Virginia Judge Tosses Frivolous American Tradition Institute Lawsuit

Brendan DeMelle DeSmog
on

A Virginia judge issued an order today putting an end to the American Tradition Institute (ATI) frivilous lawsuit that sought to compel the University of Virginia (UVA) to release the private emails of climate scientist Michaelย Mann.

Mann, author of The Hockey Stick and the Climate Wars, posted the news on his Facebook page earlierย today:

Breaking: A victory for science! ATI loses ATI/UVa FOIA case. Judge issues final order. Affirms the universityโ€™s right to withhold scholarly communications and finds that the documents & personal emails of mine demanded by ATI were indeed protected as the university hadย contended.

I am gratified for the hard work and vigorous defense provided by the university to protect scholarly communications and raw materials of scholarship. Fortunately Virginia has a strong exemption in the public records act that protects research and scholarly endeavors. The judge ruled that the exemption under Virginiaโ€™s public records protecting information in furtherance of research on scientific and scholarly issues applies to faculty communications in furtherance of their work.

This finding is a potentially important precedent, as ATI and other industry-backed front groups continue to press their attacks on climate scientists through the abuse of public records and FOIA laws and the issuing of frivolous and vexatious demands for internal scholarly deliberations and personalย correspondences.

The ATI litigation effort was led by Competitive Enterprise Institute senior fellow Christopher Horner, well-known to DeSmog readers for his anti-scienceย activism.

For more information about the case, see here.

Here are some early reactions from around the web (not a peep from ATI yet):

Peter Sinclair – Deniers Lose. Freedom of Thought Wins. The Koch Brothers Have no Right to Read Your Mail.

Rick Piltz – Court rules for Univ. of Virginia and Michael Mann against denialist inquisition – scholarly e-mail and documents are protected communication

Joe Romm – Mann Power: Court Rules Deniers Have No Right To The Emails Of UVA Climateย Scientists

Brendan DeMelle DeSmog
Brendan is Executive Director of DeSmog. He is also a freelance writer and researcher specializing in media, politics, climate change and energy. His work has appeared in Vanity Fair, The Huffington Post, Grist, The Washington Times and other outlets.

Related Posts

on

On stage at a PragerU fundraiser, the Alberta premier, under fire for allegedly encouraging U.S. leaders to influence Canadian politics, said 'I come in peace'.

On stage at a PragerU fundraiser, the Alberta premier, under fire for allegedly encouraging U.S. leaders to influence Canadian politics, said 'I come in peace'.
on

Retired politician Barry Penner is heading a Resource Works campaign taking aim at the provinceโ€™s climate and energy policy.

Retired politician Barry Penner is heading a Resource Works campaign taking aim at the provinceโ€™s climate and energy policy.
on

New DeSmog map shows how the leader of Canada's Conservative Party is linked to Koch Industries, Elon Musk, and former prime minister Stephen Harper.

New DeSmog map shows how the leader of Canada's Conservative Party is linked to Koch Industries, Elon Musk, and former prime minister Stephen Harper.
Series: MAGA
on

AKQA Bloomโ€™s closure comes amid calls for the ad and PR industry to stop working with fossil fuel clients.

AKQA Bloomโ€™s closure comes amid calls for the ad and PR industry to stop working with fossil fuel clients.