Jim Prentice, Canadaโs Environment Minister, lands in the US capital today as part of the Conservative governmentโs attempt to ride on Obamaโs green coattails on climateย change.
But he wonโt get too far with the George W. Bush playbook on climate change heโll be trying to sell the Obamaย administration.
The problem for Canada and the Harper government is that President Obama is actually planning to do something significant about the issue of climate change, while Canadaโs Conservatives continue to spend their time trying to spin a plan that will see their countryโs emissions continue toย rise.
The Globe and Mail rightly points out this morning that during Obamaโs visit to Canada two weeksย ago:
โThe President gave no indication during his trip to Canada that he was enthusiastic about Prime Minister Stephen Harperโs idea for a bilateral agreement on climateย change.โ
No kidding. Obama and his team see right through Canadaโs weak, ineffectual plan. After all itโs pretty much the plan set out by former President George W.ย Bush.
But for those in Washington who arenโt savvy to the Canadian plan, hereโs a quick rundown of the Conservative governmentโs โspin-tionaryโ on climateย change:
What theyย say:
The Canadian government says its committed to an absolute reduction in greenhouse gas emissions of 20% byย 2020.
Realityย check:
The Canadian government uses 2006 levels as the benchmark for reductions, instead of 1990 which is the internationally recognized benchmark for greenhouse gas emission reductions – and the one used by the vast majority of other countries. When you move the Conservativeโs numbers back to 1990 levels, there is a rise in emissions of around 2% byย 2020.
What theyย say:
The Canadian government promises an absolute reduction in greenhouseย gas.
Realityย check:
The Canadian government actually plans to measure greenhouse gas emission reductions through โcarbon intensityโ targets. This means that reductions are measured by the decrease in theย amount of greenhouse gas that is emitted per unit of energy – a standard that still allows total emissions to increase. For example, Suncor Energy, one of the largest companies in the Alberta oil sands, once announced that it had reduced its carbon intensity by 51 per cent between 1990 and 2006. However, thanks to huge increases in production – the companyโs absolute emissions increased by 131 per cent over the sameย period.
These are the two very big fundamental differences between Canadaโs plan and the plan being proposed by President Obama who has committed to reducing absolute US greenhouse gas emissions by 15% by 2020, based on 1990 levels. No PR spin or fancy tricks on the ledger for Obama, just a straightenย commitment.
While many are arguing that Obamaโs plan does not go far enough, his honesty is refreshing after years of baffle gab and delay from the former White Houseย administration.
Good luck in Washington this week Minister Prentice, youโre going to need it if you plan on sticking George W. Bushโs greenhouse gas inaction plan under the noses of this newย administration.
This month weโre giving away FREE copies Keith Farnishโs new book Times Up: an uncivilzed solution to a globalย crisis.
Go here to find out more details about DeSmogBlogโs monthly bookย give-away.
Subscribe to our newsletter
Stay up to date with DeSmog news and alerts