Warren Buffett Exposed: The Oracle of Omaha and the Tar Sands

picture-7018-1583982147.png
on

On January 23, Bloomberg News reported Warren Buffett’s Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railway (BNSF), owned by his lucrative holding company Berkshire Hathaway, stands to benefit greatly from President Barack Obamaโ€™s recent cancellation of the Keystone XL pipeline.ย 

If built, TransCanada’sย Keystone XLย (KXL)ย pipeline would carryย tar sands crude, or bitumen (โ€œdilbitโ€) from Alberta, B.C. down to Port Arthur, Texas, where it would be sold on the global export market.ย 

If not built, as revealed recently by DeSmogBlog, the grass is not necessarily greener on the other side, and could include increased levels of ecologically hazardous gas flaring in the Bakken Shale, or else many other pipeline routes moving the prized dilbit to crucial globalย markets.

Rail is among the most important infrastructure options for ensuring tar sands crude still moves to key global markets, and the industry is pursuing rail actively. But transporting tar sands crude via rail is in many ways a dirtier alternative to the KXL pipeline. โ€œRailroads too present environmental issues. Moving crude on trains produces more global warming gases than a pipeline,โ€ explained Bloomberg.

A key mover and shaker behind the push for more rail shipments is Warren Buffett, known by some as the โ€œOracle of Omahaโ€ย โ€“ of โ€œBuffett Taxโ€ fame โ€“ย and the third richest man in the world, with a net worth of $39 billion. With or without Keystone XL, Warren Buffett stands to profit enormously from multiple aspects of the Alberta Tar Sands project. He also, importantly, maintains close ties with President Barackย Obama.

Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway, BNSF and the Tarย Sands

Many eyebrows were raised in August 2008, when two of the richest men on the planet, Warren Buffett and Bill Gates, sojourned to Albertaโ€™s tar sands patch. The Calgary Herald wroteย โ€œthey took in the oilsands, apparently with awe.โ€ According to a reliable but confidential source quoted in the story, the two men โ€œvisited the booming hub to satisfy โ€˜their own curiosityโ€™ but also โ€˜with investment inย mind.โ€™โ€

And while he told the media he wasnโ€™t interested in doing so at the time of the trip, Buffett soon became a major investor in tar sands related assets. A year after his visit to the oil sands, in November 2009, Buffettโ€™s Berkshire Hathaway purchased BNSF Railway as a wholly ownedย subsidiary.

BNSF Railway is the second largest freight railroad network in North America. BNSF โ€œplans $3.9 billion in capital spending this year, an increase of 11 percent from 2011,โ€ according to a recent article byย Bloomberg.ย 

BNSF serves as a vital cog in the oil sands procurement process.ย In the November/December 2008 edition of BNSFโ€™s employee magazine, โ€œRailway,โ€ BNSF produced a piece titled, โ€œAlberta oil Sands: No sour deal.โ€ย 

The article reveals the exact role BNSF plays in the oil sands procurementย process:

Before bitumen can move through a pipeline to its destination, it must be blended with diluents (diluting agents) such as natural gasoline (not natural gas, which is a gaseous fuel) or butane, which are composed of lighter weightย hydrocarbons.

For the last two years, BNSF has been moving single carloads of diluents from U.S.refineries to the Canadian border (at Superior,Wis., Noyes, N.D., Sweetgrass, Mont., and New West minster, B.C.). The inbounds are then interchanged with Canadian railroads, then moved to Edmonton, with the final move to the oil sandsโ€™ processing center viaย pipeline.

Last year, BNSF moved about 9,000 carloads of diluents for the project, with the majority of loads originating from the Gulf Coast,California and Kansas. This year, about 12,000 carloads are anticipated toย move.

(Snip)

In addition to moving the diluents, BNSF has also transported turbines, other large machinery and pipes for use at the drillingย sites.

Not only does BNSF haul diluent materials in its freight trains bound for Alberta for tar sands oil procurement, but it also hauls pipes and pipelineย materials.

Does this include materials for the KXL Pipeline? As the prospective pipeline is not yet officially dead, this is a key question toย ask.ย 

Look no further than to BNSFโ€™s involvement in hauling the pipeline materials for the original TransCanada Keystone pipeline for crucialย evidence.

BNSF Railway and the Original Keystoneย Pipeline

A South Dakota state government document shows that BNSF and TransCanada Keystone Pipeline, LP entered into a Pipeline License Agreement on August 1, 2008. The Agreement called for BNSF to carry pipeline materials from South Dakota up to the Alberta tarย sands.

The Keystone Pipelineย was the first TransCanada pipeline carrying tar sands crude down from Alberta to Cushing,ย Oklahoma.ย 

BNSF Railway, the KXL Pipeline, and Railwayย Alternative

BNSFโ€™s ties to TransCanada are not limited to the Keystone Pipeline โ€“ they are also on the State Departmentโ€™s โ€œDistribution Listโ€ section of the Environmental Impact Statement report released in August 2011 on TransCanadaโ€™s KXL pipelineย proposal.

In its final Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), the State Department acknowledged that railway is both a key alternative to the Keystone XL and capable of hauling dilbit around North America to vital markets through 2030,ย stating,

Even in a situation where there was a total freeze in pipeline capacity for 20 years, it appears that there is sufficient capacity on existing rail tracks to accommodate shippingโ€ฆthrough at least 2030โ€ฆ[S]tatistics from the Department of Transportation,โ€ฆconservatively estimated that the existing cross-border rail lines from Canada to the U.S. could accommodate crude oil train shipments of over 1,000,000 bpd (barrels per day).

Keystone XL, if built, is expected to ship 700,000 bpd of tar sands crude to Port Arthur, Texas, according toย Bloomberg.ย Furthermore, the State Department notesย that rail transportย is also a dirtier alternative than a pipeline, due to the diesel cumbustion inherent in such aย scheme.

In addition, there would be an increase in the emission of combustion products due to the use of diesel engines which could have an adverse impact on air quality along the route selected. ย As compared to the proposed Project (Keystone XL), this alternative would have substantially greater GHG (greenhouse gas) emissions during operation due to the combustion of dieselย fuel.

BNSF is eager to haul anything and everything it can. โ€œWhatever people bring to us, we’re ready to haul [and if KXL] doesn’t happen, we’re here to haul.โ€ Krista York-Wooley, a spokeswoman for BNSF said in an interview with Bloomberg.

Buffettโ€™s financial interests in the tar sands, though, go far beyond the Keystone XL saga, and into the development of the tar sands more generally, through Berkshire Hathawayโ€™s extensive stock holdings in ConocoPhillips, ExxonMobil, and General Electric. All three corporations are big league financial players in thisย game.

Berkshire Hathaway, ConocoPhillips, ExxonMobil and Generalย Electric

An August 2011ย Fox Business storyย revealedย Buffett owns 29.1 million shares of stock in ConocoPhillips, 421,800 shares of stock in ExxonMobil, and 7.777 million shares of stock in General Electric. All three of these corporations are deeply tied to the Alberta tarย sands.

As of the Jan. 24 closing stock prices for the three corporations, this amounts to $1.73 billion worth of stock owned by Berkshire in these three Alberta oil sandsย profiteers.

ConocoPhillips’ websiteย notes that itย runs the Surmont oil sands project in Alberta. That project produces some 110,000 barrels of tar sands crude per dayย and is expected to run through 2015, according to Reuters.

ExxonMobil also has a massive stake in the Alberta Tar Sands through its Canadian subsidiary, Imperial Oil. As reported by Agence France-Presse in May 2009, ExxonMobil has plans, through its Kearl oil sands project, to begin producing 110,000 barrels of tar sands crude per day in 2012. ExxonMobil has future plans to produce over 300,000 barrels per day of dirty tar sands crude via the Kearl oilย sands.

ExxonMobil is also deeply invested in oil sands pipelines, exposed in July 2011 for carrying oil sands crude down from Alberta through Montana in one of its pipelines. The pipeline ruptured, spilling 1,000 barrels of oil into the Yellowstoneย River.

Lastly, General Electric (GE), via its GE Water & Process Technologies and GE Canada subsidiaries, also has much to gain from tar sands oil development, particularly in the area of water holding and usage, once water has been contaminated during the procurementย process.ย 

A September 2010 press release reads,

โ€œIn 2007, GE entered into a $15-million technology development program with the Alberta Water Research Institute and its research funding partners. The program aims to develop technology to improve water reuse and management in in-situ oil sands operations. GE is also actively involved in developing and proving effective technologies for treating tailings water for industrial reuse, in order to help operators improve the efficiency of theirย operations.โ€

In addition to its tight-knit financial and research relationship with the Alberta Water Research Institute, GE also owns a water treatment facility in the tar sands patch through its wholly owned subsidiary, Zenon Environmental Inc., which it purchased for $760 million in 2006. Furthermore, in September 2011, Grizzly Oil Sands ULC announced that it had chosen GEโ€™s water technology for its Algar Lake oil sands project inย Alberta.

Buffett Raises Big Bucks forย Barack

Buffett hosted an Obama fundraiserย in August 2007,ย well before the 2008 Democratic Party presidential primaries. The minimum donation wasย $500 to attend and many gave up toย $2,300.

โ€œAbout 35 people who gave the higher amount or helped raise money from others met first with Buffett and Obama in a smaller room,โ€ wrote the Los Angelesย Times.

Buffett did not limit his fundraising help in the Democratic primary process to Obama exclusively. He also hosted two multi-million dollar fundraising events for Hillary Clintonโ€™s presidential bid in 2007, one in Juneย in New York City and another in Decemberย inย Sanย Francisco.

โ€œGuests at a high-dollar fundraiser for Hillary Rodham Clinton on Tuesday were treated to cocktails, dinner and an hour-long business tutorial from billionaire Warren Buffettโ€ฆโ€ฆ[T]he fundraiserโ€ฆbrought in at least $1 million for Clintonโ€ฆ,โ€ wrote the Associated Press of the June New York Cityย fundraiser.ย 

The San Francisco event, on the other hand, drew โ€œabout 1,200 people,โ€ with tickets costing โ€œbetween $100 and $2,300.โ€ The event raised over $1 million for the Clinton for Presidentย campaign.

Once Obama won the Democratic Party nomination in May 2008, not long thereafter, Buffett endorsed Obama for President.ย A couple months later, in July, Buffett hosted a fundraiser for Obama with a required commitment of the individual maximum $28,500 per attendee, according to the New York Times.

Buffett has maintained tight ties with President Obama since his November 2008 victory, and has met with Obama to discuss economic issues on multiple occasions. Additionally, in February 2011, Obama honored Buffett with a Presidential Medal of Freedom.ย 

At the awards ceremony Obama ironically scoffed, โ€œBuffett doesnโ€™t wear โ€˜fancy tiesโ€™ or drive โ€˜fancy cars.โ€™ Instead, โ€˜you see him devoting the vast majority of his wealth to those around the world who are suffering, or sick, or in need of help,โ€™โ€ wroteย Bloomberg on the scene of the the medalย ceremony.

Most recently, Buffett has hosted Obama campaign fundraisers on September 30 in New York and October 27 in Chicago.ย Of the New York City Buffett fundraiser, CNN Money wrote, โ€œThe event will bring in a pretty penny for the campaign. The base price is $10,000, while a $35,800 donation will buy a VIP reception with Buffett, according to theย schedule.โ€

The Chicago Buffett fundraiser was similar in its extravagance, โ€œwith a ticket price of $35,800 per person,โ€ according to Bloomberg, or nearly $10,000 more than the 2010 median American income ofย $26,364.ย 

Buffett also gave a $30,800 donation to the Democratic National Committee in October 2011, according to the Center for Responsiveย Politics.

From TransCanada Corruption to BNSFย Corruption

While DeSmogBlog and many others thoroughly uncovered the corrupt ties between the Obama White House and State Department and the tar sands lobby, the additional Obama-Buffett-industry ties have gotten little play in the media untilย now.ย 

Image credit: Pete Souza, Executive Office of theย President

picture-7018-1583982147.png
Steve Horn is the owner of the consultancy Horn Communications & Research Services, which provides public relations, content writing, and investigative research work products to a wide range of nonprofit and for-profit clients across the world. He is an investigative reporter on the climate beat for over a decade and former Research Fellow for DeSmog.

Related Posts

on

Lucy von Sturmer and Duncan Meisel are building communities of creatives dedicated to preventing the advertising and public relations industry from casting polluters as climate saviours.

Lucy von Sturmer and Duncan Meisel are building communities of creatives dedicated to preventing the advertising and public relations industry from casting polluters as climate saviours.
Opinion
on

It's time to come together to collectively work through the anxiety, grief and overwhelm so many of us are experiencing.

It's time to come together to collectively work through the anxiety, grief and overwhelm so many of us are experiencing.
on

UCP pledges to abandon the provinceโ€™s net zero targets, and remove the designation of CO2 as a pollutant.

UCP pledges to abandon the provinceโ€™s net zero targets, and remove the designation of CO2 as a pollutant.
on

Speaking at the UCP annual general meeting, the Premier took shots at the federal government and vowed not to โ€œbudge an inch.โ€

Speaking at the UCP annual general meeting, the Premier took shots at the federal government and vowed not to โ€œbudge an inch.โ€