construction near tribal lands until a more thorough assessment of the impacts isย made.
Stephanie Tsosie, an associate attorney with Earthjustice, says the consultation process by the Army Corps of Engineers has been โinadequate atย best.โ
โSince 2014, when the pipeline construction was announced, the tribe has consistently reached out for consultation, but the Corps steamrolled the tribe throughout the process,โ Tsosie tellsย DeSmog.
โAll the tribe wanted and what we asked the judge for on August 24 was for the tribe to have a seat at the table and for the Corps to fully explore all the risks and burdens associated with theย pipeline.โ
In July, Dakota Access filed an unrelated lawsuit in federal court in Bismarck, North Dakota, against the chairman of the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, one of the tribeโs elected officials, and several other individuals. The company claimed that these individuals were interfering unlawfully with pipelineย construction.
Allies Stand Against theย Pipeline
Support and protesters have been flowing into the Sacred Stone Camp near Cannon Ball, North Dakota, since April, with a huge influx in late August. Right now there are more than five dozen Native tribes represented at the camp, which demonstrators say is starting to resemble aย village.ย
For the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, the pipeline is not just a spiritual crisis. They say it is a very real threat to the Missouri River watershed, which the tribe depends on. The entire Dakota Access pipeline would carry as much asย 570,000 barrels of Bakken crude oil daily through the Dakotas, Iowa, andย Illinois.
Farmers whose land sits in the way of the pipeline are also concerned about safety and enraged about the cavalier attitude of the company. In Iowa, farmers and allies have risked arrest to take a stand against theย pipeline.ย
Earlier this year, the Iowa Utilities Board (IUB) granted Dakota Access eminent domain across the stateโs entire pipeline route, extending through 18 counties. Fifteen Iowa landowners have filed a lawsuit against the IUB, challenging its eminent domain authority and โpublic utilityโ claims behind Energy Transfer Partnerโs seizure of their land. The same company has used a similar argument to seize land for another pipeline inย Pennsylvania.
More than two dozen environmental groups, including the Sierra Club and Greenpeace, have severely criticized federal permitting agencies involved with the entire Bakken pipeline project for failures involving insufficient public engagement and environmentalย review.
Last week, the United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues called on the U.S. and Energy Transfer Partners to respect the Standing Rock Siouxโs objections to the project and called for a โfair, independent, impartial, open and transparent process to resolve this serious issue and to avoid escalation into violence and further human rightsย abuses.โ
Cheyenne River Sioux member Ben-Alex Dupris says that the companyโs weekend actions underscore the operating procedure of Dakota Access and Energy Transferย Partners.
โThis is the mentality of the companies,โ DuPris says. โDo whatever they want, donโt worry if itโs legal, pay a fine later. This should be a red flag about the safety of the water supply. How would they respond if there is a spill? Pay a fine and keep doing what theyโre doing.โย
Photo credit: Dellย Hambleton
*This story has been updated to clarifyย details.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Stay up to date with DeSmog news and alerts