Breaking: $3 Million Jury Verdict in Texas Fracking Nuisance Case

Brendan DeMelle DeSmog
on

A jury in Dallas, TX today awarded $2.925 million to plaintiffs Bob and Lisa Parr, who sued Barnett shale fracking company Aruba Petroleum Inc. for intentionally causing a nuisance on the Parr’s property which impacted their health and ruined their drinking water.

The jury returned its 5-1 verdict confirming thatย Aruba Petroleum โ€œintentionally created a private nuisanceโ€ though its drilling, fracking and production activities at 21 gas wells near the Parrs’ Wise County home over a three-year period between 2008-2011.

Plaintiffs attorneys claimed the case is โ€œthe first fracking verdict in U.S. history.โ€ย 

The trial lasted two and a half weeks. Aruba Petroleum plans to appeal the verdict.

The pollution from natural gas production near the Parrs’ Wise County home was so bad that they were forced to flee their 40-acre property for months at a time.ย ย 

The Parrsย were represented by attorneys David Matthews, Brad Gilde and Richย Capshaw.

โ€œTheyโ€™re vindicated,โ€ said Mr. Matthews. โ€œIโ€™m really proud of the family that went through what they went through and said, โ€˜Iโ€™m not going to take it anymore. It takes guts to say, โ€˜Iโ€™m going to stand here and protect my family from an invasion of our right to enjoy our property.โ€™ Itโ€™s not easy to go through a lawsuit and have your personal life uncovered and exposed to the extent this family wentย through.โ€

According to Mr. Matthews’ blog post, the verdict included $275,000 for the Parrโ€™s property loss of market value and $2 million for past physical pain and suffering by Bob and Lisa Parr and their daughter,ย  $250,000 for future physical pain and suffering, $400,000 for past mentalย anguish.

The Parrs’ petition to the court is attached below. The case wasย Parr v. Aruba Petroleum, Inc., No. 11-1650 (Dallas Co. Ct. at Law, filed Mar.ย 2011)

ย Image credit: Fracking viaย Shutterstock

Below is a slideshow of photos taken by Julie Dermansky of fracking activities in the Barnett Shale.

Brendan DeMelle DeSmog
Brendan is Executive Director of DeSmog. He is also a freelance writer and researcher specializing in media, politics, climate change and energy. His work has appeared in Vanity Fair, The Huffington Post, Grist, The Washington Times and other outlets.

Related Posts

Analysis
on

Our editors and reporters weigh in on a year of seismic political events, and what theyโ€™re paying close attention to in 2025.

Our editors and reporters weigh in on a year of seismic political events, and what theyโ€™re paying close attention to in 2025.
on

A new lawsuit alleges toxic, radioactive waste leaked into a PA familyโ€™s water well, uncovering a regulatory abyss for miles of fracking pipelines in the state.

A new lawsuit alleges toxic, radioactive waste leaked into a PA familyโ€™s water well, uncovering a regulatory abyss for miles of fracking pipelines in the state.
Analysis
on

The celebrity investor pitched โ€˜Wonder Valleyโ€™ with no committed investors, no Indigenous partnership, and about 27 megatonnes of projected annual emissions.

The celebrity investor pitched โ€˜Wonder Valleyโ€™ with no committed investors, no Indigenous partnership, and about 27 megatonnes of projected annual emissions.
on

City Council OKs private equity firmโ€™s purchase of Entergy gas utility, undermining climate goals and jacking up prices for the cityโ€™s poorest.

City Council OKs private equity firmโ€™s purchase of Entergy gas utility, undermining climate goals and jacking up prices for the cityโ€™s poorest.